Given a circle of radius 1 , the locus of all P such that there are points A , B , C on the circle such that
∠ A P B = ∠ B P C = ∠ C P A = 9 0 °
is a surface of a solid that has a volume V . Find ⌊ 1 0 0 V ⌋
This is a 3D generalization of the fact that the locus of all P on a circle makes a right triangle with the diameter.
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
This is a cool problem. I think one simpler way of doing this is to exploit symmetry. Let there be the case where A,B,C are vertices of an inscribed equilateral triangle. Applying the given angle rule forms a regular tetrahedron with base length 3 and slant length 3 / 2 . We use the Pythagoras theorem to calculate the height, which is 1 / 2 . Now this is the maximum value in the z-axis. By symmetry will lead to the desired equation of the solid x 2 + y 2 + ( 1 / 2 z ) 2 = 1 .
Use the prismoidal formula (common hack for solids like these), we evaluate:
6 2 2 ( 0 + 4 π + 0 ) = 2 . 9 6 1 9
Let A P , B P , C P denote the legs of the tetrahedron , H orthocentre of acute △ A B C , O ( 0 , 0 , 0 ) circumcentre of △ A B C and R its circumradius, P ′ projection of apex P onto △ A B C .
A P ⊥ B P ⊥ C P ⇒ A P ⊥ B C P and B P ⊥ A C P ⇒ A P ⊥ B C and B P ⊥ A C ⇒ A B C P orthogonal ⇒ P ′ = H
A P = A H + H P and B P = B H + H P
A P ⋅ B P = 0 ⇒ A H ⋅ B H = − ∣ H P ∣ 2
Let
D
be a foot of altitude from
A
on
B
C
and
G
intersection of line of altitude and the circumcircle.
∣
A
H
⋅
B
H
∣
=
A
H
×
H
D
⇒
H
P
2
=
A
H
×
H
D
Using a fact that
H
D
=
D
G
for any triangle and any vertex and by intersecting chords theorem
A
H
×
H
D
=
(
R
2
−
O
H
2
)
/
2
⇒
H
P
2
=
(
R
2
−
O
H
2
)
/
2
⇒
2
z
2
=
1
−
(
x
2
+
y
2
)
Using formula for the volume of an elipsoid:
V
=
3
2
4
π
R
3
=
2
.
9
6
1
9
2
1
9
5
8
7
7
2
More info on
tetrahedrons
and
orthocentre
Note:
H P has similar formula as the polar circle
As a "side effect" of this exercise the following formulas can be easily derived:
A P 2 = A H × A D
D P 2 = H D × A D = C D × B D where DP is height of △ B C P
A B 2 = A H × A D + B H × B E - another take on Pythagorean. E is a foot of altitude from B on A C
m a 2 = A H × A D + 4 a 2 where m a is a median from A .
m a 2 + m b 2 + m c 2 = 2 3 ( A P 2 + B P 2 + C P 2 )
The surface of the locus of P has the equation
x 2 + y 2 + 2 z 2 = 1
which means it has the volume of 2 1 of that of an unit sphere, or 2 . 9 6 1 9 2 . . . . so that the answer would be 2 9 6 .
Volume of an Elipsoid , a 2 x 2 + b 2 y 2 + c 2 z 2 = 1 , w i t h s e m i − a x i s a , b , c i s g i v e n b y V = 3 4 ∗ π ∗ a ∗ b ∗ c
W e h a v e a = b = 1 , c = 1 / 2 1
Can you explain how you arrived at that equation?
Log in to reply
Okay, we make use of the following, given the sides a , b , c of triangle Δ A B C , that has area A
R = 4 A a b c
where R = 1 is the circumradius
O H 2 = 9 R 2 − ( a 2 + b 2 + c 2 )
where O H is the distance between the circumcenter and the orthocenter, and
z = 2 1 4 A 1 ( − a 2 + b 2 + c 2 ) ( a 2 − b 2 + c 2 ) ( a 2 + b 2 − c 2 )
where z is the height of the apex of the trirectangular corner After considerable ado, it can be shown that
O H 2 + 2 z 2 = 1
which leads to the equation
x 2 + y 2 + 2 z 2 = 1
It should be noted that the projection of the apex point P on the plane is the orthocenter of the triangle Δ A B C .
I"m sure there's a more elegant way to prove this, maybe someone else can offer one? If not, I'll come back to this later.
Coming right up, Calvin. Let me find the time to do it.
Moved my comment to the solution posted.
Log in to reply
The other two solution above assumes that the solid is an Ellipsoid. Thanks for giving the proof that it is an ellipsoid and its formula. Your proof is very simple and your diagrams help a lot.
How did u get 2.96192 answer sir. There is no given area in the problem.
Log in to reply
The volume of an unit sphere is 3 4 π . The locus of the point P is an oblate spheroid which has one semi-axis of 2 1 , so that the volume would be 2 1 3 4 π = 2 . 9 6 1 9 2 . . . . Probably most people who solve this realize that P must be 2 1 at the center above the unit circle, and guess that it's a single surface, that of an oblate spheroid. But proving that it's a single surface is actually not easy to do.
yes i agree with jeff deb
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
Imgur
STRATEGY: For any two such A and B select a coordinate frame as shown. Then repeatedly use " angle in a semicircle = 90° " to get the locus of P in XZ plane. Finally, by symmetry get the surface as surface of revolution of that locus about Z axis.
From the figure A = ( cos α , sin α , 0 ) B = ( cos α , − sin α , 0 ) Take the symmetric case where C = ( − 1 , 0 , 0 )
Consider the r e d semicircle shown with AB as diameter. Center M, Radius = sin α and a point Q vertically above M giving ∠ A Q B = 9 0 °
Now consider another semicircle in XZ plane with CM as diameter shown in g r e e n . All angles inscribed here will be 90° too. So if we can get our point Q on this semicircle, the problem is solved!
So rotate MQ about M till it meets this circle at P as shown in the 'Elevation' below. THAT point P is a trirectangular corner!
Imgur
Let β = ∠ P M C and since M A = M Q = M P = sin α we get P x = cos α − sin α . cos β ; P y = 0 ; P z = sin α . sin β
From △ C P M , cos β = 1 + cos α sin α and sin β = 1 + cos α 2 cos α
\Note : I had given a long winded way of showing that locus of P in XZ plane to be the ellipse P x 2 + 2 P z 2 = 1 but Prof. Niranjan Khanderia showed me a simple way to get there lot quicker! Here is his method:
P x 2 = ( cos α − sin α . cos β ) 2
= cos 2 α + sin 2 α ( 1 − sin 2 β ) − 2 sin α . cos α . cos β
= 1 − P z 2 − 2 sin α . cos α . 1 + cos α sin α
= 1 − P z 2 − sin 2 α . 1 + cos α 2 . cos α
= 1 − P z 2 − sin 2 α . sin 2 β
= 1 − P z 2 − P z 2
= 1 − 2 . P z 2
Thus the locus of P in XZ plane is the ellipse x 2 + 2 z 2 = 1 revolving which we get the desired surface - the oblate spheroid: x 2 + y 2 + 2 z 2 = 1 .
Consider it as a sphere unilaterally scaled (compressed) by a factor 2 1 thus giving a volume 2 1 3 4 π . 1 3 = 2 . 9 6 1 9 2 . . .
Surprising how far simple high school math can take us!