What a chain! 3


One end of the pile of chain kept on a support falls vertically through a hole in its support and pulls the remaining links steadily.

The links which are at rest acquire the velocity of the hanging part suddenly without having interaction with the remaining stationary links and support.

If the acceleration of the falling chain is g k \dfrac{g}{k} , where g g is acceleration due to gravity and k k is a positive integer.

What is k k ?



Details and Assumptions

  • There is no interaction between the links falling and the stationary links and support
  • The chain is uniform

This is a part of my set Aniket's Mechanics Challenges


The answer is 3.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Laszlo Mihaly
Apr 5, 2018

Let us denote the position of the end of the chain by y y . The mass of the moving segment of the chain is m = ρ y m=\rho y , where ρ \rho is the mass per unit length. The velocity of the chain is v = y ˙ v=\dot y and the acceleration is y ¨ \ddot y . According to Newton's law

m g = d ( m v ) d t = m v ˙ + v m ˙ mg= \frac{ d(mv)}{dt}= m \dot v+ v \dot m

Since m ˙ = ρ y ˙ \dot m= \rho \dot y , we can rewrite this as

g = y ¨ + y ˙ m m ˙ = y ¨ + y ˙ 2 y g= \ddot y + \frac{\dot y}{m} \dot m= \ddot y+ \frac{\dot y^2}{y}

This is a second order ordinary nonlinear differential equation. It has a simple solution if the initial conditions are y ( 0 ) = 0 y(0)=0 and y ˙ ( 0 ) = 0 \dot y(0)=0 . The trial function that satisfies the initial conditions is y = 1 2 a t 2 y=\frac{1}{2} at^2 , where a a is a constant acceleration. With that, y ˙ = a t \dot y=at . Inserting this to the equation we get

g = a + 2 ( a t ) 2 a t 2 = 3 a g= a+\frac{2 (at)^2}{at^2}=3a

and a = g / 3 a=g/3 .

If the chain has a non-zero length hanging down when it is released this solution is not valid, but it is likely that the solution will always approach a = g / 3 a=g/3 as the chain gets longer with time.

Aniket Sanghi
Mar 11, 2016

The only external force on the chain is weight of the released chain



Consider the system at time t....when dx length is about to join the moving part of chain .........Mass of the released portion is m and length L...

Impulse = d (mv)

mg = m d v d t \frac{m dv}{dt} + v d m d t \frac{v dm}{dt}

mg = ma + m v L \frac{mv}{L} d x d t \frac{dx}{dt}

mg = ma + m v 2 L \frac{mv^2}{L}

v 2 = ( g a ) L v^2 = (g - a) L

comparing it with v 2 = 2 a L v^2 = 2aL

g - a = 2 a

a = g 3 a = {\frac{g}{3}}


I didn't get why is the acceleration of the chain uniform. And isn't the equation v²=2as valid for only constant acceleration? Thanks in advance.

Pranav Rao - 5 years, 3 months ago

A correct approach would be to solve the differential equation. . . a = g- v^2/x. v=sqrt(2gx/3) Satisfies it

saptarshi dasgupta - 3 years, 2 months ago

The forces acting on the falling part of chain are its weight and the tension which is equal to thrust force m v 2 / x mv^2/x
So, m a = m g m v 2 / x ma = mg - mv^2/x . Or, v d v / d t = g v 2 / x vdv/dt=g-v^2/x Let u = v 2 u=v^2 Then d u / d t + 2 u / x = 2 g du/dt +2u/x =2g Multiplying by x 2 x^2 ,and putting z = u x 2 . , d z / d x = 2 g x 2 z=ux^2. , dz/dx = 2gx^2 So v 2 x 2 = z = 2 g x 3 / 3 v^2x^2 = z = 2gx^3/3 , considering ​the initial conditions v = ( 2 g x / 3 ) v=\sqrt(2gx/3)

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...