Bird's Eye View (Mathathon Problem 7)

Geometry Level 3

A bird sitting on a tree noticed a lion following an elephant coming towards the tree.

The bird was 45 m \SI{45}{m} above the ground. From her point of view, the angles of depression of the lion and the elephant were 4 5 45^\circ and 6 0 60^\circ respectively.

How far was the lion from the elephant in metres?

60 45 3 60 - 45\sqrt{3} 45 15 3 45 - 15\sqrt{3} 45 + 15 3 45 + 15\sqrt{3} 45 3 15 45\sqrt{3} - 15

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

13 solutions

Julie Éthier
Apr 1, 2021

Sundar R
Mar 25, 2021

Oskar Dobroczek
Mar 25, 2021

First of all, let's give some names to the known values!

Let x e x_e be the position of the elephant on the ground and let ϵ = π 3 \epsilon=\frac{\pi}{3} be the elephant's angle of depression from the bird's eye view.

Let x l x_l be the position of the lion on the ground and let λ = π 4 \lambda=\frac{\pi}{4} be the lion's angle of depression from the bird's eye view.

What we want to find is the distance d = x l x e d=x_l-x_e

Now we can make a drawing of the whole situation (not to scale).

One nice thing immediately springs to attention. The diagonal of a square has angle π 4 \frac{\pi}{4} with respect to the horizontal, just like our lion! Since the sides of a square have equal length and the bird's location is perpendicular to the ground, we can immediately conclude that x l x_l must also equal 45 m 45m .

Now we still need x e x_e . It isn't too hard to see that the angle of depression of the elephant plus some angle must equal π 2 \frac{\pi}{2} , let's call that angle ϵ \overline{\epsilon} , so that we get ϵ + ϵ = π 2 ϵ = π 2 ϵ . \epsilon + \overline{\epsilon} = \frac{\pi}{2} \iff \overline{\epsilon} = \frac{\pi}{2} -\epsilon . What's left is to note that we know the angle ϵ \overline{\epsilon} , the height of the bird and want to know the length of the other leg of the right triangle which the three are part of - this just begs for some trigonometry! So let's take the tangent of ϵ \overline\epsilon : tan ϵ = x e 45 x e = 45 tan ϵ \tan\overline\epsilon = \frac{x_e}{45} \iff x_e = 45\cdot \tan\overline\epsilon That was already the hardest part, but further simplification can make the problem even easier. It can be proven that tan ϵ = tan [ π 2 ϵ ] = cot ( ϵ ) = cot [ π 3 ] = 3 3 . \tan\overline\epsilon =\tan\left[\frac{\pi}{2}-\epsilon\right] = \cot(\epsilon) = \cot\left[\frac{\pi}{3}\right] = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{3}. All that's left to do is plugging in these values! d = x l x e = 45 x e d = 45 45 3 3 d = 45 15 3 \begin{aligned} d = x_l -x_e &= 45 - x_e\\ d&= 45 - \frac{45\cdot\sqrt{3}}{3}\\[10pt] d &=45 - 15\sqrt{3} \end{aligned}

Newton Kayode
Apr 8, 2021

s i n ( A ) a \frac{sin(A)}{a} = s i n ( B ) b \frac{sin(B)}{b} So, we start off with s i n ( 60 ) 45 \frac{sin(60)}{45} = s i n ( 90 ) x \frac{sin(90)}{x} We then cross multiply to get 45 ( s i n ( 90 ) ) 45(sin (90)) = x ( s i n ( 60 ) ) x(sin (60)) 45 = x ( 0.86602540378 ) 45=x(0.86602540378) So x = 51.961 x=51.961 . We then repeat the process to obtain s i n ( 45 ) 51.961 \frac{sin(45)}{51.961} = s i n ( 15 ) y \frac{sin(15)}{y} . We again cross-multiply to obtain 51.961 ( ( 6 2 51.961((\sqrt{6}-\sqrt{2} )/ 4 ) 4) = y\(\frac{1}{\sqrt{2} We finally obtain by rearranging , \frac{y}{\sqrt{2} to get y = 19.019 = 45 15 ( 3 y=19.019=45-15(\sqrt{3} )

Kevin Long
Mar 28, 2021

In the graph above, we can see that the triangle that the elephant is a vertex of is a 30-60-90 triangle. Since the 45 meter side is the long leg, the shorter leg of a 30-60-90 triangle is always the longer leg of the triangle × ( 3 ) 3 \text{longer leg of the triangle}\times \frac{\sqrt(3)}{3} , so the shorter side of the 30-60-90 triangle, which is the distance from the bird to the elephant, is, in this case, 15 ( 3 ) 15\sqrt(3) . The bigger triangle is a 45-45-90 triangle, and because the leg lengths are always the same in a 45-45-90 triangle, the distance from the tree to the lion is 45 meters. Taking the difference between out two distances, we get 45 15 ( 3 ) \boxed{45-15\sqrt(3)} , which is our final answer.

there's your red and blue lines I guess

Kevin Long - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

and my handwriting reveal sry for "unrecognizable handwriting"-mom

Kevin Long - 2 months, 2 weeks ago
Agent T
Mar 26, 2021

Bird witnessed a crime Bird witnessed a crime

Let B 1 \textcolor{#EC7300}{B1} be the distance from tree to 🦁

And B 2 \textcolor{#0C6AC7}{B2} be the distance from tree to 🐘

t a n 45 ° \textcolor{#EC7300}{tan45°} = 45 B 1 \frac{45}{B1}

t a n 60 ° \textcolor{#0C6AC7}{tan60°} = 45 B 2 \frac{45}{B2}

t a n 45 ° \textcolor{#EC7300}{tan45°} =1

t a n 60 ° \textcolor{#0C6AC7}{tan60°} = 3 2 \frac {√3}{2}

Hence B 1 \textcolor{#EC7300}{B1} = 45 1 45*1 and B 2 \textcolor{#0C6AC7}{B2} = 45 3 \frac{45}{√3}

Note:we can rationalise 45 3 \frac{45}{√3} * 3 3 \frac{√3}{√3} to get 15 3 15*√3

To find the distance between the 🦁 and the 🐘: Subtract B 1 \textcolor{#EC7300}{B1} and B 2 \textcolor{#0C6AC7}{B2}

Subtracting the two we get,

45 15 3 \textcolor{limegreen}{ 45-15√3}

Hence option B \boxed{\textcolor{#69047E}{B}} is correct!

Atin Gupta
Mar 26, 2021

α = 30 ° ( 90 ° 45 ° 15 ° ) α = 30° (90° - 45° - 15°)

tan θ = Opposite Adjacent \text{tan θ} = \dfrac{\text{Opposite}}{\text{Adjacent}}

Y = 45 tan α = 45 tan 30° = 45 1 3 = 15 3 3 = 15 3 Y = 45 \text{ tan }α = 45 \text{ tan 30°} = 45 \cdot \dfrac{1}{\sqrt{3}} = \dfrac{15 \cdot 3}{\sqrt{3}} = 15 \sqrt{3}

Z = 45 tan ( α + 15 ° ) = 45 tan ( 30 ° + 15 ° ) = 45 tan 45° = 45 1 = 45 Z = 45 \text{ tan }(α+15°) = 45 \text{ tan } (30° + 15°) = 45 \text{ tan 45°} = 45 \cdot 1 = 45

X = Z Y = 45 15 3 X = Z - Y = \boxed{45 - 15 \sqrt{3}}

Aditya Mittal
Mar 26, 2021

birds eye view birds eye view

Look at the picture. It is given that A B E = 45 ° (the yellow angle) \angle ABE = 45\degree \text{(the yellow angle)} and A B D = 60 ° (the cinnamon angle) \angle ABD = 60\degree \text{(the cinnamon angle)}

From this we get B E C = 45 ° \angle BEC = 45\degree and B D C = 60 ° A B C F and they are alternate interior angles \angle BDC = 60\degree \hspace{5 cm} \because AB \parallel CF \text{and they are alternate interior angles}

We need to find E C D C EC - DC

BEC and BDC are two triangles right-angled at C and we know BC = 45m and also the measures of angles BEC and BDC.

We can use trigonometry for this. We will use t a n θ = o p p o s i t e h y p o t e n u s e tan \theta = \dfrac{opposite}{hypotenuse} to get EC and DC.

For B E C \triangle BEC :

t a n 45 ° = B C E C tan 45\degree = \dfrac{BC}{EC}

E C = B C t a n 45 ° EC = \dfrac{BC}{tan 45\degree}

E C = 45 1 = 45 m EC = \dfrac{45}{1} = 45m

For B D C \triangle BDC :

t a n 60 ° = B C D C tan 60\degree = \dfrac{BC}{DC}

D C = B C t a n 60 ° DC = \dfrac{BC}{tan 60\degree}

D C = 45 3 = 45 3 3 = 15 3 m DC = \dfrac{45}{\sqrt{3}} = \dfrac{45\sqrt{3}}{3} = 15\sqrt{3}m

Now E C D C = 45 m 15 3 m EC - DC = 45m - 15\sqrt{3}m

Therefore, the distance between the lion and the elephant = 45 m 15 3 m \boxed{45m - 15\sqrt{3}m}

Morris Pearl
Mar 25, 2021

This is how I solved it. For the 45 degree angle, it creates an isosceles triangle. The leg along the ground is the same length as the vertical leg, so the lion is 45 meters away.

For the elephant, it is half of an equilateral right triangle, so the leg along the ground is exactly half of the straight line distance between the bird and the elephant. Let x x be the distance to the elephant. Using the pythagorian theorem:

  • 45 2 + x 2 = ( 2 x ) 2 {45}^2 + x^2 = (2x)^2
  • 45 2 + x 2 = 4 x 2 {45}^2 + x^2 = 4x^2
  • 45 2 = 3 x 2 {45}^2 = 3x^2
  • x = 45 3 x = \frac{45}{\sqrt{3}}
  • The answer is 45 ( l i o n ) 45 3 45 (lion) - \frac{45}{\sqrt{3}}
  • 45 15 3 45 - 15 \sqrt{3}

Picture Picture Since a n g l e B A C = a n g l e A C B = 45 angle BAC = angle ACB = 45\circ , A B = B C = 45 m AB = BC = 45 m . We notice that A B D \triangle ABD is a special 30 60 90 30-60-90 triangle, and the ratios of the sides of the triangle is 1 : 3 : 2 1 : \sqrt{3} : 2 . Let B D = x BD = x . According to the ratios of the sides of the triangle, A B = 45 m = x 3 B D = x = 15 3 AB = 45 m = x\sqrt{3} \rightarrow BD = x = 15\sqrt{3} . Now that we already have the measurements, we can calculate the distance between the lion and the elephant, which is 45 15 3 \boxed{ 45-15\sqrt{3} }

Avner Lim - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

Log in to reply

@Brilliant Mathematics can you convert my comment to a solution? I accidentally pressed the wrong option.

Avner Lim - 2 months, 2 weeks ago
Omek K
Mar 25, 2021

Now we need to find DB - DC = BC

in Δ \Delta ABD, by using sin(45) = A D A B \frac{AD}{AB} , we get

1 2 = A D A B A B = A D × 2 = 45 2 m \begin{aligned} \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}&= \frac{AD}{AB}\\ AB&= AD×\sqrt{2}&= 45\sqrt{2} m \end{aligned}

The above image indicates the positions of lion and elephant The above image indicates the positions of lion and elephant

Now by applying sine rule in Δ \Delta ABC, we get

B C S i n ( 15 ) = A B S i n ( 120 ) B C = A B × S i n ( 15 ) S i n ( 120 ) B C = A B × S i n ( 15 ) S i n ( 60 ) u s i n g S i n ( 180 θ ) = S i n ( θ ) \begin{aligned} \frac{BC}{Sin(15)}&= \frac{AB}{Sin(120)}\\ BC&= AB × \frac{Sin(15)}{Sin(120)}\\ BC&= AB × \frac{Sin(15)}{Sin(60)} \Rightarrow using& Sin(180-\theta)&= Sin(\theta) \end{aligned}

Now by substituting the values we get
B C = 45 2 × 3 1 2 2 3 2 = 45 3 1 3 = 45 15 3 \begin{aligned} BC&= 45\sqrt{2} × \normalsize\frac{\frac{\sqrt{3}-1}{2\sqrt{2}}}{\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}}\\ &= 45\frac{\sqrt{3}-1}{\sqrt{3}}\\ &= 45 - 15\sqrt{3} \end{aligned}

Note:

  • Sin(45) = 1 2 \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}
  • Sin(15) = 3 1 2 2 \frac{\sqrt{3}-1}{2\sqrt{2}}
  • Sin(60) = 3 2 \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}

The Sine Rule The Sine Rule

What do you use for your images? I really like the style.

A Former Brilliant Member - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

Log in to reply

I use Samsung notes

Omek K - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

Log in to reply

Ok, cool :)

A Former Brilliant Member - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

Log in to reply

@A Former Brilliant Member Will you be posting more questions now or later, I am running out of questions

Omek K - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

Log in to reply

@Omek K 2 more questions today. After that I will score all solutions and then give results by april :)

A Former Brilliant Member - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

Log in to reply

@A Former Brilliant Member Oh ok and thank you

Omek K - 2 months, 2 weeks ago
Siddhesh Umarjee
Mar 25, 2021

Let the Point where the bird is sitting be B, where the lion is be L, where the elephant is be E.

Simple calculations tell us that A B E = 3 0 \angle {ABE} = 30^{\circ} & A B L = 4 5 \angle {ABL} = 45^{\circ}

In A B L \triangle ABL , A B L = 4 5 \angle {ABL} = 45^{\circ} & A = 9 0 \angle {A} = 90^{\circ} . So A L B = 4 5 \angle {ALB} = 45^{\circ} . Hence A B L \triangle ABL is an isosceles triangle.

Hence , AL = AB = 45m \text {AL = AB = 45m}

We have to find EL = AL - AE = 45 - AE. So EL is less than 45.

Now we can find the answer by eliminating the options (consider 3 = 1.7 \sqrt {3} = 1.7 )

Option 1 : 60 45 3 = 60 45 1.7 = 16.5 60 - 45 \sqrt{3} = 60-45\cdot 1.7 = -16.5 As Distance can't be negative o p t i o n 1 i s e l i m i n a t e d . \color{#D61F06}{option~1~is~eliminated}.

Option 2 : 45 15 3 = 45 15 1.7 = 19.5 45 - 15 \sqrt {3} = 45 - 15 \cdot 1.7 = 19.5 . Cannot be eliminated

Option 3 : 45 + 15 3 45 + 15 \sqrt{3} As d(EL) has to be less than d(AL) = 45 o p t i o n 3 i s e l i m i n a t e d . \color{#D61F06}{option~3~is~eliminated}.

Option 4 : 45 3 15 = 45 1.7 15 = 61.5 45 \sqrt{3} - 15 = 45*1.7 - 15 = 61.5 o p t i o n 4 i s e l i m i n a t e d . \color{#D61F06}{option~4~is~eliminated}. (same reason as for option 3)

Only remaining Option 2 = 45 3 45 - \sqrt{3} is the correct answer.

Zakir Husain
Mar 25, 2021

L e t t h e h o r i z o n t a l d i s t a n c e b e t w e e n t h e b i r d a n d Let\space the\space horizontal\space distance\space between\space the\space \space bird\space and t h e l i o n b e l a n d b e t w e e n t h e b i r d a n d t h e e l e p h a n t b e e the\space lion\space be\space l\space and\space between\space the\space bird\space and\space the\space elephant\space be\space e i n y e l l o w in\space \yellow{yellow\space\triangle} tan 60 ° = 45 m e = 3 \tan \red{60\degree}=\dfrac{45m}{e}=\sqrt{3} e = 45 m × 3 3 × 3 = 45 3 m 3 = 15 3 m \Rightarrow e=\dfrac{45m\red{\times\sqrt{3}}}{\sqrt{3}\red{\times\sqrt{3}}}=\dfrac{45\sqrt{3}m}{3}=15\sqrt{3}m i n g r e e n in\space \green{green\space\triangle} tan 45 ° = 45 m l = 1 \tan \blue{45\degree}=\dfrac{45m}{l}=1 l = 45 m \Rightarrow l=45m D i s t a n c e b e t w e e n t h e b i r d a n d t h e e l e p h a n t = l e = ( 45 15 3 ) m Distance\space between\space the\space bird\space and\space the\space elephant = l-e=(45-15\sqrt{3})\red{m}

Using basics of trigonometry, 45 tan ( 4 5 ) 45 tan ( 3 0 ) = 45 45 3 = 45 15 3 45 \tan(45^{\circ}) - 45 \tan(30^{\circ}) =45 - \dfrac{45}{\sqrt3}=\boxed{45-15\sqrt3}

I don't want to draw lol

Vinayak Srivastava - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

I misread the problem and tried to report, I deleted the report when I understood the question and now it shows I viewed the explanation for some reason?

Devbrat Dandotiya - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

Log in to reply

I think if you delete the report it shows like that, it has happened to me also once.

Vinayak Srivastava - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

Log in to reply

it kinda makes sense because sometimes the unattended reports from others can contain the solution.... i don't know, just guessing

Siddhesh Umarjee - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

I think it is because if you report a problem, its answer is shown to you so that you can crosscheck your report. Did you click the wrong answer and then report, or report before giving an answer?

A Former Brilliant Member - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

Log in to reply

@Percy Jackson I had a typo so I changed it, is it ok?

Vinayak Srivastava - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

Log in to reply

@Vinayak Srivastava Its fine Vinayak.

A Former Brilliant Member - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

I reported it after reading the question, neither did I click an answer nor see an explanation beforehand, it showed I viewed the explanation after I deleted the report

Devbrat Dandotiya - 2 months, 2 weeks ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...