Coulomb's choreography

Exact solutions for many-body problems are rarely encountered in physics. The following problem deals with a non-trivial motion of four charges. Due to the symmetry of the problem it is possible to determine the trajectories of the charges analytically.

Four identical particles with mass m m and charge + q +q , orbit a charge q -q as shown in the figure. The four positive charges always form a square of side l ( t ) l(t) while the negative charge stays at rest at the center of the square. The motion of the charges is periodic with period T T . That is, if the vectors r k ( t ) \vec{r}_k(t) , k = { 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 } k=\{1,2,3,4\} , describe the position of the charges then we have that r k ( t + T ) = r k ( t ) . \vec{r}_{k}(t+T)=\vec{r}_{k}(t). It is also known that the side of the square oscillates between l min = 1 4 L 0 l_{\textrm{min}}=\frac{1}{4}L_{0} and l max = L 0 l_{\textrm{max}}=L_{0} . Determine the period T in seconds if the parameters q , m q, m and L 0 L_{0} satisfy the relation k q 2 m L 0 3 = 1 0 4 s 2 , where k = 1 4 π ϵ 0 . \frac{k q^{2}}{m L_{0}^{3}}=10^{4}~\mbox{s}^{-2}, \quad \textrm{where} \quad k=\frac{1}{4\pi \epsilon_{0}}.

Details and assumptions

  • Ignore any radiation from the charges.


The answer is 0.089.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

1 solution

David Mattingly Staff
May 13, 2014

We begin by noting that resulting force exerted on any of the charges is always directed toward the center center of square. Let l l be the side of the square at a specific moment in time. Then the total force acting on a charge is given by F = F 1 + F 2 + F 3 + F 4 , \vec{F}=\vec{F}_{1}+\vec{F}_{2}+\vec{F}_{3}+\vec{F}_{4}, as shown in the figure below.

It is relatively simple to find its magnitude. Using some trigonometry we find that F = k q ( ( 3 2 2 ) 2 q ) l 2 = k q ( ( 3 2 2 ) 4 q ) r 2 F=k \frac{q ( \frac{(3-2\sqrt{2})}{2}q)}{l^{2}}=k \frac{q ( \frac{(3-2\sqrt{2})}{4}q)}{r^{2}} where r = l 2 r=\frac{l}{\sqrt{2}} is the distance from the charge to the center of the square. This is a very important observation because it suggests that if we want to describe the motion of one charge, the rest of the charges can be replaced by an effective charge Q e f f = ( 3 2 2 ) 4 q Q_{eff}=- \frac{(3-2\sqrt{2})}{4}q located at the center of the square. In addition, since both Coulomb and Gravitational forces are of the form F = γ / r 2 F= \gamma/r^{2} the orbit of any or the charges must be elliptical.

In the figure below, we show the positions of the charges corresponding to r m a x = l m a x 2 r_{max}=\frac{ l_{max}}{\sqrt{2}} and r m i n = l m i n 2 . r_{min}=\frac{l_{min}}{\sqrt{2}}.

The semi-major axis of the ellipses is a = r m i n + r m a x 2 = 5 8 2 L 0 . a=\frac{r_{min}+r_{max}}{2}=\frac{5}{8\sqrt{2}}L_{0}. Kepler's law states that the orbital period depends only on the semi-major axis. Consider a planet describing an elliptical orbit around the sun, then Kepler's law tells you that the period is given by T = 2 π a 3 G M s . T=2 \pi \sqrt{\frac{a^{3}}{GM_{s}}}. Thus, by exploiting the similarity between Coulomb and Gravitational forces we can write T = 2 π a 3 k q Q e f f / m = 5 π 8 5 2 ( 3 2 2 ) k q 2 / m L 0 3 = 0.089 s . T= 2 \pi \sqrt{\frac{a^{3}}{k q|Q_{eff}|/m}}= \frac{5\pi}{8}\sqrt{\frac{5}{\sqrt{2}(3-2\sqrt{2})kq^{2}/mL_{0}^{3}}}=0.089~\mbox{s}.

that's really some work but i did it too....:P

A Former Brilliant Member - 4 years, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

Oh so it was Kepler's analogy as well.I didn't notice that.I rather went in the calculus way and got the correct answer.

Spandan Senapati - 4 years ago

Log in to reply

i did using calculus too

Log in to reply

@A Former Brilliant Member This is a nice problem.....Has less no of solvers...Davids method was the same but he used the previously proved results in case of elliptical orbits..So that is great linking.

Spandan Senapati - 4 years ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...