Victorious sets!

Algebra Level 4

Call a non-empty set V \mathbb V of non-zero integers victorious if there exists a polynomial P ( x ) P(x) with integer coefficients such that P ( 0 ) = 330 P(0) = 330 and P ( v ) = 2 v P(v) = 2|v| for all elements v V . v \in \mathbb V.

How many victorious sets exist?


The answer is 217.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Mark Hennings
Nov 8, 2017

If V V is a victorious set containing positive integers only, and if P ( x ) P(x) is a polynomial with the defining property for V V , then we can find a polynomial A ( x ) A(x) with integer coefficients such that P ( x ) 2 x = A ( x ) v V ( x v ) P(x) - 2x \; = \; A(x) \prod_{v \in V}(x-v) and we must have (putting x = 0 x=0 ) 330 = A ( 0 ) v V ( v ) 330 \; = \; A(0) \prod_{v \in V}(-v) which means that v V v \prod_{v \in V}v must divide 330 330 . Thus V V must be a subset of the set V = { 1 , 2 , 3 , 5 , 6 , 10 , 11 , 15 , 22 , 30 , 33 , 50 , 66 , 110 , 165 , 330 } \mathcal{V} \; = \; \{ 1,2,3,5,6,10,11,15,22,30,33,50,66,110,165,330\} of positive divisors of 330 330 , and the product of all the elements of V V must also divide 330 330 . Without listing them all, there are 103 103 such sets. Thus there are 103 103 victorious sets consisting of positive integers only, and (by symmetry) there are 103 103 victorious sets consisting of negative integers only.

Suppose that V V is a victorious set that contains both positive and negative integers, and let P ( x ) P(x) be its associated polynomial. Let V + V_+ and V V_- be the positive and negative elements of V V respectively. It follows that we can find polynomials A ( x ) , B ( x ) A(x),B(x) such that P ( x ) 2 x = A ( x ) v V + ( x v ) P ( x ) + 2 x = B ( x ) v V ( x v ) P(x) - 2x \; = \; A(x) \prod_{v \in V_+} (x -v) \hspace{2cm} P(x) + 2x \; = \; B(x) \prod_{v \in V_-} (x -v) and hence 2 P ( x ) = A ( x ) v V + ( x v ) + B ( x ) v V ( x v ) 2P(x) \; = \; A(x) \prod_{v \in V_+} (x -v) + B(x) \prod_{v \in V_-} (x -v) If w V w \in V_- then 4 w = A ( w ) v V + ( w v ) -4w \; = \; A(w) \prod_{v \in V_+}(w - v) so that v V + ( w v ) \prod_{v \in V_+}(w-v) divides 4 w 4w for any w V w \in V_- . Similarly, v V ( w v ) \prod_{v \in V_-}(w-v) divides 4 w 4w for any w V + w \in V_+ . Checking the possibilities, it follows that there are only three types of victorious set V V that contain both positive and negative integers: { v , v } \{v,-v\} , { v , 3 v } \{v,-3v\} and { 3 v , v } \{3v,-v\} .

  • If { v , v } \{v,-v\} is a victorious set, then we have P ( x ) 2 v = C ( x ) ( x v 2 ) P(x) - 2v \; = \; C(x)(x - v^2) for some polynomial C ( x ) C(x) , which implies that v 2 v^2 must divide 330 2 v 330 - 2v . This means that v v can be one of 1 , 3 , 165 1,3,165 only. There are 3 3 victorious sets like this.
  • If { v , 3 v } \{v,-3v\} is a victorious set, then we have P ( x ) = 3 v x + C ( x ) ( x v ) ( x + 3 v ) P(x) = 3v - x + C(x)(x-v)(x+3v) for some polynomial C ( x ) C(x) , and hence v 2 v^2 must divide 110 v 110 - v . This means that v v must be one of 1 , 2 , 10 , 110 1,2,10,110 . There are 4 4 victorious sets like this.
  • By symmetry, there are also 4 4 victorious sets of the form { 3 v , v } \{3v,-v\} .

Thus there are 103 + 103 + 3 + 4 + 4 = 217 103 + 103 + 3 + 4 + 4 = \boxed{217} different victorious sets.

Great proof. Wanted to mention that in the second half of the proof, the products should read v V + \prod_{v \in V_+} rather than x V + \prod_{x \in V_+} .

Stephen Brown - 3 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

Thanks for spotting that. Typo corrected.

Mark Hennings - 3 years, 6 months ago

Wow, great proof and great problem!!

Christopher Criscitiello - 3 years, 6 months ago

A very nice proof -- I learned a lot. Thank you very much, Mark.

Rob Brott - 3 years, 6 months ago

After I finally got my solution, I was excited to see if there was a better one. Unfortunately your solution is almost exactly the same as mine! At least there's no need for me to write it up. Very nice.

I wonder: is there a general formula for the quantity 103 103 that appears in the proof? Or maybe just in the special case of products of distinct primes? It should only depend on the number of distinct primes in that case...

Patrick Corn - 3 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

Well if N N is square-free, being a product of n n distinct primes, then the number of positive integer N N -victorious sets is 2 k = 1 n ( n k ) B k + 1 2\sum_{k=1}^n \binom{n}{k}B_k + 1 where B k B_k is the k k th Bell number. To see this, if N = p 1 p 2 . . . p n N=p_1p_2...p_n , then for any subcollection of k k of the prime factors of N N there are B k B_k partitions, and each set V V obtained by multiplying together the primes in each component of the partition gives us an N N -victorious set V V that does not contain 1 1 . We can double the number of N N -victorious sets by adding 1 1 to each set. Since there is also the singleton N N -victorious set { 1 } \{1\} , we obtain the above formula.

Life would be more complicated for a number N N that is not square-free.

Mark Hennings - 3 years, 6 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...