α f ( x ) = f ( x + α )
Given that α is a real number greater than 1, does a non-constant function f : R → R exist that satisfies the above functional equation for all x ?
Bonus
If you think the answer is yes, then find all functions that satisfy the given equation.
If you think the answer is no, then prove it.
What happens when 0 < α < 1 ? What happens when α < 0 ?
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
Nice solution Pranshu #excellent
Does not f(x) = 0 work?
Log in to reply
Sure, f ( x ) = 0 works. However it is a constant function, and the problem asks for a non-constant function.
Log in to reply
Ohhh. I came here from Facebook, that wasn't included in the premise of the question there.
For any non-zero α , we can choose f ( x ) freely on the interval I = [ 0 , ∣ α ∣ ). Any real x can then be written uniquely as x = y + k α where y is on I and k is an integer, and we have f ( x ) = f ( y + k α ) = α k f ( y ) .
( α α 1 ) x = α α x is a solution for any α > 0 , but take any function p ( x ) with period α , e.g. p ( x ) = sin ( α 2 π x ) , and p ( x ) ⋅ α α x is also a solution.
For x = 0 , there's only the constant function f ( x ) = 0 .
For α < 0 , I must say that I have no idea so far.
All group homomorphisms from the reals with addition to the reals under multiplication? Guessing
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
The given functional equation is similar to f ( x ) ⋅ f ( y ) = f ( x + y ) . One solution to functional equations of this kind is f ( x ) = k x for all x , where k is a positive real number. If f ( y ) = y = α , then this functional equation becomes equal to the functional equation in the problem.
Suppose f ( x ) = k x satisfies our functional equation. This means that f ( y ) = k y . We want to solve the equation f ( y ) = y = α . This implies
f ( α ) k α α lo g k lo g k k = α = α = lo g α = α 1 lo g α = α 1 / α
Therefore a solution for f ( x ) is
f ( x ) = ( α 1 / α ) x for all x
The answer to this problem is Yes because we have found a non-constant function satisfying the given functional equation.
Now try answering the bonus questions!