Theorem:
Any vehicle which can travel at infinite speed can also travel (backwards or forwards) in time.
Corollary: Any vehicle which can travel at a reasonably high speed can also travel (backwards or forwards) in time.
Solve the problem given after the proof.
Proof of theorem: Consider cities A, B, C, D… located in consecutive 1-hour time zones around the world.
Suppose you are at city A at 7 am on 7th June. You get into your vehicle and instantaneously travel to city B at infinite velocity, and arrive there instantaneously. Now you are 1 hour in the future, and you have to set your clock to 8 am. Travelling further, at city C, you are at 9 am, at city D at 10 am and so on. At city R, it is midnight, and sure enough, at city S, it is 1 am the next day, 8th June.
So if you instantaneously travel around the world at infinite speed from west to east and come back to city A, you are 1 whole day into the future, i.e. it is 7 am on 8 June instead of 7 June. If you make N trips around the world at infinite speed (i.e. instantaneously), from west to east, then you are N days in the future.
If you made the trips from east to west, i.e. from city D to C to B to A, you would set your clock 1 hour back at each city, i.e. 7 am, 6 am, 5 am…midnight previous date, … until you arrive back at city A 1 day in the past. If you make N trips around the world instantaneously from east to west, you would be N days in the past.
In order to convince yourself that the above is actually true, consider that there actually is something called an International Date Line, where the date actually changes. When you cross over the date line, you are one day in the past or future, depending on the direction in which you cross it. So if you go around the world instantaneously and cross the international date line N times in the same direction, then you are actually N days in the past or future.
Superman actually did this in one of his movies, and this proof shows that that was not fiction, but a scientific fact.
Proof of Corollary:
Suppose you have a vehicle which does not have infinite speed, but is still very fast, and you can travel around the world in 5 minutes. Now, starting at 7 am on 7 June and going from west to east, around the world in 5 minutes and coming back to city A, the time would be 7 am on 8 June, so I go from 7 am, 7 June to 7 am, 8 June in 5 minutes. So, other than the 5 minutes which I have spent, I have traveled 23 hrs, 55 minutes into the future. With each of N rounds around the world at this speed, I travel 23 hrs 55 minutes further into the future.
Now suppose, I have a still slower vehicle, which travels around the world in 23 hrs, 55 minutes. Starting at 7 am on 7 June at city A, and traveling west to east, it would take me 23 hrs, 55 min to reach city A again, where the time would be 7 am, 8 June, so other than the 23 hrs 55 min which I have spent, I have traveled 5 minutes into the future. Travelling around the world at this speed, with each revolution, I travel 5 minutes into the future, so with N revolutions, I am 5N minutes in the future, where N can be as large as you want. With N revolutions from east to west, I can be 5 N minutes in the past, where N can be as large as you want.
This phenomenon is actually experienced by millions of travelers in daily life. If a traveler flies from London to New York, he has to set his clock 5 hours back (say from 10 am to 5 am), so he goes back to the past, and re-lives the same 5 hours of his life which he had already lived before. He could keep flying westward, keep going to the past, and re-living the same hours again and again, any number of times. Similarly, a traveler who flies eastward, goes to the future (say from 5 am to 10 am) and continues his life from that point in the future, without ever having lived the intervening hours.
Consider the above proofs carefully and choose one option.
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
If the possibility of time travel is false, then we need to explain what was the mistake in the proofs given.
The key to this is to realize that in a single proof, both phenoena - (i) going one hour at a time backwards or forwards in 24 time zones and (ii) going one day backwards or forwards when crossing the International date line work together, and in opposite directions, so that after going around the world and coming back to point A, a person is neither one day back or forward in time. If he can go around the world instantaneously starting at A at 7AM on 7 June, then after going around the world in either direction, he will reach point A gain at the same instant when he started, ie at 7AM on 7 June.
If he moved FORWARD by 1 day in going through 24 times zones from west to east, then at the same time, he also went BACK by 1 day when he crossed the international date line, so in total he neither moved forward nor backward.
The given proof very skillfully uses the time zones and the international date line as two separate proofs, both separately showing that the person is travelling in time, but does not consider their cumulative effect, nor does it consider that the effect of crossing the date line is OPPOSITE to that of crossing the time zones, and they cancel each other out.
If you were to travel around the world in 5 minutes, then you would reach point A again in 5 minutes after you started out, ie at 7:05 on 7 June. So all you have done is move 5 minutes forward in your life in NORMAL Time, with no time travel.
The statement that if you travel from London to NewYork, you reset your clock from say from 10AM to 5 AM, so you travel back to the past and re-live the same hours of your life all over again also needs some explanation.
Actually, while it is true that by New York time, you live 5 AM to 10 AM (seemingly all over again), but in actual fact, you are living the next 5 hours of your life. You first lived 5 AM to 10 AM according to London time once only, and if for any reason you do not reset your clock and keep it to London time, then you will live the next few hours of your life. If you reset your clock to New York time, then the next thing you will do will be to live your life from 5 AM to 10 AM according to New York time, which is not a repeat of the same hours of your life that you lived before, but which is actually living the next 5 hours of your life.
In fact you never lived any 5 hours of your life twice according to New York time, nor did you live any 5 hours of your life twice according to London time. It only appears that you are living the same hours again because you are changing your time reference.
Similarly when going back from New York to London, you are not actually jumping to a point in future time and continuing your life from there, but it appears that way only because you changed your time reference.
An example: Suppose I change my time reference or "definition" of 0 AD to mean the year 2000. So now according to this new definition, I am in the year 2014 or 14 AD. Does this mean I have travelled back in time by 2000 years? Obviously not because it is only a change in my definition. Actually I am just going forward with the next few years of my life in NORMAL time, regardless of whether I choose to call it 2014.... or 14AD....