Powder is sprinkled on a plate. When the plate is vibrated at a certain frequency, the powder moves into a pattern.
What is happening where the powder gathers?
Clip excerpted from the YouTube channel
brusspup
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
The whole plate does not have a frequency of 345 hz- it is being vibrated with a 345 Hz sine wave. The grains are gathering/vibrating where the plate is vibrating with a lower amplitude that are not at a frequency of 345 Hz. If the plate is vibrated at another frequency, the pattern will change and the sand will gather and vibrate in a different pattern.
Log in to reply
I think you are confusing frequency with amplitude. Where the sine wave is highest (largest amplitude) it pushes the grains around.
Log in to reply
Perhaps, I could be wrong. ¯_(ツ)_/¯ My understanding of these plates - which might be deficient - is that it is a combination of both. The plate is being driven with a signal at a frequency of 345 Hz and if some parts of the plate have a resonant frequency at that frequency the plate vibrates with greater amplitude at that frequency. The parts of the plate that have no resonance at the frequency of 345 Hz are not vibrating and have minimal or no amplitude at a frequency of 345 Hz. The plate itself might vibrate at a multitude of resonant frequencies- the plate does not just have one resonant frequency. There can be however dominate resonant frequencies contained in the object where vibrations at certain frequencies will have greater amplitudes than at other frequencies. This can be demonstrated by driving the plate with a signal at another frequency.
Log in to reply
@Warren Cowley – I see your point. Maybe there are other frequencies arising from the plate itself. Then there are multiple sine waves that cancel each other out. This isn't my area of expertise. We'd need someone else to weigh in.
The choice of correct answer is still clear. It isn't the frequency at the places where the grains stay still.
Log in to reply
@Jeremy Galvagni – Thanks and - yes, I agree the answer is clearly correct. My quibble with the solution you provided is that you state that the whole plate has the same frequency of 345 Hz. From my understanding as a result of being an audio engineer and musician for over 30 years, is that if an object has a resonant frequency- it will also, most likely have resonate frequencies in a harmonic series. This does not necessarily apply to objects like bells or percussion instruments, as the resonate frequencies in objects like that are a bit more random or chaotic.
But, I would welcome the expertise of others on this as I could always learn something new or be mistaken in my understanding. I did find this: "Rigid and semi-rigid bodies possess an (in principle) infinite number of natural frequencies of vibration at which the object “wants” to move. " .. Source: https://skullsinthestars.com/2013/05/02/physics-demonstrations-chladni-patterns/
But the grains were scattered on the plate randomly at first. If the amplitude is low, the grains don't move vigorously. Then isn't that they don't gather as well? I'm still confused.And BTW is the frequency not able to be changed because of the information provided?
Log in to reply
In places with higher amplitude, the grains are eventually pushed away by the vigorous movement. They keep moving until they reach a place of lower amplitude. Here, they will not move as much. The general effect is that the grains move toward areas of lower amplitude.
Please participate in my Question Game here
Simple and good
When the Chladni plate in the gif used for this problem is vibrated with a frequency of 345 hz the parts of the plate that have a resonant frequency of 345 hz vibrate with a larger amplitude than the parts of the plate that do not. The parts of the plate that are not vibrating at the resonant frequency of 345 hz have no or very low amplitudes hence the grains of sand gather in the parts of the plate with lower or no amplitudes. If the experiment is continued with different frequencies the patterns will change depending upon the resonant frequencies of each part of the plate. For a detailed explanation of this phenomenon read:
It's sort of like a Kundt's tube experiment which determines the speed of sound in gases At the nodes(of the standing wave),which have theoretically 0 amplitude,the heaps are formed Almost the same phenomenon occurs here too
Log in to reply
Yes! It is a related demonstration of the same principles. :-)
Please participate in my Question Game here
It's the same concept as a standing wave on a string, but extrapolated to 2D. Given the properties of the string including tightness and length, there will be nodes at which the string doesn't go up or down, as the +/- interference cancels perfectly at a single and steady location.
These nodes are seen as lines and loops on the 2D oscillating face, and if you watch YouTube videos (https://youtu.be/1yaqUI4b974) of monotonically increasing pitch, you see that, like standing waves on a string, the patterns seen are quantized. Only certain patterns exist, and only at distinct, definable frequencies. Any frequency that deviates from the quantized frequencies will demonstrate weak pattern formation or complete loss of pattern formation. Finally, as with string standing waves, the higher the frequency, the more sensitive to deviation the standing waves become. That is, high Hz standing waves require much higher precision of quantized frequency matching than low Hz.
First thing you should make out is that the frequency of the entire thing will remain same that is 345hz. hence we can remove the first two options so we are left with two options now imagine the powder at a closer look now we have two cases that are 1. the place is vibrating with larger amplitude: if that is the case then the power would slide towards a lower religion due to the gravitational force on it 2. the place is vibrating with a lower amplitude: hence this is the correct option to be considered. Because the place with lower amplitude can hold the powder between two places of higher amplitude.
Hence the correct option is that "THE PLACES ARE VIBRATING WITH A LOWER AMPLITUDE".
As the frequency is same on the whole plate, so our concern is on the amplitude.. Now where amplitude is more,the energy will be automatically increase. The places whereth powder cant stay are of higher energies. So its obvious for the places where the powder gathers to be of lower energy. So lower amplitude is the correct answer.
When liquids are subjected to vibrations, such as a rock being dropped in the middle of a puddle, the waves radiate out getting lower and lower amplitudes till there is no amplitude at all. The powder spreads out in a similar pattern, forming a picture of the amplitude waves being produced, strongest and highest at the center and dissipating at the outer edges.
345 hz is the 5 th harmonic of super glu's resonant frequency, so it will gather where that combines with that of the gluons.
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
The whole plate has the same frequency: 345 Hz. So that rules out two of the answers.
Amplitude is the energy. In this case, up and down motion. If the amplitude is high, the grains are going to get bounced about randomly. If the amplitude is low, they will not get bumped hard enough to move. So the grains settle where the amplitude is low.