Good Driver, Bad Decisions

Devin is a troublemaker. While driving, Devin happens to see a police car stopped at a red light. Being the instigator that he is, Devin promptly pulls up his car even with the cop's, rolls down the window and throws a burrito in the cop's face . Immediately, Devin speeds off, knowing that he's in big trouble. The cop leaves the light at the same time, tailing closely behind.

Even though Devin loves to break the rules, he doesn't want to get in trouble for more than throwing a burrito. Because of this, Devin stops at every stop sign on the road, and slows down appropriately for each one. Ironically, the cop only cares about catching Devin and drives straight through every stop sign. Eventually, the policeman catches up with Devin, but not after traveling quite a ways down the road. How far did the policeman have to travel in order to catch up to Devin? Round your answer to the nearest thousandth of a meter.

Details and Assumptions

  • Devin and the cop start even with their front bumpers even at the stop light, and we are looking for the next point in time where the cop's front bumper is once again even with Devin's.

  • Both drivers start at 0 m/s 0 \text{ m/s} .

  • Devin drives at a constant rate of 50 m/s 50\text{ m/s} , but when a stop sign is approaching, he slows down at a rate of 25 m/s 2 25 \text{ m/s}^2 and reaches 0 m/s 0 \text{ m/s} just as he reaches the stop sign, then immediately begins to reaccelerates at the same speed of 25 m/s 2 25\text{m/s}^2 until he reaches 50 m/s 50\text{ m/s} again. Devin always accelerates and decelerates at 25 m/s 2 25\text{m/s}^2 .

  • The policeman starts at 0 m/s 0 \text{ m/s} at the light, then accelerates continuously at a rate of 3 m/s 2 3 \text{ m/s}^2 until he catches Devin.

  • There is a stop sign every 300 m 300 \text{ m} down the road, and the first one is 300 m 300 \text{ m} from the stop light.

  • Ignore friction and wind resistance.


The answer is 903.719.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Garrett Clarke
Jul 5, 2015

Our first step should be to find formulas to calculate the distance each person travels as a function of time. We'll denote D ( t ) D(t) and P ( t ) P(t) as Devin and the policeman's distance formulas, respectively.

Finding P ( t ) P(t) is easy. Using the formula d = v i t + 1 2 a t 2 d=v_it+\frac{1}{2}at^2 :

P ( t ) = 1 2 ( 3 m / s 2 ) t 2 = 3 2 t 2 P(t) = \frac{1}{2}(3m/s^2)t^2=\frac{3}{2}t^2

Finding D ( t ) D(t) is a little bit harder. First, let's find how far away Devin has to be from the stop light in order for him to come to a complete stop at the stop sign. Using the formula v f 2 = v i 2 + 2 a d v_f^2=v_i^2+2ad :

( 0 m / s ) 2 = ( 50 m / s ) 2 + 2 ( 25 m / s 2 ) d d = 5 0 2 2 ( 25 ) = 50 m (0m/s)^2=(50m/s)^2+2(25m/s^2)d \Longrightarrow d = \frac{50^2}{2(25)}=50m

t = v a = 50 m / s 25 m / s 2 = 2 s t=\frac{v}{a}=\frac{50m/s}{25m/s^2}=2s , therefore it takes 2 s 2s to travel the 50 m 50m required to slow down. This will be the same time and distance required to speed up, so a total 100 m 100m out of the 300 m 300m is spent accelerating and decelerating. The other 200 m 200m , Devin is traveling at a constant speed of 50 m / s 50m/s , which takes t = d v = 200 m 50 m / s = 4 s t=\frac{d}{v}=\frac{200m}{50m/s}=4s . Therefore, it takes 2 s + 4 s + 2 s = 8 s 2s+4s+2s=8s to travel the 300 m 300m in between each stop sign; 2 s 2s to accelerate, 4 s 4s to travel 200 m 200m , then 2 s 2s more to decelerate to a stop. If we follow this general idea that it takes Devin 8 s 8s to travel 300 m 300m , then we can have a simplified formula of D ( t ) = 300 ( t 8 ) D(t)=300\bigg(\frac{t}{8}\bigg) . Please note that this formula is only valid when t = 8 n t=8n , AKA he is at a stop sign.

Let's just start by seeing how many stop signs Devin can get to and still be ahead of the cop.

P ( t ) < D ( t ) P(t) < D(t)

3 2 t 2 < 300 ( t 8 ) \frac{3}{2}t^2 < 300\bigg(\frac{t}{8}\bigg)

t 2 < 25 t t^2 < 25t

0 < t < 25 0 < t < 25

Again, Devin's formula is only valid when t = 8 n t=8n , so we can only trust the formula up until t = 24 t=24 , AKA he has passed three stop signs and traveled 900 m 900m . How far has the policeman traveled in this time? P ( 24 ) = 3 2 ( 24 ) 2 = 864 m P(24)=\frac{3}{2}(24)^2=864m .

At this point the cop is moving pretty fast at a speed of v = a t = ( 3 m / s 2 ) ( 24 s ) = 72 m / s v=at=(3m/s^2)(24s)=72m/s , so let's check to see if he catches Devin while he's accelerating after the 3 3 rd stop sign.

864 + ( 72 m / s ) t + 1 2 ( 3 m / s 2 ) t 2 = 900 + 1 2 ( 25 m / s 2 ) t 2 864+(72m/s)t+\frac{1}{2}(3m/s^2)t^2 = 900+\frac{1}{2}(25m/s^2)t^2

11 t 2 72 t + 36 = 0 11t^2-72t+36=0

( 11 t 6 ) ( t 6 ) = 0 (11t-6)(t-6)=0

t = { 6 11 , 6 } t=\{\frac{6}{11},6\}

After excluding the 6 s 6s solution, we can conclude that our policeman does catch Devin 6 11 \frac{6}{11} seconds after he leaves the 3 3 rd stop sign. Add that to our 24 s 24s that it took to get up to that point and plug it into our formula for P ( t ) P(t) and we have our answer!

t = 24 + 6 11 = 270 11 s t=24+\frac{6}{11}=\frac{270}{11}s

P ( 270 11 ) = 3 2 ( 270 11 ) 2 903.719... P\big(\frac{270}{11}\big)=\frac{3}{2}\big(\frac{270}{11}\big)^2\approx \boxed{903.719...}

Nice problem, brother...

Took me a while to figure out the time 6/11 sec....(Cant ignore the fact that I had 9Gag ON on the other tab :))

Pankaj Joshi - 5 years, 11 months ago

Nice question ! Enjoyed solving it. : ) :)

Keshav Tiwari - 5 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

Thank you!

Garrett Clarke - 5 years, 11 months ago
Michael Mendrin
Jul 6, 2015

You need to specify that Delvin does not [instantly achieve after starting] 50 m / s e c 50 m/sec , and that he accelerates from the stop light at the same rate as he accelerates from all the stop signs. This might seem obvious, but for the sake of removing ambiguity of this problem, include this proviso.

The word 'immediately re accelerates' made me think he instantaneously achieves a speed of 50 m/s. I got the answer a roughly 1234.2 in that case.

Vishnu Bhagyanath - 5 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

It works out to 974.292 974.292 if Delvin starts at 50 m / s e c 50 m/sec .

Michael Mendrin - 5 years, 11 months ago

I'm confused, the clause "Both driver's start at 0 m / s 0m/s " has been in there from the beginning, does that not tell you that Devin starts at 0 m / s 0m/s ?

Garrett Clarke - 5 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

I did say that "this might seem obvious", but you've already got at least one confused customer. When failure starts to matter, you get unhappy customers.

Michael Mendrin - 5 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

What do you suggest I change it to? I don't know how to be more explicit than "Both drivers start at 0 m/s 2 0\text{m/s}^2 ."

Garrett Clarke - 5 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

@Garrett Clarke You can say that Devin never accelerates faster than 25 m / s e c 2 25 m/sec^2 , which bars him from instantly achieving a speed of 50 m / s e c 50 m/sec

Michael Mendrin - 5 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

@Michael Mendrin Awesome that works, thanks!

Garrett Clarke - 5 years, 11 months ago

I will rephrase the reacceleration from the stoplight, good call on that.

Garrett Clarke - 5 years, 11 months ago

Time for Devin (D) to acc. from 0 m/s to 50 m/s, = 50/25= 2 s. He moves (1/2) * 25 * (2 * 2)=50 m during these 2 s. Same for decc. So acc. and decc. for 2 + 2= 4 s , moves 50+50=100 m. remaining 300-100=200 m with 50 m/s takes 200/50=4 s. From stop to stop D takes 8s to move 300 m at an average speed of
300 / 8 = 37.5 m / s 300/8=\color{#3D99F6}{37.5 m/s} . THIS IS TRUE ONLY AT STOPS, that is for 8,16,24 ...seconds.

To achieve 37.5 m/s Police (P) takes T t s g i v e n b y 0 T t + 3 T t 2 = 37.5 m / s T t = 25 s T_t s ~given ~by \dfrac{0*T_t+3*T_t} 2 =37.5~ m/s~~\therefore ~~T_t=25 s

But this is true only at 24 s. That means D moves 37.5 * 24 =900 m and P moves (1/2) * 3 * 24 * 24 = 864 m in 24 s; P's speed then is 3 * 24= 72 m/s .
D is still 900-864= 36 m ahead. P still needs t < 1 second to catch up, for the speed of D is now less than 37.5 average.

Distance moved by P= 36+distance moved by D in t s (in acc. period for t is not more than 2.) 72 t + 1 2 3 t 2 = 36 + 1 2 25 t 2 11 t 2 72 t + 36 = 0. t = 6 11 o r t = 6. t = 6 d o e s n o t h o l d s i n c e a c c o f D i s o n l y f o r 2 s . F o r t = 6 11 , distance moved by both is 0 ( 24 + 6 11 ) + 1 2 3 ( 24 + 6 11 ) 2 = 903.719. O r 37.5 24 + 1 2 25 ( 6 11 ) 2 = 903.719 \implies 72*t + \dfrac 1 2 *3*t^2= 36 + \dfrac 1 2 *25*t^2~\implies11t^2-72t+ 36=0.\\\therefore~t=\dfrac 6 {11}~ or~~ t = 6.~~ t=6 ~does~ not~ hold~ since~ acc~ of~ D ~is ~only~ for~ ~2~ s.\\For~t=\dfrac 6 {11} ,\text{ distance moved by both is} \\ 0*(24+\frac 6 {11})+\dfrac 1 2 *3*(24+\frac 6 {11} )^2=~~~~~\color{#D61F06}{903.719}.\\Or~~~~~~~37.5*24+\dfrac 1 2 *25*(\frac 6 {11})^2=903.719

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...