Will of Honey

The assets of a will lists 7 barrels full of honey, 7 barrels 1/2 full of honey and 7 empty barrels.

The executor's task was to divide these assets among 3 sons, so that each son gets 7 barrels and the same amount of honey, without pouring honey from one barrel to another.

How many distinct ways could the estate be divided into?


Treat the barrels and honey as identical objects


The answer is 6.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

9 solutions

Junayed Aziz
Oct 22, 2014

ways of distribution: [3 full barrels + 1 half barrel + 3 empty barrels]
[2 full barrels + 3 half barrels + 2 empty barrels]
[1 full barrel + 5 half barrels + 1 empty barrel] which adds up to 3 ways. now to get all that "distinct" ways all is left to do is 3!=3 * 2 * 1 = 6 ways.

Dhafa Hikmawan
Oct 22, 2014

there are 7 barrels full of honey, 7 barrels 1/2 full of honey and 7 empty barrels. It means that the total of the honey are (1 7 + 1/2 7 + 0*7) barrels, and it is equal to 10.5 barrels. Since we are going to use all barrels for 3 sons and they got the same amount, that means each son will get (10.5)/2 barrels, that is 3.5 barrels. These are the possibility for this case:

(A) (3 full + 1 half + 3 empty), (2 full + 3 half + 2 empty) and (2 full + 3 half + 2 empty) there are three sons to give the barrel, and a case where there are 2 same configurations (the 2 full + 3 half + 2 empty) so the ways sons can get that is (3!/2!) = 3 ways

(B) (1 full + 5 half + 2 empty), (3 full + 1 half +3 empty) and (3 full + 1 half +3 empty) here, we met the same case with the possibility (A), where there are 2 same configurations (the 3 full + 1 half + 3 empty) so the ways sons can get that is also (3!/2!) ways = 3 ways

Then, we add the result of possibility (A) and possibility (B). There, we got 3 ways + 3 ways = 6 ways

Brahmam Meka
Oct 21, 2014

average 3.5 every son gets. It is 3f,1h 3e;3f 1h 3e; 1f 5h 1e; combination.it can be done in 3 ways or 2f 3h 2e; 2f 3h 2e ;3f 1h 3e combination. it can also be done in 3 ways . Total 6 ways here f is full ;h is half full & e is empty barrels.

Anna Anant
Nov 16, 2014

Total amount = 7 full + 7 half + 7 empty = 10.5 with 21 barrels. Every person (all of them is 3 person) will have 3.5 with 7 barrels. Now the combination can be any order, one of them: 1. 3 full 1 half 3 empty, makes the remaining are 4 full 6 half 4 empty, then 2. 2 full 3 half 2 empty and 3. 2 full 3 half 2 empty. Another combination is 1. 3 full 1 half 3 empty, 2. 3 full 1 half 3 empty, and 3. 1 full 5 half 1 empty. I only can find these combination. Since each above combination can be arranged in two other arrangement, then 3+3= 6

Kalfin Muchtar
Oct 23, 2014

let m be the number of full barrels, n be the number of 1/2 full barels, and p is the number of empty barrels. The total of amount of honey is 21/2. So each of son must get 7/2. And we have 2m+n+p = 7/2, and gives solution of triple (m,n,p) are (3,1,3), (1,5,1), (2,3,1). Then there are 2* ((3!)/(2!)(1!)) = 6 distinct ways such that the total barrel which received by 3 sons is 7 barrels.

Annu Riz
Oct 23, 2014

we just take 3! ...to divide honey among 3 children

Mohammad Mohsin
Oct 23, 2014

Total amount = 7 full + 7 half + 7 empty = 10.5 with 21 barrels. Every person (all of them is 3 person) will have 3.5 with 7 barrels. Now the combination can be any order, one of them: 1. 3 full 1 half 3 empty, makes the remaining are 4 full 6 half 4 empty, then 2. 2 full 3 half 2 empty and 3. 2 full 3 half 2 empty. Another combination is 1. 3 full 1 half 3 empty, 2. 3 full 1 half 3 empty, and 3. 1 full 5 half 1 empty. I only can find these combination. Since each above combination can be arranged in two other arrangement, then 3+3= 6

Gurjot Sodhi
Oct 20, 2014

Solution is very simple just divide 7!/3! as 7 barrels are there and 3 sons......

Your answer is 840?????????

Guiseppi Butel - 6 years, 7 months ago

A] 2(3 * 1+1 * .5+4 * 0) + 1 * 1+5 * .5+1 * 0 however last combination can be to any of the three......................................3
B] 2(2 * 1 +3 * .5 +2 * 0) +3 * 1+ * .5+3 * 0 however last combination can be to any of the three......................................3 ..................................................................................................... Total 6.

FYI, when using " * " in text (IE not Latex), you have to keep spaces around it, otherwise the formatting will interpret it as "italicize this".

I've updated your solution so that * shows properly.

Calvin Lin Staff - 6 years, 7 months ago

Log in to reply

Thanks. I did find out this, but I missed!!

Niranjan Khanderia - 6 years, 7 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...