Where Will They Meet?

Two point masses of 3 kilograms and 7 kilograms are separated by a distance of 10 meters. Their initial speed is zero. What is the distance in meters from the initial position of the mass of 7 kilograms where these two bodies will meet? Assume that no other forces except the gravitational attraction between the two bodies are in play here.


The answer is 3.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

15 solutions

Nishant Sharma
Jan 1, 2014

Since the system is isolated so no other force except gravitational force acts between them. This implies the center of mass of the system remains at rest and for this to be true the bodies must meet at the center of mass of the system.

So the required distance is the position of center of mass w.r.t 7 k g 7\,kg mass i.e. r = 3 × 10 + 0 × 7 3 + 7 = 3 m \textbf{r}=\displaystyle\frac{3\times10+0\times7}{3+7}=\boxed{3\,m} .

Thankyou

AAditya Barot - 7 years, 5 months ago

Thank you

Carlos Vinícius Moreira Salgado - 7 years, 5 months ago

yes thank u

Ravalee Kanthi Ravuri - 7 years, 4 months ago

thank you

ram kumar - 7 years, 4 months ago

CAN U GIVE ME ANY FORMULA TO FIND THIS

Abhijeet Singh - 7 years, 4 months ago

I thought the question had something to do with the universal gravitation formula. Instead I just with my instinct to avoid the work.

Robert Fritz - 7 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

me too but i got the answer correct

Manan Manwani - 7 years, 4 months ago

is there any formula for this?

shuvayan ghosh dastidar - 7 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

well, i think we should not look out for formulae...they curb our temprament of understanding ..... just give time to questions and btw, most of such questions can be solved with normal mathematics

Chiya Anand - 7 years, 3 months ago

Log in to reply

Formula is important to understand concept of the nature works

Hafizh Ahsan Permana - 7 years, 3 months ago

Could any one please do this using The gravitation formula ?

Alan Cooper - 7 years, 4 months ago

Can you explain the 'centre of mass ' concept...i didn't get it!

Chiya Anand - 7 years, 3 months ago

ok, thanks for the explain

Theresia Yuniari - 7 years, 4 months ago

We need to consider the space the bodies take and what is the distance from center of mass to outer shell. Thats why its needed to say what are their sizes. so why is size important? because its proven that matter manifests its self differently when smaller with same mass, in compared to when bigger. So the dots must not have same size because one of the 2 will act differently because of squized matter. Example Black hole is created by squeezing mass and not by leaving it scattered. The light behaves differently also, around the objects.

Miodrag Grgurovic - 7 years, 4 months ago
Nico Valdes
Jan 1, 2014

For this problem, you could probably go out of your way doing integrals and doing tons of complicated stuff; all you need, however, is some of Newton's laws and a bit of physical intuition :).

Everything gets much simpler if we remember Newton's third law- equal and opposite forces. The two point masses will always exert equal forces on each other; the only difference will be the resulting accelerations. So it doesn't really matter that they're getting closer to each other and the gravitational attractions are increasing, because they're increasing equally for both masses. The one difference is the actual mass; remembering Newton's third: the 3 kg mass will have an acceleration of F/3 (F is changing but we don't care), while the 7 kg mass will have an acceleration of F/7. The acceleration of the 7 kg mass is 3/7 that of the 3 kg mass. Distance covered is directly proportional to acceleration, so the distance covered by the 7 kg mass is 3/7 that of the distance covered by the 3 kg mass! Let's call the distance the 3 kg mass goes x. Then 10=x+3/7•x=x(1+3/7)=x(10/7). So, x=7 (the distance covered by the 3 kg mass is 7 meters). Now we can either subtract that from the total distance, or multiply it by 3/7; it doesn't matter. Both operations give us the same result, the distance covered by the 7 kg mass (the point at which they meet starting from the 7 kg mass): 3 meters! Pretty great, right?

Or we could just say the center of mass stays the same.

Samuel Jackson - 7 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

That's true, hadn't thought of it. Really nice!

Nico Valdes - 7 years, 5 months ago

I was wondering about integrals. Force IS changing with distance. Why are we discounting that?

Jean Gloria - 7 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

It increases equally for both.

Nico Valdes - 7 years, 4 months ago

Doesn't the hypothesis of acceleration (and hence distance covered) inversely proportional to masses contradict galileo's finding of common acceleration and forces increasing (weight) ? Is this because Galieo's findings were local (euclidean ???) and essentially due to the asymmetry of the situation on earth with regard to falling bodies ?

Sundar R - 7 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

You're confusing two very different concepts. One is of bodies falling freely on the Earth's surface; all bodies on Earth accelerate towards the ground at the same rate, independent of their mass, of course (neglecting air resistance). However, this situation is completely different. It's not like comparing a hammer and a feather falling into the Earth. What we're doing is more like comparing, how much a feather falls into the Earth , with how much the Earth moves up into the feather . Do you see my point here? Hopefully this was helpful.

Nico Valdes - 7 years, 4 months ago
Ahaan Rungta
Jan 2, 2014

The two objects will meet at their center of mass. Let x = 0 m x = 0 \, \text{m} be the position of the 7 7 -kg object and let x = 10 m x = 10 \, \text{m} be the position of the 3 3 -kg object. Then,

x COM = ( 0 m ) ( 7 kg ) + ( 10 m ) ( 3 kg ) 3 kg + 7 kg = 3 m , x_{\text{COM}} = \dfrac {(0 \, \text{m}) \cdot (7 \, \text{kg}) + (10 \, \text{m}) \cdot (3 \, \text{kg})}{3 \, \text{kg} + 7 \, \text{kg}} = 3 \, \text{m},

so the displacement we seek is 3 m 0 m = 3 m 3 \, \text{m} - 0 \, \text{m} = \boxed {3} \, \text{m} .

how u subtracted the initial position

hari prasath murugesan - 7 years, 5 months ago
Himadri Shee
Feb 21, 2014

Since no external force is working except their mutual force, thus, dx(COM)= 0

So, mdx = Mdy (m = mass of smaller body, M = mass of larger body, dx = distance moved by the smaller body, dy = distance moved by the latger body)

Let the point where they meet be a metres from 7kg mass.

So, 3 X (10 - a) = 7 X a

a = 3

So, 3 metres is the answer.

Swapnil Saha
Jan 3, 2014

Assume m=7kg & m"=3kg Force act on m & m" is 1.40 10^-11( by using the equation F=mm" G/r^2) Again,F=ma, a=F/m.By using this equation, I found the acceleration for m & m" is a= 2 10^-12 & a"= 4.67 10^-12 s=ut+.5at^2 s=at^2 t^2=s/a Assume the path passed by m is s & m" is (10-s). Here the duration of passing is same. So, 2s/a=2(10-s)/a" From this equation I found s is 2.99 m=3 m

Although the argument gives the correct answer, the reasoning is flawed since the magnitude of the gravitational forces will change as the objects move towards each other.

Jørgen Thomassen - 7 years, 4 months ago

I solved it also like this :D

Sherif Elmaghraby - 7 years, 5 months ago

very complicated. Better use center of mass system to solve the problem

Govind Kalaga - 7 years, 4 months ago
Santanu Banerjee
Jan 2, 2014

They will of course meet at their centre of mass

The question would have been more challenging if it would have been WHEN will they meet!!! instead of Where will they meet!!!

I actually calculated "WHEN" they meet which also is kind of easy.

siddharth shah - 7 years, 5 months ago
Shweta Rai
Feb 28, 2014

as no other force than gravitation is acting the will meet at center of mass which is at 3 metres from 7. if we consider coordinate of 7kg to be 0 and that of 3kg to be 10 com=(3 10+7 0) \7+3=30\10=3 :)

Saurav Sharma
Feb 25, 2014

this questin is similar to problems we do electrostatics just use the formula of gravitational force take distance 3 kg mass be X then from from 7 kg it will be 10-X and equate the forces.

Mohd Wasih
Jan 16, 2014

as no external force acts on the composite system, therefore the center of mass of the system will be at rest or we can say that the two masses will meet at their center of mass. so in reference frame of 7 kg mass, the center of mass is at 3*10/3+7=3m

Jonty Roy
Jan 10, 2014

The two bodies are at rest (initially). We will consider the two bodies as one system. They will meet at their center of mass (center of mass of the two body system). Since there is only motion along one axis (say X). CM at X-axis is:

(m1.x1 + m2.x2)/(m1 + m2) [This is how you find Center of Mass of two body system like the one in question]

Here m1=3kg, x1=0m, m2=7kg, x2=10m. Thus Center of mass is at 7m from 3kg, or 7m from 7kg.

We take m1 to be the starting point(datum point), thus x1=0m.

Siddharth Shah
Jan 6, 2014

first of all lets calculate the acceleration on 7kg mass using the standard formula for gravitaional force i.e. F= G M 1 M_{1} M 2 M_{2} / r 2 r^{2} . Now the acceleration on 7kg is F/7 = 3G/100.

Let 'x' be the distance from 3kg mass where the particles meet. Therefore 10-x is the point from 7kg where the points meet. Using the formula x=1/2 X a 1 a_{1} X t 2 t^{2} and 10-x = 1/2 X a 2 a_{2} X t 2 t^{2} . Since the time of meeting is same for both the particles. On solving we get t 2 t^{2} = 200/G On plugging this value in 10-x equation, we get the desired result i.e. Ans = 3 \boxed{3}

Su Ku
Jan 5, 2014

In the absence of any external force, the center of mass will remain at rest as it was at the time of leaving the bodies. So, effectively we have to calculate the center of mass position from body of mass 7 kg.

Venkatesh G
Jan 5, 2014

When the two bodies collide they shall be at their center of mass and hence, the ans is 3 as the center of mass of the two bodies is 3 m from the larger mass.

Ryan Yang
Jan 1, 2014

Since this system only evolves through internal forces, the center of mass of the system remains constant. Therefore, they will meet at the center of mass of the system.

M r c m = m 1 r 1 + m 2 r 2 Mr_{cm} = m_{1}r_{1} + m_{2}r_{2}

Where M M is the total mass, m 1 m_{1} is 3 kg, m 2 m_{2} is 7 kg, r 1 r_{1} is the distance the 7-kg block is from the 3-kg block, and r 2 r_{2} is the distance the 3-kg block is from the 3 kg block.

When you evaluate this, r c m r_{cm} is 7 meters. The place where the two blocks meet is therefore 3 m e t e r s \boxed{3 meters} away from the 7-kg block.

Sazzad Sayyed
Dec 27, 2013

Here the only forces in play are the mutual attraction forces between the two bodies which are action-reaction pair.As no external force acts on this two body system so the position of their center of mass will remain unchanged.So the only point at which they can meet is the center of mass of this system. Now suppose that the 3 kilo mass is at the origin and the 7 kilo mass is at the point (10,0).Then the center of mass lies on the x axis and we calculate it this way- x coordinate of the center of mass =(3 times 0 + 7 times 10)/(3+7)=7 SO the distance of the center of mass from the 3 kilo mass is 7.Hence the distance of the center of mass from the 7 kilo mass is (10 - 7) = 3.

please explain formula

Vikas Jangra - 7 years, 3 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...