Why does 0 = 1? Cos 0 = 1

Geometry Level 5

r = 0 3 [ 4 sin ( 3 5 r x ) sin ( 5 r x ) 1 ] = 1 \large \prod_{r=0}^3 \left [ 4\sin(3 \cdot 5^r x) \sin(5^r x) - 1 \right ] = 1

Suppose x x satisfies the equation above, find the total number of solutions of x x that falls in the range ( 0 , π ) (0, \pi) .

Inspiration .


The answer is 623.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Pi Han Goh
May 23, 2015

It's equivalent to solving for r = 0 3 [ 1 4 sin ( 3 5 r x ) sin ( 5 r x ) ] = 1 \displaystyle \prod_{r=0}^3 \left [ 1 - 4\sin(3 \cdot 5^r x) \sin(5^r x) \right ] = 1 .

For the first term being multiplied, we apply the double angle formula and product to sum formula, and let y = cos x y=\cos x for simplicity sake.

1 4 sin ( 3 x ) sin ( x ) = 1 + 2 ( 2 sin ( 3 x ) sin ( x ) ) = 1 + 2 ( cos ( 4 x ) cos ( 2 x ) ) = 1 2 [ 2 ( cos 2 ( 2 x ) 1 ) 2 1 cos ( 2 x ) ] = 1 + 2 [ 2 ( ( 2 y 2 1 ) 2 1 ) 2 1 ( 2 y 2 1 ) ] = 16 y 4 20 y 2 + 5 \begin{aligned} 1 - 4\sin(3x) \sin(x) &=& 1 + 2(-2\sin(3x) \sin(x)) \\ &=& 1 + 2(\cos(4x) - \cos(2x)) \\ &=& 1 - 2 \left [ 2(\cos^2(2x) - 1)^2 - 1 - \cos(2x) \right ] \\ &=& 1 + 2 \left [ 2((2y^2-1)^2 - 1)^2 - 1 - (2y^2-1) \right ] \\ &=& 16y^4 - 20y^2 + 5 \\ \end{aligned}

Does the polynomial looks familiar? It's a slightly modified form of quintuple angle formula, cos ( 5 A ) = 16 cos 5 ( A ) 20 cos 3 ( A ) + 5 cos ( A ) \cos(5A) = 16\cos^5 (A) - 20\cos^3(A) + 5\cos(A) , which can be easily derived from Chebyshev Polynomials.

Thus, 1 4 sin ( 3 x ) sin ( x ) = cos ( 5 x ) cos ( x ) 1 - 4\sin(3x) \sin(x) = \frac{ \cos(5x)}{\cos(x)} . The product in question can be stated as such:

cos ( 5 x ) cos ( x ) cos ( 25 x ) cos ( 5 x ) cos ( 125 x ) cos ( 25 x ) cos ( 625 x ) cos ( 125 x ) = 1 cos ( 5 x ) cos ( x ) cos ( 25 x ) cos ( 5 x ) cos ( 125 x ) cos ( 25 x ) cos ( 625 x ) cos ( 125 x ) = 1 \begin{aligned} \frac{ \cos(5x)}{\cos(x)} \cdot \frac{ \cos(25x)}{\cos(5x)} \cdot \frac{ \cos(125x)}{\cos(25x)} \cdot \frac{ \cos(625x)}{\cos(125x)} &=& 1 \\ \Rightarrow \frac{ \cancel{\cos(5x)}}{\cos(x)} \cdot \frac{ \cancel{\cos(25x)}}{\cancel{\cos(5x)}} \cdot \frac{ \cancel{\cos(125x)}}{\cancel{\cos(25x)}} \cdot \frac{\cos(625x)}{\cancel{\cos(125x)}} &=& 1 \\ \end{aligned}

Or cos ( 625 x ) = cos ( x ) cos ( 625 x ) cos ( x ) = 0 \cos(625x) = \cos(x) \Rightarrow \cos(625x) - \cos(x) = 0

2 sin ( 625 + 1 2 x ) sin ( 625 1 2 x ) = 0 sin ( 313 x ) = 0 , sin ( 312 x ) = 0 \Rightarrow -2 \sin \left(\frac{625+1}2 x \right) \sin \left(\frac{625-1}2 x \right) = 0 \Rightarrow \sin(313x) = 0, \sin(312x) = 0 .

Since 313 313 is a prime number (which can be easily verified), all the values of x x that satisfy sin ( 313 x ) = 0 \sin(313x) = 0 falls in the given range are irreducible:

{ π 313 , 2 π 313 , 3 π 313 , , 312 π 313 } \left \{ \frac{\pi}{313}, \frac{2\pi}{313}, \frac{3\pi}{313}, \ldots , \frac{312\pi}{313} \right \}

Which gives a total of 312 312 solutions, similarly, sin ( 312 x ) = 0 \sin(312x) = 0 gives a total of 311 311 solutions. Hence totaling of 312 + 311 = 623 312+311 =\boxed{623} solutions.

Moderator note:

A better way to phrase it is by stating that the solution set for sin ( 313 x ) = 0 \sin(313x) = 0 and sin ( 312 x ) = 0 \sin(312x)=0 does not share a common value. Nice work nonetheless, I wasn't expecting a telescoping product to appear.

Nice problem

Kunal Verma - 6 years ago

Log in to reply

Yay! How did you solve this?

Pi Han Goh - 6 years ago

Log in to reply

Exactly same approach. I hope there's still a better solution to that( I really don't think so though).

Kunal Verma - 6 years ago

Really enjoyed the problem Sir!

User 123 - 5 years, 10 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...