HexaRatio

Geometry Level 3

If right M C N \triangle MCN is inscribed in regular hexagon A B C D E F ABCDEF such that M M is the midpoint of A B AB , then the ratio of the perimeters of pentagon A M N E F AMNEF to hexagon A B C D E F ABCDEF is a b \frac{a}{b} for relatively prime positive integers a a and b b .

Find a + b a + b .

Challenge: Solve without using trigonometry.


The answer is 11.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

5 solutions

David Vreken
Feb 17, 2021

Let each side of the regular hexagon be s s , so that its perimeter is P A B C D E F = 6 s P_{ABCDEF} = 6s , and reflect M B C \triangle MBC along M C MC and C D N \triangle CDN along C N CN :

Since B C M + N C D = B C D M C N = 120 ° 90 ° = 30 ° \angle BCM + \angle NCD = \angle BCD - \angle MCN = 120° - 90° = 30° , and B C M = B C M \angle BCM = \angle B'CM and N C D = N C D \angle NCD = \angle NCD' , then B C M + N C D = B C M + N C D = 30 ° \angle B'CM + \angle NCD' = \angle BCM + \angle NCD = 30° , so B C D = M C N ( B C M + N C D ) = 90 ° 30 ° = 60 ° \angle B'CD' = \angle MCN - (\angle B'CM + \angle NCD') = 90° - 30° = 60° .

Since B C = B C = C D = C D = s BC = B'C = CD = CD' = s , and since B C D = 60 ° \angle B'CD' = 60° , B C D \triangle B'CD' is an equilateral triangle, which means B D = s B'D' = s .

Also, A M + M B = A M + M B = s AM + MB' = AM + MB = s , and D N + N E = D N + N E = s D'N + NE = DN + NE = s .

That means the perimeter of A M N E F AMNEF is P A M N E F = ( A M + M B ) + B D + ( D N + N E ) + E F + A F = s + s + s + s + s = 5 s P_{AMNEF} = (AM + MB') + B'D' + (D'N + NE) + EF + AF = s + s + s + s + s = 5s .

The ratio of the perimeters is then P A M N E F P A B C D E F = 5 s 6 s = 5 6 \cfrac{P_{AMNEF}}{P_{ABCDEF}} = \cfrac{5s}{6s} = \cfrac{5}{6} .

Therefore, a = 5 a = 5 , b = 6 b = 6 , and a + b = 11 a + b = \boxed{11} .

Good solution. I think there is a typo: "reflect M B C \triangle MBC " instead of " A B C \triangle ABC ".

Chew-Seong Cheong - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

Log in to reply

Yes, thanks! I edited it.

David Vreken - 3 months, 3 weeks ago
Stewart Gordon
Feb 20, 2021

My approach was based on 3D coordinate geometry. Why 3D? Because this enables us to simplify the numbers based on the fact that, if you cut a cube in half perpendicularly to a vertex axis, the cross-section so produced is a regular hexagon.

So let the coordinates be as follows: A = ( 0 , 2 , 2 ) B = ( 2 , 0 , 2 ) C = ( 2 , 2 , 0 ) D = ( 0 , 2 , 2 ) E = ( 2 , 0 , 2 ) F = ( 2 , 2 , 0 ) M = ( 1 , 1 , 2 ) N = ( t , 2 t , 2 ) A = ( 0, -2, -2) \\ B = (-2, 0, -2) \\ C = (-2, 2, 0) \\ D = ( 0, 2, 2) \\ E = ( 2, 0, 2) \\ F = ( 2, -2, 0) \\ M = (-1, -1, -2) \\ N = (t, 2-t, 2) The dot product of non-zero vectors is zero if and only if they are perpendicular. Thus we can solve: C M . C N = 0 ( 1 3 2 ) . ( t + 2 t 2 ) = 0 ( 1 ) ( t + 2 ) + ( 3 ) ( t ) + ( 2 ) ( 2 ) = 0 4 t 2 = 0 t = 1 2 \overrightarrow{CM} . \overrightarrow{CN} = 0 \\ \Rightarrow \begin{pmatrix} 1 \\ -3 \\ -2 \end{pmatrix} . \begin{pmatrix} t+2 \\ -t \\ 2 \end{pmatrix} = 0 \\ \Rightarrow (1) (t+2) + (-3)(-t) + (-2) (2) = 0 \\ \Rightarrow 4t - 2 = 0 \\ \Rightarrow t = \frac12 This gives N = ( 1 2 , 3 2 , 2 ) . N = \left(\frac12, \frac32, 2\right).

Now we can calculate the perimeters of the two shapes. Perimeter of hexagon: h = 6 A F = 6 8 = 12 2 h = 6 AF \\ = 6 \sqrt8 \\ = 12 \sqrt2 Perimeter of pentagon: p = A M + M N + N E + E F + F A = 2 + 7 2 2 + 3 2 2 + 2 ( 2 2 ) = 10 2 p = AM + MN + NE + EF + FA \\ = \sqrt2 + \frac72 \sqrt2 + \frac32 \sqrt2 + 2 (2 \sqrt2) \\ = 10 \sqrt2 Ratio: h p = 12 2 10 2 = 6 5 . \displaystyle{\frac{h}{p} = \frac{12\sqrt2}{10\sqrt2} = \boxed{\frac65}}.

Wow, nice out-of-the-box (or maybe I should say out-of-the-cube) solution!

David Vreken - 3 months, 3 weeks ago
Michael Huang
Feb 17, 2021

The unit hexagon can be presented in the lattice points of unit equilateral triangle as shown above. Notice that by extending the leg perpendicular to one of the segments, we have a right green triangle with leg lengths 11 2 \dfrac{11}{2} and 5 2 3 \dfrac{5}{2}\sqrt{3} . Following Pythagorean’s Theorem, ( 11 2 ) 2 + ( 5 2 3 ) 2 = 7 \sqrt{\left(\dfrac{11}{2}\right)^2+\left(\dfrac{5}{2}\sqrt{3}\right)^2} = 7 . Therefore,

Perimeter of 5-gon Perimeter of 6-gon = 2 + 3 + 4 + 4 + 7 4 × 6 = 5 6 \dfrac{\text{Perimeter of 5-gon}}{\text{Perimeter of 6-gon}} = \dfrac{2+3+4+4+7}{4 \times 6} = \dfrac{5}{6}

which returns us a + b = 5 + 6 = 11 a + b = 5 + 6 = \boxed{11} .


Note that if we extend the segment as shown above, it is easier to see that the right triangle of side lengths 1 1 and 3 2 × 8 = 4 3 = 48 \dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2} \times 8 = 4\sqrt{3} = \sqrt{48} has the hypotenuse 49 = 7 \sqrt{49} = 7 .

From the tell of the diagram I provided, there exists different ways of proving the hypotenuse length of the given right triangle is 7 7 . I have updated my solution, which includes the alternate way of noticing the side length 7 7 . It appears that some original/fresh question ideas popped up in my head after I inspected my own solution! What a luck!

Michael Huang - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

Here is the follow-up problem I posted. It adds some nice twist from my solution. :)

Michael Huang - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

@Michael Huang - Hi Michael! In both your solution you take for granted that the brown triangle (red in the second solution) formed by the specific three vertex points is indeed a right triangle. Isn't it necessary to prove this? Do I miss something obvious here?

Thanos Petropoulos - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

Log in to reply

Ah. That is a good question. The diagrams I showed are some interpretations of the problem. There is some combinatorial billiard feeling to the problem, but if suppose we use elementary geometry, it is good enough to prove that given G G is a midpoint of A B \overline{AB} , A G E H = 2 \dfrac{|\overline{AG}|}{|\overline{EH}|} = 2 (I set my variables for this one), which is rational. In this case, as we are considering a regular hexagon, we can extend triangular lattice points.

Michael Huang - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

Log in to reply

I see, but how to prove that this ratio equals 2? Check my solution, based on elementary euclidean geometry.

Thanos Petropoulos - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

For simplicity we scale A B C D E F ABCDEF to a unit hexagon. Then A C AC is the side of an equilateral triangle inscribed in the hexagon’s (unit) circumsircle, thus, A C = 3 AC=\sqrt{3} . Let L L be the midpoint of D E DE and N 1 {{N}_{1}} the midpoint of D L DL .

First we prove that N 1 {{N}_{1}} in fact is the given point N N .
By Apollonius's Theorem on A B C \triangle ABC , C B 2 + C A 2 = 2 { C M 2 + ( A B 2 ) 2 } C{{B}^{2}}+C{{A}^{2}}=2\left\{ C{{M}^{2}}+{{\left( \frac{AB}{2} \right)}^{2}} \right\} from which we get C M 2 = 2 C B 2 + 2 C A 2 A B 2 4 = 2 × 1 2 + 2 × 3 2 1 2 4 = 7 4 C{{M}^{2}}=\dfrac{2C{{B}^{2}}+2C{{A}^{2}}-A{{B}^{2}}}{4}=\dfrac{2\times {{1}^{2}}+2\times {{\sqrt{3}}^{2}}-{{1}^{2}}}{4}=\dfrac{7}{4} Similarly, for the median C N 1 C{{N}_{1}} of C D L \triangle CDL , C N 1 2 = 2 C D 2 + 2 C L 2 D L 2 4 = 2 C D 2 + 2 C M 2 D L 2 4 = 2 × 1 2 + 2 × 7 4 ( 1 2 ) 2 4 = 21 16 C{{N}_{1}}^{2}=\dfrac{2C{{D}^{2}}+2C{{L}^{2}}-D{{L}^{2}}}{4}=\dfrac{2C{{D}^{2}}+2C{{M}^{2}}-D{{L}^{2}}}{4}=\dfrac{2\times {{1}^{2}}+2\times \dfrac{7}{4}-{{\left( \dfrac{1}{2} \right)}^{2}}}{4}=\dfrac{21}{16} By Pythagorean theorem on right M L N 1 \triangle ML{{N}_{1}} , M N 1 2 = M L 2 + L N 1 2 = ( 2 O L ) 2 + ( D L 2 ) 2 = ( 2 3 2 ) 2 + ( 1 4 ) 2 = 49 16 M{{N}_{1}}^{2}=M{{L}^{2}}+L{{N}_{1}}^{2}={{\left( 2OL \right)}^{2}}+{{\left( \dfrac{DL}{2} \right)}^{2}}={{\left( 2\cdot \dfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2} \right)}^{2}}+{{\left( \dfrac{1}{4} \right)}^{2}}=\dfrac{49}{16} thus M N 1 = 7 4 M{{N}_{1}}=\dfrac{7}{4} We notice that C M 2 + C N 1 2 = 7 4 + 21 16 = 49 16 = M N 1 2 C{{M}^{2}}+C{{N}_{1}}^{2}=\dfrac{7}{4}+\dfrac{21}{16}=\dfrac{49}{16}=M{{N}_{1}}^{2} Hence, by the converse of Pythagorean theorem ( Euclid's Elements, Book I, Proposition 48 ), M C N 1 = 90 \angle MC{{N}_{1}}=90{}^\circ and this proves that N 1 {{N}_{1}} coincides with given point N N .

The perimeter P 5 {{P}_{5}} of pentagon A M N E F AMNEF is P 5 = A M + M N + N E + E F + F A = 1 2 + 7 4 + 3 4 + + 1 + 1 = 5 {{P}_{5}}=AM+MN+NE+EF+FA=\frac{1}{2}+\frac{7}{4}+\frac{3}{4}++1+1=5 and the perimeter P 6 {{P}_{6}} of the regular hexagon is 6, hence, P 5 P 6 = 5 6 \dfrac{{{P}_{5}}}{{{P}_{6}}}=\dfrac{5}{6} For the answer, a = 5 a=5 , b = 6 b=6 , thus, a + b = 11 a+b=\boxed{11} .

Chris Lewis
Feb 17, 2021

Original (trig) solution in a comment below.

Say the hexagon has unit sides. Note that A B AB and D E DE are parallel. To make things a bit easier to see, rotate the image so that these lines are horizontal:

Point D D' lies on the extension of line D E DE so that D D C DD'C is a right-angle; point B B' is defined similarly. D D = B B = 1 2 DD'=BB'=\frac12 and B C = C D = 3 2 B'C=CD'=\frac{\sqrt3}{2} .

Since the triangles B C M B'CM and D C N D'CN are similar, D N B C = C D B M \frac{D'N}{B'C}=\frac{CD'}{B'M}

so B M D N = B C C D = 3 4 B'M \cdot D'N = B'C \cdot CD' = \frac34 .

By Pythagoras... M N 2 = C M 2 + C N 2 = ( B C 2 + B M 2 ) + ( C D 2 + D N 2 ) = 3 2 + B M 2 + D N 2 = 2 B M D N + B M 2 + D N 2 = ( B M + D N ) 2 = ( 1 + B M + D N ) 2 \begin{aligned} MN^2&=CM^2+CN^2 \\ &=\left(B'C^2+B'M^2 \right)+\left(CD'^2+D'N^2 \right) \\ &=\frac32+B'M^2+D'N^2 \\ &= 2B'M\cdot D'N+B'M^2+D'N^2 \\ &=(B'M+D'N)^2 \\ &=(1+BM+DN)^2 \end{aligned}

so M N = 1 + B M + D N = 1 + ( 1 A M ) + ( 1 E N ) = 3 A M E N MN=1+BM+DN=1+(1-AM)+(1-EN)=3-AM-EN .

Hence the perimeter of A M N E F AMNEF is A M + M N + N E + E F + F A = A M + ( 3 A M N E ) + N E + 1 + 1 = 5 AM+MN+NE+EF+FA=AM+(3-AM-NE)+NE+1+1=5

so the ratio is Perimeter 5-gon Perimeter 6-gon = 5 6 \frac{\text{Perimeter 5-gon}}{\text{Perimeter 6-gon}}=\boxed{\frac56}

...which doesn't depend on the position of M M along A B AB !

Nice solution! You'll be interested to know that there is also a non-trigonometric solution for this problem, can you find it?

David Vreken - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

Log in to reply

I am interested in that...and I've just noticed the ratio is independent of the position of M M along A B AB ! Right, back to the drawing board...

Chris Lewis - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

I finally got it! I am going to update the solution once I am done eating.

Spoiler : It has to do with unit equilateral triangular lattice points.

Michael Huang - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

Log in to reply

@David Vreken - was this the way you meant?

@Michael Huang - no time for eating! ;-) Although I think you might have done this yet another way...I hope I haven't just found a different ugly solution!

Chris Lewis - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

Log in to reply

@Chris Lewis I have posted the solution.

Michael Huang - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

@Chris Lewis I love both your and @Michael Huang 's solutions, but I actually had a different method! I'll post it soon.

David Vreken - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

Alternative trig solution in a reply to this...

Chris Lewis - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

Log in to reply

Assume the hexagon has unit sides.

In triangle Δ M B C \Delta MBC , M B = 1 2 MB=\frac12 , B C = 1 BC=1 and M B C = 12 0 \angle MBC=120^\circ . By the cosine rule, we get M C 2 = M B 2 + B C 2 2 M B B C cos M B C = 7 4 MC^2=MB^2+BC^2-2MB\cdot BC\cdot \cos \angle MBC=\frac74 so M C = 7 2 MC=\frac{\sqrt7}{2} .

By the sine rule, sin M C B M B = sin M B C M C \frac{\sin \angle MCB}{MB}=\frac{\sin \angle MBC}{MC} so sin M C B = 1 2 3 7 \sin \angle MCB = \frac12 \sqrt{\frac37} . We also get cos M C B = 5 2 7 \cos \angle MCB=\frac{5}{2\sqrt7} .

Now, in triangle Δ C D N \Delta CDN , C D = 1 CD=1 , C D N = 12 0 \angle CDN=120^\circ and D C N = 12 0 9 0 M C B = 3 0 M C B \angle DCN=120^\circ-90^\circ-\angle MCB=30^\circ-\angle MCB . It follows that C N D = 3 0 + M C B \angle CND=30^\circ+\angle MCB .

Using the sine rule again, D N sin D C N = C D sin C N D D N = sin ( 30 M C B ) sin ( 30 + M C B ) = 1 4 \begin{aligned} \frac{DN}{\sin \angle DCN}&=\frac{CD}{\sin \angle CND} \\ DN &= \frac{\sin \left(30-\angle MCB \right)}{\sin \left(30+\angle MCB \right)} \\ &=\frac14 \end{aligned} (where I've left out some trig expansion and substitution)

Also, using whatever rule we want now, we get C N = 21 4 CN=\frac{\sqrt{21}}{4} .

By Pythagoras, M N = C N 2 + M C 2 = 7 4 MN=\sqrt{CN^2+MC^2}=\frac74

Now we have everything we need; the perimeter of A B C D E F ABCDEF is 6 6 and the perimeter of A M N E F AMNEF is A M + M N + N E + E F + F A = 1 2 + 7 4 + 3 4 + 1 + 1 = 5 AM+MN+NE+EF+FA=\frac12+\frac74+\frac34+1+1=5

so the ratio is Perimeter 5-gon Perimeter 6-gon = 5 6 \frac{\text{Perimeter 5-gon}}{\text{Perimeter 6-gon}}=\boxed{\frac56}

Chris Lewis - 3 months, 3 weeks ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...