How many zeros does the following function have?
P ( x ) = x P ( 9 ) + x P ( 8 ) + x P ( 7 ) + x P ( 6 ) + x P ( 5 ) + x P ( 4 ) + x P ( 3 ) + x P ( 2 ) + x P ( 1 ) + P ( x ) x
This question is flagged because it seems like we need to make the assumption that P ( x ) is a polynomial defined over the complex numbers.
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
Define denominator.
Log in to reply
Log in to reply
Sorry, I just did not know what do you mean by demominator. And I don't get how non-zero denominators makes you say that there are 0 roots. Btw, im younger than you, dont need to call me sir.
Log in to reply
@Julian Poon – Definition of polynomial says it is continuous over R. thus the given polynomial should also be continuous over R.
Thanks for asking me question , here i may be totally wrong too , so what's your age
Log in to reply
@U Z – 14
Log in to reply
@Julian Poon – Do you agree with what I say
Please ask me question, I want to release myself
Log in to reply
@U Z – No... I dont agree... sorry... I cant find a proof for that statement. Happy new year!
Log in to reply
@Julian Poon – Thanks , can you give some contradictory statement to that point.
Same to you
Log in to reply
@U Z – I don't have a contradictory statement to prove this is wrong and I don't have a proof on why this is correct. I don't know anything! yay. thats why I did not agree
Log in to reply
@Julian Poon – What Megh means is at x = 0 , P ( x ) x is of the form 0 0 ; thus, P ( x ) is discontinuous and not a polynomial.
Clarification : P ( x ) is assumed to be a Polynomial throughout.
Solution : Simplifying the given expression, we have P 2 ( x ) = P ( x ) i = 1 ∑ 9 x P ( i ) + x Let α be a root of P ( x ) . Thus P ( α ) = 0 . Putting x = α in the above, we have 0 = 0 + α i.e., α = 0 Hence all roots of the polynomial P ( x ) are zero. Thus P ( x ) is of the form x d for some positive integer d ≥ 1 ( P ( x ) ≡ 0 is not allowed). Hence we have the following identity x 2 d ≡ x d i = 1 ∑ 9 x i d + x Since 9 d + d > 2 d , for any d ≥ 1 , the above expression is impossible to satisfy. Hence no such polynomial P ( x ) is possible. ■
We will assume that a nonconstant polynomial exists with n roots and show that this cannot be the case.
Consider any non-zero roots. Let the root be A.(Note: This could be imaginary as well) . So (A)^2= (A^P(9)+.....+A^P(1))P(A)+x. Since P(A) is zero, we see that the LHS gives us 0 and the RHS gives us A. So all roots must be zero. So P(x)= Bx^n where B is the coefficient of x^n.
Repeating the above argument, we can see that n=1. So P(X)=Bx. Setting x=1 gives B=9.109.... or, -0.1097... If we check the 2 values, we see that neither of them work as the degrees of the polynomials are not the same and it is a well known fact that the highest degree term will dominate for very large values of x meaning that the 2 sides cannot be equal.
So no polynomials exist and so the number of roots is 0.
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
A polynomial is always continuous,
Given,
P ( x ) = x P ( 9 ) + x P ( 8 ) + x P ( 7 ) + x P ( 6 ) + x P ( 5 ) + x P ( 4 ) + x P ( 3 ) + x P ( 2 ) + x P ( 1 ) + P ( x ) x
This implies the denominator should not be zero , thus zero solutions
Please comment , Please correct me.