The smell of burned rubber

Race car tracks bank their turns so that cars can go faster without sliding off the track . Consider a banked race car track. The track is in the shape of a circle of radius 300 m 300~\mbox{m} and the track is banked at an angle of 2 0 20^\circ with respect to the horizontal. The maximum speed of race cars around this track is v b v_b . The maximum speed of race cars around a non-banked (flat) track of the same radius is v f v_f . What is v b / v f v_b/v_f ?

Details and assumptions

  • The coefficient of static friction μ \mu between car tires and the track can be taken to be one. Tires don't like to slide.


The answer is 1.46.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

6 solutions

Deep Chanda
May 20, 2014

From the forces acting on the vehicle in a banked curve where N = Normal from the ground ; F = Frictional force; N cos θ F sin θ = m g N\cos\theta-F\sin\theta=mg N sin θ + F cos θ = m v b 2 r N\sin \theta +F\cos\theta=\frac{ {m \ v_{b}^2}}{r} F = μ N F = μN Solving for v we get v b = r g ( t a n θ + μ ) ( 1 μ t a n θ ) v_{b}= \sqrt{\frac{ rg(tanθ+μ)}{(1-μtanθ)}} For a non-banked (flat) track of the same radius we get v f = r g v_{f}= \sqrt {rg} The ratio v b v f = ( t a n θ + μ ) ( 1 μ t a n θ ) \frac{ { v_{b}}}{v_{f}}= \sqrt{\frac{ (tanθ+μ)}{(1-μtanθ)}} According to the question θ = 20 , μ = 1 \theta=20,~μ=1 So ,we get v b v f = 1.464 \frac{ { v_{b}}}{v_{f}}= 1.464

Upendra Singh
Nov 25, 2013

Friends

We will solve this by drawing a free body diagram(FBD) of the car on a banked as well as a flat road.

To start with...

Forces acting on the car are-

  1. Weight of the car = mg (downward)
  2. Centrifugal force = m v 2 r \frac{mv^{2}}{r} (outward)
  3. Force of friction = μ \mu N (inward)

where, m=mass of car and N=normal reaction on car

Friction force is inwards because the car has a tendency to slide outwards under the action of the centrifugal force.To oppose this motion, friction force is inwards.

The FBD of car is-

Alt Alt

The figure is self-explanatory.

Now we proceed further...

For banked road

Summation of forces parallel to incline = 0

This gives N=mgcos θ \theta + m v b 2 r \frac{mv_b^{2}}{r} sin θ \theta

Summation of forces perpendicular to incline = 0

This gives m v b 2 r \frac{mv_b^{2}}{r} cos θ \theta =mgsin θ \theta + μ \mu N

Putting value of N from above equation in this, we get

m v b 2 r \frac{mv_b^{2}}{r} cos θ \theta =mgsin θ \theta + μ \mu mgcos θ \theta + μ \mu m v b 2 r \frac{mv_b^{2}}{r} sin θ \theta

Cancelling out 'm' on both sides, we get

v b 2 r \frac{v_b^{2}}{r} cos θ \theta =gsin θ \theta + μ \mu gcos θ \theta + μ \mu v b 2 r \frac{v_b^{2}}{r} sin θ \theta

=> v b 2 r \frac{v_b^{2}}{r} (cos θ \theta - μ \mu sin θ \theta )=g(sin θ \theta + μ \mu cos θ \theta ) ----- i \boxed{i}

For flat road

Summation of forces along horizontal road = 0

This gives m v f 2 r \frac{mv_f^{2}}{r} = μ \mu mg

=> v f 2 r \frac{v_f^{2}}{r} = μ \mu g (By cancelling 'm' on both sides) ----- i i \boxed{ii}

Putting value of ' μ \mu g' from eqn-ii in eqn-i, we get

μ \mu v b 2 r \frac{v_b^{2}}{r} (cos θ \theta - μ \mu sin θ \theta )= v f 2 r \frac{v_f^{2}}{r} (sin θ \theta + μ \mu cos θ \theta )

=> v b 2 v f 2 \frac{v_b^{2}}{v_f^{2}} =(sin θ \theta + μ \mu cos θ \theta )/ μ \mu (cos θ \theta - μ \mu sin θ \theta )=(sin θ \theta +cos θ \theta )/(cos θ \theta -sin θ \theta ) (because it is given that μ \mu =1)

Now put value of θ \theta ,i.e, θ \theta =20 (Given)

We get,

v b v f \frac{v_b}{v_f} =1.464 A n s \boxed{Ans}

You may know that......the centripetal force is not mentioned.....in FBD........as it originates from other forces. (which is frictional force and normal reaction is this case).

Led Tasso - 7 years, 6 months ago

The following claim is proved first.

The maximum speed of a car which travels on a banked track with angle of inclination A and radius r is given by sqrt(rg(sinA + UcosA)/(cosA-UsinA)), where U is the friction of static co-efficient between the tyre and the track.

Proof:- Let v be the maximum velocity and the normal force acting on the car be R. The forces acting on the car in the horizontal direction are:- i) Centrifgual force (mv^2/r) outwards ii) Rsin(A) inwards iii) URcos(A) inwards.

From Newton's 2nd law of motion, mv^2/r= Rsin(A) + URcos(A).....(1)

Now consider the vertical forces acting on the car. They are:- i) Rcos(A) upwards ii) URsin(A) downwards iii) mg downwards (where mg is the weight of the car)

From Newton's 2nd law of motion, Rcos(A)= Usin(A) + mg .....(2)

Solving equations (1) and (2) for v gives us v= sqrt(rg(sinA + UcosA)/(cosA-UsinA))

Here U=1, A= 20 degree.

So, vb= sqrt(rg(sin(20 deg)+ cos(20 deg))/(cos(20 deg)-sin(20 deg))

On a flat track, A= 0

So, vf= sqrt(rg(sin(0)+ cos(0)/(cos(0)-sin(0))= sqrt(rg)

So, vb/vf= sqrt((sin(20 deg)+ cos(20 deg))/(cos(20 deg)-sin(20 deg)) = ~~ 1.464 Picture at http://s7.postimage.org/vx1nmm12z/image.png

Sagar Chand
May 20, 2014

Let N be normal reaction by ground on car let v be max velocity

along y-axis Ncos20 = μNsin20 + mg mg = N(cos20 -μsin20) .......(i)

along x-axis (mv^2)/r = Nsin20 + μNcos20 (mv^2)/r = N(sin20 + μcos20) .....(ii)

(ii)/(i)

(sin20 +μcos20)/(cos20 - μsin20) = (v^2)/(rg)

(tan20 + μ)/(1-μtan20) = v^2/rg

v^2 = rg(tan20 + μ)/(1-μtan20)

Let u be max velocity

μmg = mu^2/r u^2 = μrg

(v^2)/(u^2) = (tan20 + μ)/μ(1-μtan20)

on putting values we can get v/u

Michael Tong
Nov 24, 2013

This is a simple banked curve with friction problem. The key derivation involved is the following formula:

F n e t = F c F_{net} = F_c

F n e t = tan θ + μ 1 μ tan θ m g = m v 2 r F_{net} = \frac {\tan \theta + \mu}{1 - \mu \tan \theta} mg = \frac {mv^2}{r}

And we know that for a flat surface the equation is v 2 = g r v^2 = gr . The rest of the problem is trivial number chugging.

The derivation is left as an exercise (plus, it's a bit messy to write out). Hint: The frictional force will act in a downwards direction relative to the ramp. Thus, it will have a negative y-component and a positive x-component. Find the magnitude of the Normal force using the fact that F y = 0 \sum F_y = 0 .

First let us define all the forces acting on the bank and the car :

  • F n F_n = mg
  • F f r F_fr = μ F n F_n
  • F c F_c = m v 2 r \frac{mv^{2}}{r}

These forces can be breakdown into x (horizontal) and y (vertical) components. In vertical direction we write :

  • F n F_n cosθ = mg + F f r F_fr sinθ
  • F n F_n cosθ - μ F n F_n sinθ = mg
  • F n F_n = m g c o s θ μ s i n θ \frac{mg}{cosθ - μsinθ}

Now, in horizontal direction we write :

  • F n F_n sinθ + F f r F_fr cosθ
  • F n F_n sinθ + μ F n F_n cosθ
  • F n F_n (sinθ + μcosθ)

Substitute the value of F n F_n from the vertical direction:

  • m g c o s θ μ s i n θ \frac{mg}{cosθ - μsinθ} (sinθ + μcosθ)
  • ( m g ) ( s i n θ + μ c o s θ ) c o s θ μ s i n θ \frac{(mg)(sinθ + μcosθ)}{cosθ - μsinθ}

Since F n F_n = F c F_c

  • ( m g ) ( s i n θ + μ c o s θ ) c o s θ μ s i n θ \frac{(mg)(sinθ + μcosθ)}{cosθ - μsinθ} = m v 2 r \frac{mv^{2}}{r}

    Cancel out both mass (m) :

  • v 2 v^{2} = ( r g ) ( s i n θ + μ c o s θ ) c o s θ μ s i n θ \frac{(rg)(sinθ + μcosθ)}{cosθ - μsinθ}

  • v = ( r g ) ( s i n θ + μ c o s θ ) c o s θ μ s i n θ \sqrt{\frac{(rg)(sinθ + μcosθ)}{cosθ - μsinθ}}

So by substituting all the values :

  • v b v_b = ( 300 × 9.8 ) ( s i n 20 + ( 1 ) c o s 20 ) c o s 20 ( 1 ) s i n 20 \sqrt{\frac{(300 \times 9.8)(sin20 + (1)cos20)}{cos20 - (1)sin20}}
  • v b v_b = 79.40
  • v f v_f = ( 300 × 9.8 ) ( s i n 0 + ( 1 ) c o s 0 ) c o s 0 ( 1 ) s i n 0 \sqrt{\frac{(300 \times 9.8)(sin0 + (1)cos0)}{cos0 - (1)sin0}}
  • v b v_b = 14 15 \sqrt{15}

So for v b v f \frac{v_b}{v_f} : v b v f \frac{v_b}{v_f} = 79.40 14 15 \frac{79.40}{14 \sqrt{15}}

  • v b v f \frac{v_b}{v_f} = 1.46 \boxed{1.46}

typo : v f v_f = 14 15 \sqrt{15}

Rey Francis Famulagan - 7 years, 6 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...