Let reals a , b , c satisfy:
a + b = 1 5 ,
a b + c = 7 4 ,
a c = 1 2 0 .
Find the sum of all possible values of a .
This is a simpler version (and a hint) of the problem Equations and Polynomials and is part of the set ... and polynomials
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
Here getting the 3 r d degree equation and applying Vieta's sum is not enough. Because it is mentioned in the question that a , b , c ∈ R . So you also need to show that this equation has all three real roots. @sujoy roy @Joel Tan
Log in to reply
By some calculation roots for above equation are 6,5,4.
Indeed. It is important to verify that the roots are real, in order to conclude that there are corresponding real values of a . This mistake was made in subsequent questions, which invalidated the final answer.
It's clear that this doesn't have a triple root. Thus taking the second derivative for inflection points we get a=5. Plugging in 5 we find 5 to be a root of the equation. Thus since the inflection point is at zero and there isn't a triple root (there must be up and down curves), there are three real roots.
Nice and elegant!
Is there another method that will work for this question and the other harder one?
Log in to reply
Some thing is getting to me. If you add all the equations and factor, you get 2 1 0 = ( a + 1 ) ( b + c + 1 )
Btw, I edited the first line of your solution to say 74a
a + b = 1 5 ,
a b + c = 7 4 ,
a c = 1 2 0 . From 1. b = 1 5 − a , , from 3. c = a 1 2 0 ,
Putting the values on 2
We get a ( 1 5 − a ) + a 1 2 0 = 7 4
or, a 3 − 1 5 a 2 + 7 4 a − 1 2 0 = 0
or, ( a − 5 ) 3 − ( a − 5 ) = 0
or, ( a − 5 ) [ ( a − 5 ) 2 − 1 ] = 0
or, ( a − 5 ) ( a − 4 ) ( a − 6 ) = 0
Either a = 5 ,or a = 4 ,or a = 6
Sum of the possible values of a = 4 + 5 + 6 = 1 5
Just a small correction. In the second last line it should be x-6.
hello i want to modify the solution as we can use the veitas formulae to find the the sum than breaking the cubic equation a+b+c=-b/a=15/1=15
We can see that a are roots of the polynomial P ( x ) = x 3 − 1 5 x 2 + 7 4 x − 1 2 0 . Let's try to find rational roots. If x = q p , then q 3 P ( x ) ≡ − 1 2 0 q 3 m o d p ; since p , q must be coprime, it follows that p ∣ 1 2 0 ; with q as the modulo, we can find that q = 1 . Trying out the first few divisors of 1 2 0 , we can see that 4 , 5 , 6 are roots and P ( x ) = ( x − 4 ) ( x − 5 ) ( x − 6 ) . Therefore, a = 4 , 5 , 6 are all solutions.
Can you explain why is a a root of that polynomial?
Log in to reply
I'm trying to stay conscious right now, so here's a link . By this, rational roots must be (integer) divisors of 120. We just try them by increasing abs. value and get lucky quickly.
Log in to reply
I'm not asking how to factorize the polynomial. I understand that there are various ways of doing so, and the rational root theorem is one of them.
My question is, how do you know that the first line is true? You stated that "We can see that a are roots of the polynomial P ( x ) = x 3 − 1 5 x 2 + 7 4 x − 1 2 0 ." How do we see that?
From Sujoy's solution, I know that this is true, but it takes some work. It seems to me that you had a fast/simple way of understanding why this must be true, which is why you didn't add an explanation.
Log in to reply
@Calvin Lin – Oh. Brute force expressing c = 7 4 − a b = 7 4 − a ( 1 5 − a ) and stuffing it into a c = 1 2 0 . There's literally no thinking behind this.
Log in to reply
@Jakub Šafin – Ah I see, so something similar to what Sujoy did, though harder to motivate why it works. Thanks!
Notice that
( x + a ) ( x 2 + b x + c ) = x 3 + ( a + b ) x 2 + ( a b + c ) x + a c
We substitute the above values in to get
x 3 + 1 5 x 2 + 7 4 x + 1 2 0 = ( x + a ) ( x 2 + b x + c ) ( x + a )
Since x 3 + 1 5 x 2 + 7 4 x + 1 2 0 = ( x + 4 ) ( x + 5 ) ( x + 6 ) , we can have the value of a to be one of 4 , 5 , 6 and the other quadratic would be the product of he other two brackets. Thus, the sum of all values of a is 15.
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
Multiply equation 2 by a , we get a 2 b + a c = 7 4 a
or, a 2 ( 1 5 − a ) + 1 2 0 = 7 4 a (using equations 1 and 3 )
or, a 3 − 1 5 a 2 + 7 4 a − 1 2 0 = 0
Sum of all possible values of a is 1 5 .