a 1 × b 1 = a × b 1
Knowing the above, can we also say there are real numbers a and b such that a 1 + b 1 = a + b 1 ?
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
Suppose there exist real a , b such that a 1 + b 1 = a + b 1 . Clearly, a , b = 0 .
First, suppose a b > 0 . There are two cases:
a > 0 , b > 0 : a < 0 , b < 0 : ⟹ ⟹ a + b > a a + b < a ⟹ ⟹ a + b 1 < a 1 < a 1 + b 1 a 1 + b 1 < a 1 < a + b 1 → ← → ←
Next, suppose a b < 0 ; WLOG, let a < 0 , b > 0 . There are two cases:
∣ a ∣ > ∣ b ∣ : ∣ a ∣ < ∣ b ∣ : ⟹ ⟹ a + b 1 < 0 < a 1 + b 1 a 1 + b 1 < 0 < a + b 1 → ← → ←
Therefore our original assumption must have been false.
Ah, a very simple case-by-case approach. Thanks for sharing!
First note that we will require that a , b = 0 and a = − b . Then
a 1 + b 1 = a + b 1 ⟹ a b a + b = a + b 1 ⟹ ( a + b ) 2 = a b ⟹ a 2 + 2 a b + b 2 = a b ⟹ a 2 + b 2 = − a b .
Method 1: By the AM-GM inequality a 2 + b 2 ≥ 2 ∣ a b ∣ > ∣ a b ∣ ≥ − a b , and thus a 2 + b 2 = − a b has no real solutions.
Method 2: Divide a 2 + b 2 = − a b through by b 2 to end up with ( b a ) 2 + b a + 1 = 0 , which is quadratic in b a with solutions b a = 2 − 1 ± i 3 , which are complex, implying that at least one of a , b must be complex, i.e., a 1 + b 1 = a + b 1 has no real solutions a , b .
Note: From the 2nd method we have b a = e i 3 2 π and b a = e i 3 4 π as principal roots, so for any non-zero real b we have a = b e i 3 2 π or a = b e i 3 4 π .
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
The expression a 1 + b 1 = a + b 1 can be rearranged to a 2 + a b + b 2 = 0 (for a = 0 , b = 0 , and a = − b ).
Using the quadratic equation to solve for a gives a discriminant of − 3 b 2 , which is negative for all real values of b , which means a has no real solutions for any real value of b .