Trinity

Geometry Level 4

A unit radius sphere split into three uniform spherical wedges ( regular trigonal hosohedron ) all have an area to volume ratio of A A . The same unit radius sphere partitioned into 3 solid sections by 2 parallel planes with both spherical caps ( calotte ) each having a height of 0.7458904 units all have an area to volume ratio of B B . If A = B 0.745890 4 2 A = B - 0.7458904^2 , find A A to 2 decimal places.


The answer is 5.25.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

K T
Jul 16, 2019

For the regular trigonal hosohedron , we can think of three planes intersecting the ball x 2 + y 2 + z 2 1 x^2+y^2+z^2 \leq 1 :

  • Plane 1: y=z
  • Plane 2: x=z
  • Plane 3: x=y.

Alternatively, or maybe complementary to that, we can also think of sets of points that are in each of the three parts:

  • Part X consists of all points of the ball that have x>y and x>z
  • Part Y has all points where y>x and y>z
  • Part Z has all points where z>x and z>y

So each of the 3 parts has spherical area 4πr^2/3 (one third of the total sphere exterior) and planar area πr^2 (two half disks: one half on each of the two interior faces).

So the total area for each of the three parts is 7 π 3 \frac{7π}{3} . The volume of such a part is 4 π 9 \frac{4π}{9} . And the ratio A = Area Volume = 63 12 = 5.25 A = \frac{\text{Area}}{\text{Volume}} = \frac{63}{12}=\boxed{5.25} , which is the requested answer already. Note that it is an exact answer.

So what about the calotte and the number B?

I will assume that the cuts are parallel to the x-y- plane. For the spherical area we want to integrate z = z 1 z 2 d A \int_{z=z_1}^{z_2}dA . The integrand dA is a thin ring at height z. Let φ be the angle between the z-axis and the line connecting the origin to the ring, then the radius of the ring is r = sin φ r=\sin φ . The surface dA of the ring is at an angle 90-φ with the z-axis and therefore has area d A = 2 π r d z cos ( 90 φ ) = 2 π sin φ d z sin φ = 2 π d z dA=\frac{2πrdz}{\cos (90-φ)}=\frac{2π\sinφ dz}{\sin φ} =2πdz . So spherical area is just equal to z 1 z 2 2 π d z = 2 π ( z 2 z 1 ) \int_{z_1}^{z_2}2πdz=2π(z_2-z_1) .

A cap of height h (h is the distance from the intersecting plane to the top of the unit sphere) has spherical area 2πh and planar area ( 1 ( 1 h ) 2 ) π = ( 2 h h 2 ) π (1-(1-h)^2)π=(2h-h^2)π , so Area c a p = ( 4 h h 2 ) π \text{Area}_{cap} = (4h-h^2)π

The mid section between the caps has spherical area 4 π ( 1 h ) 4π(1-h) and planar area ( 4 h 2 h 2 ) π (4h-2h^2)π so Area m i d = ( 4 2 h 2 ) π \text{Area}_{mid} = (4-2h^2)π

The volume of a cap is found easily from 1 h 1 π r 2 d x \int_{1-h}^1 πr^2dx with r 2 = 1 x 2 r^2=1-x^2 . and is Volume c a p = π ( h 2 1 3 h 3 ) \text{Volume}_{cap} = π(h^2-\frac13h^3)

The volume of the mid section is Volume m i d = 1 3 π ( 4 6 h 2 + 2 h 3 ) \text{Volume}_{mid} =\frac13π(4 - 6h^2+2h^3)

The area to volume ratio of a cap is Ratio c a p = 4 h h 2 h 2 1 3 h 3 \text{Ratio}_{cap}=\frac{4h-h^2}{h^2-\frac13h^3} The area to volume ratio of the mid section is Ratio m i d = 3 ( 4 2 h 2 ) 4 6 h 2 + 2 h 3 \text{Ratio}_{mid}=\frac{3(4-2h^2)}{4 - 6h^2+2h^3}

Setting these ratios equal and solving numerically gives the value h = 0.7459 h^*=0.7459 , for which the area-to-volume for each of the three slices is equal. This ratio B B is found by setting h = h h=h^* in either ratio expression:

Ratio c a p ( h ) = Ratio m i d ( h ) = B = 5.806 \text{Ratio}_{cap}(h^*)=\text{Ratio}_{mid}(h^*)=B = 5.806

Note that h h^* and B B are approximations.

And indeed, it turns out that B h 2 = 5.25 = A B - h^2 = 5.25 = A

Elegant explanation and execution for the solution of this problem.

W Rose - 1 year, 10 months ago

Thank you. I feel the spherical area of the calotte parts may need a bit more explication. (Just remembered the fact that the area is proportional to Δx). I'll give that another look shortly. Edit: just added the paragraph 'I will assume...'

K T - 1 year, 10 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...