Hyperloop: Shock waves

The Hyperloop is a hypothetical new fast transport system between cities, which works by launching pods that carry people through a very low air pressure tunnel. The tunnel and Hyperloop pod are both cylindrically symmetric. If the radius of the pod is too close to the radius of the tunnel, then the air flowing through the cracks will become supersonic, generating shockwaves and disrupting the smooth operation of the Hyperloop. The pod helps prevent this by sucking up and compressing 0.49 kg/s of air through the front of the pod as it travels, but this still means some air must flow around the pod.

If the radius of the tunnel is 1.1 m, the speed of the pod is 300 m/s and the air in the tunnel is at a pressure of 99 Pa and temperature of 293 K, then what is the maximum radius of the pod in m that will keep the air flow relative to the pod below the speed of sound?

Details and assumptions

  • Treat air as incompressible. This isn't true at high mach number, but it will make the solution easier.
  • The molar mass of air is μ = 29 \mu= 29 g/mol.
  • Neglect the effects of gravity and viscosity.
  • Assume the air flow is perfectly laminar.


The answer is 0.734.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Yuchen Liu
Aug 19, 2013

As the speed of the pod is constant, its length l l is equal to its speed v v times time t t

Therefore, in the tube, the volume of air displaced by the pod per unit time is given by

V d i s p l a c e d t = π r p 2 l t = π r p 2 v t t = π r p 2 v \frac{V_{displaced}}{t}=\frac{\pi r_p^{2}l}{t}=\frac{\pi r_p^{2}vt}{t}=\pi r_p^{2}v ,

Denote the mass of air sucked out per unit time as S,

Volume of air sucked out per unit time is thus S ρ a i r \frac{S}{\rho_{air}}

The volume of air flows around the pod per unit time is

d V d t = π r p 2 v S ρ a i r \frac{dV}{dt}=\pi r_p^{2}v - \frac{S}{\rho_{air}}

The open area between the tube and the pod can be expressed as

A = π ( r t 2 r p 2 ) A=\pi(r_t^{2}-r_p^{2})

the velocity of the air flowing past is hence

v a i r = d V A d t = π r p 2 v S ρ a i r π ( r t 2 r p 2 ) v_{air}=\frac{dV}{A*dt}=\frac{\pi r_p^{2}v-\frac{S}{\rho_{air}}}{\pi (r_t^{2}-r_p^{2})}

In order to keep the air flow relative to the pod below speed of sound, the following equation needs to hold,

v + v a i r v s o u n d v+v_{air} \leq v_{sound}

Rearranging the equations we have obtained,

v a i r π r t 2 = π r p 2 v S ρ a i r v_{air} \pi r_t^{2} = \pi r_p^{2}v -\frac{S}{\rho_{air}}

S ρ a i r + v a i r π r t 2 = π r p 2 ( v + v a i r ) = π v s o u n d r p 2 \frac{S}{\rho_{air}}+v_{air}\pi r_t^{2}= \pi r_p^{2} (v+v_{air}) = \pi v_{sound} r_p^{2}

r p = S ρ a i r + v a i r π r t 2 v s o u n d π r_p=\sqrt{\frac{\frac{S}{\rho_{air}}+v_{air}\pi r_t^{2}}{v_{sound}\pi}}

Using The Ideal Gas Law P V = n R T PV=nRT

ρ a i r = m V = n μ V = P V μ R T V = P μ R T \rho_{air}=\frac{m}{V}=\frac{n\mu}{V}=\frac{PV\mu}{RTV}=\frac{P\mu}{RT}

plugging in the expression for ρ a i r \rho_{air} into the equation, we get

r p = S R T P μ + ( v s o u n d v ) π r t 2 v s o u n d π r_p=\sqrt{\frac{\frac{SRT}{P\mu}+(v_{sound}-v)\pi r_t^{2}}{v_{sound}\pi}}

Subbing in the numerical values, assuming

R = 8.31 J / m o l K , v s o u n d = 340 m / s R=8.31J/molK, v_{sound}=340m/s

we find the radius of the pod to be 0.729 \boxed{0.729}

Why l l is equal to v t vt ?

Himanshu Arora - 7 years, 9 months ago

Log in to reply

Because the speed of the pod is constant.

Yuchen Liu - 7 years, 9 months ago

Log in to reply

Excuse for the late reply. At different instants of time, vt gives different values which would mean different values of l. This doesn't make sense as the length of pod doesn't change.

Thanks!

Himanshu Arora - 7 years, 9 months ago

Log in to reply

@Himanshu Arora Oh sorry. I was referring to the length that the pod travelled i.e. the "length of the air" that it displaces per unit time. Hope this explains the problem.

Yuchen Liu - 7 years, 9 months ago

Does anyone want to do this creating a variable for the drag coefficient of the pod + adding in turbulent conditions?

Rose Haft - 3 years, 10 months ago
Josh Silverman Staff
Aug 18, 2013

In an empty section of the tube, prior to the pod passing through, air fills the volume at a molar density given by the ideal gas law n / V = P / R T \displaystyle n/V = P/RT . The density of air is then given by ρ a i r = μ P / R T \displaystyle\rho_{air}=\mu P/RT .

The volume displaced by the pod is given by π r p o d 2 l p o d \displaystyle \pi r_{pod}^2l_{pod} . As the pod travels at constant speed, we can write l p o d = v p o d t \displaystyle l_{pod} = v_{pod}t . Then, the mass of air displaced by the pod per unit time is given by ρ a i r π r p o d 2 v p o d \displaystyle\rho_{air}\pi r_{pod}^2v_{pod} . At the same time, the pod can clear air at the rate v s u c k v_{suck} .

The volume of air that has to travel down the sides of the tube per unit time is then

Δ V Δ t = ρ a i r π r p o d 2 v p o d v s u c k ρ a i r \displaystyle \frac{\Delta V}{\Delta t} = \frac{\rho_{air}\pi r_{pod}^2v_{pod}-v_{suck}}{\rho_{air}}

The area of the gap between the sides of the tunnel and the pod is given by

Δ A = π ( r t u n n e l 2 r p o d 2 ) \displaystyle \Delta A = \pi\left(r_{tunnel}^2-r_{pod}^2\right)

The velocity of the volume of air moving down the cracks is then Δ V Δ t 1 Δ A = v a i r = ρ a i r π r p o d 2 v p o d v s u c k ρ a i r π ( r t u n n e l 2 r p o d 2 ) \displaystyle \frac{\Delta V}{ \Delta t}\frac{1}{\Delta A} = v_{air} = \frac{\rho_{air}\pi r_{pod}^2v_{pod}-v_{suck}}{\rho_{air}\pi\left(r_{tunnel}^2-r_{pod}^2\right)}

This gives the velocity of air relative to the walls of the tunnel as a function of the radius of the pod. We'd like to know when the velocity of air relative to the pod, which is given by v p o d + v a i r v_{pod}+v_{air} , is equal to the speed of sounds, v s o u n d v_{sound} = 340.29 m/s .

Setting v s o u n d = v a i r + v p o d v_{sound} = v_{air} + v_{pod} and solving for r p o d \displaystyle r_{pod} we find

r p o d = R T P π μ v s u c k v s o u n d + r t u n n e l 2 ( 1 v p o d v s o u n d ) \displaystyle \boxed{r_{pod} = \sqrt{\displaystyle\frac{RT}{P\pi\mu}\frac{v_{suck}}{v_{sound}} + r_{tunnel}^2\left(1-\frac{v_{pod}}{v_{sound}}\right)}}

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...