Where Do They Intersect?

Geometry Level 3

In a large circle, we draw 2 circles that are each internally tangent at A A and B B . We then draw the common exterior tangent C D CD .

Where do the lines A C AC and B D BD intersect?

On the circumference of the large circle Depends on the positions of A and B Inside the large circle Outside the large circle

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

5 solutions

Calvin Lin Staff
Oct 25, 2016

Claim: The line AC intersects the large circle at a point P A C P_{AC} , such that the tangent to the large circle is parallel to C D CD .

Proof: Think about the expansion about point A, which brings the small circle to the large circle.
The image of point C will be moving along the line AC. The image of point C will also lie on the large circle. Hence, the image of point C will be P A C P_{AC} .
The tangent CD will continue to have the same slope, so the tangent at the image of point C will have the same slope as CD, thus they are parallel.

Claim: The line BD intersects the large circle at a point P B D P_{BD} , such that the tangent to the large circle is parallel to C D CD .

Proof: Similar to previous claim

Claim: P A C = P B D P_{AC} = P_{BD}

Proof: The tangents at these points have the same slope, and lie on the same side of C D CD which intersects the circle. There is a unique point that satisfies these conditions.

Hence, the lines intersect on the circle, at a point which is tangential to CD.


The idea presented here is known as homothety , which is one of my favourite results in Euclidean Geometry. This problem is one of my favourite ones to demonstrate it's power in simplicity.

Ahmad Saad
Oct 24, 2016

That works!

Can you find a "one-line" solution?

Calvin Lin Staff - 4 years, 7 months ago

Log in to reply

sorry. I don't know.

Ahmad Saad - 4 years, 7 months ago

Simple and straightforth

Ritabrata Roy - 2 years, 11 months ago
Michael Mendrin
Oct 23, 2016

All roads lead to Rome, which is point F, on line perpendicular to arbitrary chord GH through its midpoint. Arbitrary small circle is tangent to chord GH at D and to large circle at B. Triangles BJD and BEF are similar isosceles triangles, and both vertical lines are their altitudes.

Given any arbitrary chord GH, line BD passes through point F on the large circle for any small circle tangent to GH at point D and to large circle at point B.

Hm, I'm not quite sure how your solution works out. What are the isosceles triangles?How is E defined? Is CD supposed to be parallel to BE?

Calvin Lin Staff - 4 years, 7 months ago

Log in to reply

Gimmie a little time to work up a nicer graphic. But, yes, BE is supposed to be parallel to CD. In fact, we only need to consider just one circle, the "other" circle is irrelevant. That is, given an arbitrary chord BE, for any circle tangent to it and to the large circle, line BD will always intersect the large circle at the same point F.

The way you've got your graphic drawn, it looks as if line AC doesn't intersect at F, but in fact it does, if drawn accurately.

Michael Mendrin - 4 years, 7 months ago

Log in to reply

Looks much better now.

For such problems, images are often intentionally not drawn to scale.

Calvin Lin Staff - 4 years, 7 months ago


As shown By Calvin Lin, the fixed point is the point of tangentcy of the big circle parallel to the common tangent on the opposite side.

Ujjwal Rane
Nov 23, 2016

Two internally tangent circles Two internally tangent circles

Extend AC to meet the outer circle at E. Draw radius OE. Point of tangency A and centers C1, O will be collinear. Do the same for the other circle with center C2

Triangles ACC1 and AEO are both isosceles, share an angle and the base. So they must be similar. And radius OE will be parallel to CC1 For the same reason, we must have a radius parallel to DC2. But since CC1 and DC2 are parallel (both perpendicular to the same tangent) So the two radii must merge giving a unique point E.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...