Trisecting an angle

Geometry Level 5

Ravi wants to trisect an angle A O B AOB , which has measure θ \theta . From A A , he drops a perpendicular to side O B OB , intersecting at C C . He then constructs an equilateral triangle A C D ACD on the opposite side of A C AC as compared to O O . He claims (without any justification) that 2 D O B = D O A 2\angle DOB = \angle DOA , so O D OD will trisect angle A O B AOB . What is the sum of all angles θ \theta with 0 < θ < 9 0 0 ^\circ < \theta < 90^\circ , such that his claim is true?


The answer is 45.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Emanuel Perez
May 20, 2014

Drop an altitude from D to OB. Label this point E. Because ACE is a right angle and ACD is 6 0 60^\circ , DCE must be 3 0 30^\circ . Because all figures are proportional, we can let the sidelength of the equilateral triangle be 2 and because of the 3 0 , 6 0 , 9 0 30^\circ, 60^\circ ,90^\circ triangle, C E = 3 CE=\sqrt{3} and D E = 1 DE=1 . Let O C = x OC=x , and a n g l e C O A = 3 θ angle COA = 3\theta . Assume that D O DO trisects the angle.

Now we can see that tan θ = 1 3 + x \tan \theta= \frac {1}{\sqrt{3}+x} and tan 3 θ = 2 x \tan 3\theta=\frac {2}{x} . We simplify tan 3 θ \tan3\theta into 3 tan θ tan θ 3 1 3 tan θ 2 \frac {3\tan\theta-{\tan\theta}^3}{1-3{\tan\theta}^{2}} [by splitting it up into a tangent sum with 2 θ 2\theta and θ \theta , and splitting the 2 θ 2\theta into a double angle tangent identity]. Because we know what tan θ \tan\theta is, we can substitute into the the equation for tan 3 θ \tan3\theta and it is an equation with only x as a variable. After solving the equation, you get that x = ± 2 x=\pm 2 , which leaves that tan 3 θ = 2 / ( + / 2 ) = + / 1 \tan3\theta = 2/(+/-2)=+/1 . Since the angle must be between 0 0^\circ and 9 0 90^\circ , the only viable choice is when it is 1 and that occurs when the angle is 4 5 45^\circ .

Mihir Sheth
May 20, 2014

Construct a perpendicular $DE$ on $OB$. Let $AC=CD=AD=a$. Since $\triangle ACD$ is an equilateral triangle, $\angle ACD = 60^{\circ}$ and thus $\angle DCE = 30^{\circ}$. So in right angled $\triangle DCE, DE=a/2$ and $CE=a\sqrt{3}/2$.\ \indent Now by assumption $\angle DOE = \theta /3$, so $OD=\frac{a}{2\sin({\theta /3})}$ and $OE=ODcos(\theta /3)=\frac{a}{2}cot(\theta /3)$. \ \indent Now $OC=OE-CE=\frac{a}{2}(cot(\theta /3) - \sqrt{3})$. Hence $tan(\angle AOC)=tan(\theta)=AC/OC=\frac{2}{(cot(\theta /3) - \sqrt{3})}$.\ \indent Let $f(\theta)=tan(\theta)-\frac{2}{(cot(\theta /3) - \sqrt{3})}$. The function $f$ has only one zero in the range $0$ to $\pi /2$ at $\theta = \pi /4$. Therefore $OD$ is an angle trisector only for $\theta = \pi /4$.

Calvin Lin Staff
May 13, 2014

Reflect the point D D across O B OB to a point E E . Since D C A = 6 0 \angle DCA = 60^\circ , it follows that 15 0 = D C O = E C O 150^\circ = \angle DCO = \angle ECO , so D C E = 6 0 \angle DCE = 60^\circ . By the reflection, C D = C E CD=CE , so C D E CDE is an equilateral triangle.

Consider the rotation of triangle D O E DOE about O O by D O E \angle DOE . E E gets mapped to D D , and D D gets mapped to F F , which lies on O A OA . Since D O F DOF is an isosceles triangle, D F O = 1 2 ( 18 0 D O F ) = 9 0 D O C = 9 0 1 3 C O A \angle DFO = \frac {1}{2} (180^\circ - \angle DOF) = 90^\circ - \angle DOC = 90^\circ - \frac {1}{3} \angle COA .

By construction, D A = D C = D E = F D DA=DC=DE=FD , so D F A DFA is an isosceles triangle. Let us determine where F F lies. D O F DOF is an isosceles triangle. Observe that D C O \angle DCO is obtuse, so O D 2 > O C 2 + C D 2 = O C 2 + C A 2 = O A 2 OD^2 > OC^2 + CD^2 = OC^2 + CA^2 = OA^2 , hence F F is further out from O O than A A (and also not equal to A A ). So, we have D F O = D F A = D A F = 18 0 6 0 C A O = 12 0 ( 9 0 C O A ) = 3 0 + C O A \begin{aligned} \angle DFO = \angle DFA = \angle DAF &= 180^ \circ - 60^ \circ - \angle CAO \\ &= 120^\circ - (90^\circ -\angle COA) \\ &= 30^\circ + \angle COA \\ \end{aligned}

Equating these two, we get that 9 0 1 3 C O A = 3 0 + C O A 90^\circ - \frac {1}{3} \angle COA = 30^\circ + \angle COA , or that C O A = 4 5 \angle COA = 45^\circ . Hence, there is only 1 possible value for θ \theta , and so the sum is 45 45 .

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...