A brilliant year

Consider a system in which 73 73 balls are attached to a point each suspended by similar strings and each string of length l = 17 m l = 17 m separated from its adjacent string by an angle θ = 1 radian \theta = 1 \text{radian} . Each ball is charged with q = 2 C q = 2 C . Find the mass of the ball(each has the same mass) such that the system remains in equilibrium.

Give your answer as the integer nearest to a \text{a} such that a = m ( 1.57 10 7 ) \text{a} = \text{m}*(1.57*{10}^{-7}) .

Note: You can use computer aid for calculations at the end.


The answer is 365.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

Kartik Sharma
Apr 5, 2015

Sorry for a mistake in the problem previously! I have fixed it now!

Now the system says that 73 73 strings are attached to a point which are attached to balls. We will assume that the first string is on the y-axis and subsequent strings a definite angle apart. Also, here we have just used ϵ \epsilon for ϵ 0 {\epsilon}_{0} just to ease our writing(though it is wrong as ϵ = κ ϵ 0 \epsilon = \kappa{\epsilon}_{0} Now, to be in equilibrium,

Tension in the strings would be equal to weight-force . Now this would be the case for all 73 73 balls. Hence,

Y-component is

73 mg ( T 1 + T 1 c o s θ + T 1 c o s 2 θ + T 1 c o s 3 θ + + T 1 c o s 72 θ ) \displaystyle 73\text{mg} -({T}_{1} + {T}_{1}cos\theta + {T}_{1}cos2\theta + {T}_{1}cos3\theta + \cdots + {T}_{1}cos72\theta) [as all strings are identical, all have the same tensions]

Also,

X -component is

T 1 + T 1 s i n θ + T 1 s i n 2 θ + + T 1 s i n 72 θ \displaystyle {T}_{1} + {T}_{1}sin\theta + {T}_{1}sin2\theta + \cdots + {T}_{1}sin72\theta

Now, y-component is zero but balls have a charge as well. So, they will have an electrostatic force as well and that will be along the x-axis.

The distance between 2 balls is given by a cosine rule result.

Distance between rth and kth ball = 2 l 2 ( 1 c o s ( ( k r ) θ ) ) \displaystyle \text{Distance between rth and kth ball} = 2{l}^{2}(1 - cos((k-r)\theta))

Therefore, the sum of electrostatic forces between balls will be

i = 1 72 k = 1 i q 2 8 π ϵ l 2 ( 1 c o s ( k θ ) ) \displaystyle \sum_{i=1}^{72}{\sum_{k=1}^{i}{\frac{{q}^{2}}{8\pi\epsilon{l}^{2}(1-cos(k\theta))}}} [This is because each ball will have a force of interaction with every other ball, and the force can be considered as coulomb force]

Now, the x-components will be:

T 1 ( k = 0 72 s i n k θ ) = q 2 8 π ϵ l 2 i = 1 72 72 i 1 c o s i θ \displaystyle {T}_{1}(\sum_{k=0}^{72}{sink\theta}) = \frac{{q}^{2}}{8\pi\epsilon{l}^{2}}\displaystyle \sum_{i = 1}^{72}{\frac{72-i}{1-cosi\theta}}

Now, y-component will be:

T 1 ( m = 0 72 c o s m θ ) = 72 m g \displaystyle {T}_{1}(\sum_{m=0}^{72}{cosm\theta}) = 72mg

T 1 = 72 m g m = 0 72 c o s m θ \displaystyle {T}_{1} = \frac{72mg}{\displaystyle \sum_{m=0}^{72}{cosm\theta}}

Now substituting this in equation of x-axis,

72 m g m = 0 72 c o s m θ ( k = 0 72 s i n k θ ) = q 2 8 π ϵ l 2 i = 1 72 72 i 1 c o s i θ \displaystyle \frac{72mg}{\displaystyle \sum_{m=0}^{72}{cosm\theta}}(\sum_{k=0}^{72}{sink\theta}) = \frac{{q}^{2}}{8\pi\epsilon{l}^{2}}\displaystyle \sum_{i = 1}^{72}{\frac{72-i}{1-cosi\theta}}

After some bashing we get,

m = q 2 i = 1 72 72 i 1 c o s i θ c o t ( 36 θ ) 72 8 π ϵ l 2 g \displaystyle m = \frac{{q}^{2}\displaystyle \sum_{i = 1}^{72}{\frac{72-i}{1-cosi\theta}}cot(36\theta)}{72*8\pi\epsilon{l}^{2}g}

Well, how we got that c o t cot is by using the formulas:

s i n ( a ) + s i n ( a + b ) + s i n ( a + 2 b ) + + s i n ( a + ( n 1 ) b ) = s i n ( n b / 2 ) s i n ( b / 2 ) ( s i n ( a + ( n 1 ) b / 2 ) ) \displaystyle sin(a) + sin(a+b) + sin(a+2b) +\cdots+ sin(a+(n-1)b) = \frac{sin(nb/2)}{sin(b/2)}(sin(a+(n-1)b/2))

and

c o s ( a ) + c o s ( a + b ) + c o s ( a + 2 b ) + + c o s ( a + ( n 1 ) b ) = s i n ( n b / 2 ) s i n ( b / 2 ) ( c o s ( a + ( n 1 ) b / 2 ) ) \displaystyle cos(a) + cos(a+b) + cos(a+2b) +\cdots+cos(a+(n-1)b) = \frac{sin(nb/2)}{sin(b/2)}(cos(a+(n-1)b/2))

Now, just we have to do is to substitute some values in the expression -

θ = 1 , q = 2 , l = 17 \displaystyle \theta = 1, \text{q} = 2, \text{l} = 17

m = 2 2 i = 1 72 72 i 1 c o s i θ c o t ( 36 ) 576 π ϵ 17 2 g \displaystyle m = \frac{{2}^{2}\displaystyle \sum_{i = 1}^{72}{\frac{72-i}{1-cosi\theta}}cot(36)}{576\pi\epsilon{17}^{2}g}

The sum is difficult to handle and I am still finding problem to find its analytic answer and so you can use Wolfram Alpha here.

As a result,

m = 364.9245675 576 g π ϵ \displaystyle m = \frac{364.9245675}{576g\pi\epsilon}

The denominator is just 1.57 E 7 \displaystyle 1.57E-7 and that's what we have to multiply to m m .

Therefore, a a is

364.9 \displaystyle 364.9 and here you get the answer as 365 \displaystyle \boxed{365}

And all you need is 365 365 as answer! -_- Pretty easy to guess at least!

Kartik Sharma - 6 years, 2 months ago

Log in to reply

Brilliant Problem!!!! :)

Prakhar Bindal - 6 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

Thanks! :) And now they are not unsolved anymore.

Kartik Sharma - 6 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

@Kartik Sharma By The Way You Study In Which Class?

Prakhar Bindal - 6 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

@Prakhar Bindal Class XI now! Just a newbie in the XI standard! Sorry for late reply!

Kartik Sharma - 6 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

@Kartik Sharma I Too Have Just Came XI . Are You Preparing For JEE??

Prakhar Bindal - 6 years, 1 month ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...