3 of 100: A Pythagorean Spiral

Geometry Level 2

Which triangle has an area of 1?

If you ever need to construct a line that is, in theory, N \sqrt{N} units long, now you know one way to do it! Can you design another construction technique?

A B C D E

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

27 solutions

Siva Budaraju
Jun 2, 2017

Triangle A has hypotenuse 2 \sqrt{2} and area 1 2 \frac{1}{2} .

Triangle B has hypotenuse 3 \sqrt{3} and area 2 2 \frac{\sqrt{2}}{2} .

Triangle C has hypotenuse 4 \sqrt{4} = 2 and area 3 2 \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2} .

Triangle D has hypotenuse 5 \sqrt{5} and area 1.

Triangle E has hypotenuse 6 \sqrt{6} and area 5 2 \frac{\sqrt{5}}{2} .

Therefore, we can see that Triangle D has an area of 1.

what is that construction technique

sam dave - 4 years ago

Log in to reply

Use of 45-45-90 triangle: the first 1 has sides 1, so hypothenusa is sqrt(2). From there it's Pythagoras.

Peter van der Linden - 4 years ago
Joel Kang
Jun 2, 2017

Since triangle A has hypotenuse sqrt(2), each consecutive triangle after a would be sqrt(2+n) where n is the nth position after triangle A.

The hypotenuse we are looking for is sqrt(4) because (1) it is an integer and (2) the area of the next triangle would equal (sqrt(4) * 1) / 2.

We see that triangle C has the hypotenuse of sqrt(4), but we are looking for the triangle with a side of sqrt(4), so the answer is D.

what do you think about another technique to form a line of length N \sqrt{N} .

@Ashish Siva @Siva Budaraju @Joel Kang @Richard Desper @sam dave

ABHIJIT DIXIT - 4 years ago

Log in to reply

What do you mean?

Siva Budaraju - 4 years ago

Log in to reply

@Siva Budaraju if you see complete question till the end you'll find a note giving info about difficulty level Just beside that this bonus question is given

ABHIJIT DIXIT - 4 years ago

Log in to reply

@Abhijit Dixit You could take a number line, draw a right triangle on it of sides 1, √N. Then the hypotenuse will be √(N+1). Use a compass to rotate the hypotenuse onto the number line. Voila, you have a line of √(N+1) units. Now repeat the process to get √(N+2), √(N+3), ..... units.

Siva Budaraju - 4 years ago

Log in to reply

@Siva Budaraju Yup... And this is what they have used here. I was just stressing on the word ""ANOTHER CONSTRUCTION TECHNIQUE"

ABHIJIT DIXIT - 4 years ago

Log in to reply

@Abhijit Dixit No, here they used right triangles that shared sides. My technique is similar but not the same.

Siva Budaraju - 4 years ago

Depending on the value of N, you could find a pair of squares a^2, b^2 such that a^2 + b^2 = N. If there's no pair, there might be a triple. That would probably be faster than using (N-1) triangles.

Richard Desper - 4 years ago

Log in to reply

yes sir that's a different approach. well would that be true for all n?

ABHIJIT DIXIT - 4 years ago
Sharky Kesa
Jun 3, 2017

Note that the hypotenuses of each right triangle slowly increase as you go around the spiral (called the Spiral of Theodorus). As given by the other solutions, the base length of D D is 4 = 2 \sqrt{4}=2 , so the area of D D is 1. My solution is more focused on constructing a line segment of N \sqrt{N} .

Consider a line segment A B AB of length N + 1 N+1 . Let C C be a point on A B AB such that A C = 1 AC=1 and B C = N BC=N . Let O O be the midpoint of A B AB . Consider a circle centred at O O passing through A A and B B . Let this intersect the perpendicular from C C to A B AB at D D and E E . We have C D = C E = N CD=CE=\sqrt{N} .

brilliant soln

Biswajit Barik - 4 years ago

Log in to reply

computerisation

George I'Anson-Hancock - 2 years, 10 months ago

Log in to reply

yes i agree

George I'Anson-Hancock - 2 years, 10 months ago

i also aim for making a line segment of desired quantity

Biswajit Barik - 4 years ago

Please explain the line ''Let this intersect the perpendicular from C to AB at D and E.'' I am unable to understand.

Nawal Singh - 3 years, 12 months ago

Log in to reply

Put your pencil on point C and draw a line that's perpendicular to AB. That will intersect the circle in two points, that get called E and D.

Stefano Ottolenghi - 3 years, 11 months ago

Why would the length be exactly sqrt(N)? It may be trivial but I don't get it.

Stefano Ottolenghi - 3 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

It's a result following directly from Pythagoras' Theorem. Note that O D = N + 1 2 OD=\frac{N+1}{2} and O C = N + 1 2 1 = N 1 2 OC = \frac{N+1}{2}-1=\frac{N-1}{2} . Thus, by Pythagoras' Theorem, we have C D = ( N + 1 2 ) 2 ( N 1 2 ) 2 = N CD=\sqrt{\left (\frac{N+1}{2} \right )^2 - \left (\frac{N-1}{2} \right )^2} = \sqrt{N} . Thus, proven.

Sharky Kesa - 3 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

Marvelous, thanks! :)

Stefano Ottolenghi - 3 years, 11 months ago
Venkatachalam J
Jun 5, 2017

Relevant wiki: Area Of Triangle

The given triangles are right angled triangle, we can easily find hypotenuse using pythagoras theoram & area of the triangle.

How you created this diagram?

Munem Shahriar - 3 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

Microsoft paint and word

Venkatachalam J - 3 years, 11 months ago
Ashish Menon
Jun 2, 2017

Observe that the length of the hypotenuse of the n t h n^{th} triangle that follows the pattern is n + 1 \sqrt {n+1} . Since our area of the triangle required is 1, the length of one of its legs should be 2 2 . The hypotenuse of the n t h n^{th} triangle is one leg of the n + 1 t h {n+1}^{th} triangle.

So, first find which triangle has hypotenuse 2 = 4 2 = \sqrt {4} .
n + 1 = 2 n = 3 \sqrt {n+1} = 2\\ n = 3

So, the traingle is n + 1 = 4 i.e. D n+1 = 4 \ \text {i.e.} \ \boxed {D}

Mohammad Khaza
Jun 13, 2017

at first if we think about triangle A.it's hypotenuse is root over 2.and area is 0.5.

in triangle B there is a hypotenuse of root over 3 and area is 0.71.

in case of triangle C it has a hypotenuse of 2 and it's area is 0.87.

in triangle D it has a hypotenuse of root over 5 and area of 1.

so.D is the answer

nice solution.

Halima Tahmina - 3 years, 12 months ago

Log in to reply

thanks for your comment

Mohammad Khaza - 3 years, 12 months ago
Richard Desper
Jun 2, 2017

For triangle X X let h X h_X be the length of its hypotenuse. Then h C 2 = 1 2 + h B 2 h_C^2 = 1^2 + h_B^2 and h B 2 = 1 2 + h A 2 h_B^2 = 1^2+ h_A^2 while h A 2 = 1 2 + 1 2 = 2 h_A^2 = 1^2 + 1^2 = 2 .

Thus h C 2 = 1 + ( 1 + h A 2 ) = 1 + 1 + 2 = 4 h_C^2 = 1 + (1 + h_A^2) = 1 + 1 + 2 =4 . So h C = 2 h_C = 2 . Since h C h_C is the base of triangle D D , its area is ( 1 / 2 ) 1 2 = 1 (1/2) * 1 * 2 = 1 .

O.S. Gerken
May 26, 2020

The following is an expanded explanation for someone like myself, who struggles with math.

To arrive at the solution, I used two formulas:

  1. The formula for the area of a triangle, Area = .5(bh)
  2. The formula for the hypotenuse of a triangle, a 2 b 2 = c 2 a^{2} * b^{2} = c^{2}

In preparing to solve this problem, I wrote down the information I already knew from looking at the diagram:

  1. I know all of these triangles are right triangles
  2. I know all of these triangles have a base that is 1 unit in length

The problem asks us to determine which triangle has an area of 1. Well, since I know from the diagram that all the triangles have a base length of 1, I have enough information to determine what the height of the "winning" triangle should be:

Area = 1

Base = 1

Height = h

Using the formula for the area of a triangle, I solved for h :

1 = .5(1 * h )

1 = .5( h )

1 = .5 h

( divide both sides by .5 )

2 = h

So I now know that the triangle I'm looking for will have a base of 1 and a height of 2.

Obviously, this eliminates triangle A immediately, as triangle A has a base of 1 and a height of 1.

Now, the trickier part (for me, anyway): Using the Pythagorean theorem, a 2 b 2 = c 2 a^{2} * b^{2} = c^{2} , I determined the length of the unknown height side of triangle B.

Why?

Looking at triangle A and triangle B, we see that they share a side. For triangle A, that side is its hypotenuse. For triangle B, that side is it's height. Because the value of triangle A's hypotenuse and triangle B's height are equal, if we solve a 2 b 2 = c 2 a^{2} * b^{2} = c^{2} for triangle A, we will get the value of the height side for triangle B.

In this case, for triangle A:

a 2 b 2 = c 2 a^{2} * b^{2} = c^{2}

1 2 1 2 = c 2 1^{2} * 1^{2} = c^{2}

1 + 1 = c 2 c^{2}

2 = c 2 c^{2}

( take the square root of both sides )

c = 2 \sqrt{2}

Now, for triangle B I know that:

base = 1

height = 2 \sqrt{2}

Using the formula for area, I test to see if triangle B is my winning triangle:

Area = .5(bh)

Area = .5(1 * 2 \sqrt{2} )

Area = .707

Since the area did not equal 1, we know triangle B is not the winner.

Onward!

The next step is to repeat the use of a 2 b 2 = c 2 a^{2} * b^{2} = c^{2} , this time solving for the hypotenuse of triangle B/height of triangle C. When we do this, we find:

a 2 b 2 = c 2 a^{2} * b^{2} = c^{2}

2 2 1 2 = c 2 \sqrt{2}^{2} * 1^{2} = c^{2}

2 + 1 = c 2 c^{2}

3 = c 2 c^{2}

( take the square root of both sides )

c = 3 \sqrt{3}

Now we solve for area again:

Area = .5(bh)

Area = .5(1 * 3 \sqrt{3} )

Area = .866

Just like triangle B, triangle C is not our winner!

We repeat the use of a 2 b 2 = c 2 a^{2} * b^{2} = c^{2} , this time solving for the hypotenuse of triangle C/height of triangle D. When we do this, we find:

a 2 b 2 = c 2 a^{2} * b^{2} = c^{2}

3 2 1 2 = c 2 \sqrt{3}^{2} * 1^{2} = c^{2}

3 + 1 = c 2 c^{2}

3 = c 2 c^{2}

( take the square root of both sides )

c = 4 \sqrt{4}

c= 2

(oh boy!)

Now we solve for area again:

Area = .5(bh)

Area = .5(1 * 2)

Area = 1

Ding ding ding! We have a winner!

Triangle D has a base of 1 and a height of 2. Using the formula for area of a triangle when we want Area to equal 1, we find that:

1 = .5(1 * 2)

1 = 1

Triangle D is the correct answer.

James Hensman
May 18, 2018

The Hyponause (H) increases by the root

For A it is root 2 (ajaicent of B) Then For B it is root 3 as 1 + root 2 squared is 3 then root 3. Then for C’s H is root 4 or 2

2 times 1 over 2 is one therefore it is D

Neil Myatt
Aug 11, 2017

A non-mathematical intuition approach: A is clearly half a square. Find the triangle that has double the area of A. D is the most likely, as C is clearly less than double, and E is clearly more than double. The question implies that one triangle has exactly area of 1, so D must be the answer. I know this will annoy all the topologists :-)

Forrest Henslee
Jul 13, 2017

I like to solve using a programming language as practice, in this case R:

hyp <- function(b) {
  a = 1
  c = sqrt(a^2 + b^2)
  return(c)
 }

 b <- rep(0, 5)
 b[1] = 1

 for (i in 2:5) {
  b[i] = hyp(b[i-1])
 }

 area = .5 * b * 1

The fourth element of the area vector equals 1, which corresponds to triangle D.

Kr Decker
Jul 1, 2017

The hypotenusal series is A. root(2), B. root(3), C. root(4), D.root(5) . . . Since the a-legs of the triangles are all 1 unit, the triangle with an area of 1 will be the triangle whose b-leg = 2. This will be successor to the triangle whose hypotenuse is root(4), ie, triangle D.

John Shugg
Jun 10, 2017

Would have been a lot easier to work out with a static picture. Every time i started tracing out the lines of the triangles they would disappear when the stupid animation restarted.

Khushal Jhalani
Jun 5, 2017

The area of a right-angled triangle is a b 2 \frac{ab}{2} where a and b are the sides in which the angles between these 2 sides is 90 degree. So we calculate the area for every triangle (and before that we have to calculate Hypotenuse because every hypotenuse is either 'a' or 'b' of another right angled triangle. Hence we finally get the are of triangle D is 1.

John Ferris
Jun 5, 2017

I figured that since the area of a was one half it was either d or e d looked about double a in area

Vu Vincent
Jun 5, 2017

x 1 2 = 1 x = 4 \frac { \sqrt { x } \cdot 1 }{ 2 } =1 \\ \Leftrightarrow \quad x=4

we need the side length that is 4 = 2 \sqrt {4} = 2 long , and its the D triangle that has hypotenuse length 4 \sqrt {4} long

Therefore the triangle that has area of 1 unit squared is D D

Jonathan Dapadap
Jun 4, 2017

If you are going to observe the pattern, it will go like this.

Area of Triangle = (√n)/2

Since the area to be found is 1,

(√n)/2 = 1

√n = 2, square both sides and we have:

n = 4.

So, the triangle which has an area of 1 unit square is the sequence 4 which is D.

Therefore the answer is D

Sara C
Jun 4, 2017

same general process but I approached it from a slightly different starting point.

I looked slowly are the desired area:

1 2 b a s e h e i g h t = 1 \frac{1}{2}*base*height = 1

As we have right angled triangles, we can use the height as always 1 and the base as the line shared with the neighbouring triangle

1 2 b a s e 1 = 1 \frac{1}{2}*base*1 = 1

1 2 b a s e = 1 \frac{1}{2}*base= 1

b a s e = 2 base = 2

Observe the base of each triangle is is the hypotenuse of preceding one, so we need to work out the hypotenuse of each triangle until we have one that is equal to 2, then we know the answer is the triangle with that line as its base.

using Pythagoras' theorem we get the hypotenuse of each triangle to be:

t r i a n g l e A = > s q r t 2 triangleA => sqrt2

t r i a n g l e B = > s q r t 3 triangleB => sqrt3

t r i a n g l e C = > s q r t 4 = 2 triangleC => sqrt4 = 2

Now we have this information we can say triangle D has a base of 2 and therefore the correct answer is D D

Ivan Kwek
Jun 4, 2017
  • || r o w 1 c o l 1 r o w 1 c o l 2 r o w 2 c o l 1 r o w 2 c o l 2 d e n o m i n a t o r \frac{row 1 col 1||row 1 col 2|| ||row 2 col 1||row 2 col 2}{**denominator**} ||
Cynthia Toliver
Jun 3, 2017

Triangle A has a hypotenuse of sqrt 2; Triangle B has a hypotenuse of sqrt 3; Triangle C has a hypotenuse of sqrt 4 or 2. Hypotenuse of triangle C is leg of triangle D. Area of triangle D = 1 2 \frac{1}{2} (2) (1) = 1

Avianna Gay
Jun 3, 2017

Triangle D has a hypotenuse of ✓5 which means that the longest side of Triangle D is :✓[ (✓5)^2-(1)^2]=✓(4)=2 .

Thus the area of Triangle D is :

(1/2)×1×2=1 sq. units

Omf Omf
Jun 3, 2017

The letter S stands for the area of the triangle and the letter H represents the hypotenuse of the triangle. So S(A) = 1 * 1 * 1/2 = 1/2 H(A) = √(1² + 1²) = √2 According to what I have said , We can find that when it comes to the triangle C , the H of is the sqrt of (1² + (√3)²) and it equals 2 , So the S of D equals 2 times 1 then times 1/2 . The result is the number " 1 ".

Ei Young
Jun 3, 2017

Once I figured out that the hypotenuse is the height of the next triangle, along with the fact that the base is always 1, (knowing that 1/2 base times height is area) ..well 1/2 of 2 is 1 and the problem was solved when I saw the hypotenuse of 2.

Majed Kalaoun
Jun 3, 2017

The hypotenuse of triangle A is 2 \sqrt{2}

The hypotenuse of triangle B is 2 + 1 \sqrt{2+1}

The hypotenuse of triangle C is 2 + 2 = 2 \sqrt{2+2}=2

We should also note that the hypotenuse of triangle C is the length of the base of triangle D. Thus the area of triangle D will be
2 1 2 = 1 \frac{2⋅1}{2}=1

Refath Bari
Jun 3, 2017

The area for a triangle is 1 2 b h \frac { 1 }{ 2 } bh . The height for all the triangles is 1, and the area must be 1. Thus, we set the equation to 1, and get b = 2 b = 2 . To find the base that equals 2, we know first of all, that the sum of the base and heights of all the triangles will be the root of the hypotenuse. Thus, if the hypotenuse of the 1st triangle is 2 \sqrt { 2 } , the hypotenuse of the 3rd triangle is 4 \sqrt {4} , which will also serve as the base for the 4th triangle, which will thus have an area of 1.

Gaurav Arora
Jun 3, 2017

https://ibb.co/k6hvXa Solution is here

Aidan Joyce
Jun 3, 2017

The hypotenuse of the nth triangle is ( n + 1 ) \sqrt{(n+1)}

\Rightarrow The area of the nth triangle is 1 n 2 \frac{1 * \sqrt{n}}{2} = n 2 \frac{\sqrt{n}}{2}

Area = 1

n 2 \Rightarrow \frac{\sqrt{n}}{2} = 1

n \Rightarrow \sqrt{n} = 2

\Rightarrow n = 4

\Rightarrow Triangle D has area 2

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...