Jack and Jill are standing on a large hill, as shown above. Jill, being a mischievous girl, throws a stone at Jack to break his crown. At what angle, θ , with the inclined plane (in degrees) must Jill aim the stone so that it lands closest to Jack?
Details and Assumptions
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
Very well explained! Thanks for showing the derivation of the formula.
You could have used ,
2
sin
(
α
)
cos
(
α
−
θ
)
=
sin
(
2
α
−
θ
)
+
sin
(
θ
)
which is maximum when,
2
α
−
θ
=
9
0
∘
Log in to reply
Agreed, but i like differentiating!! :D
Log in to reply
Awesome solution, Abhineet! It's well explained and neatly presented.
I would like to point out an important result.
The range is maximum when the initial velocity is along the line that bisects the angle formed by the vertical and the inclined plane.
In this problem, the angle between the inclined plane and the vertical is 1 2 0 ∘ , therefore the initial velocity must make 2 1 2 0 ∘ = 6 0 ∘ with the plane.
Log in to reply
@Pranshu Gaba – Hehe, yeah, i know that, but i thought i'd prove that! :D
If Jill were to throw the stone harder (faster) in any other angle between almost throwing horizontally (theta<110°) and throwing the stone in an almost straight line on jack (theta >0), she could of course hit Jack... Why should she be limited to throwing with 90 degrees to the plane only???
Log in to reply
@Amandus Westin if you're referring to my statement that a l p h a can't be obtuse, then i should probably clarify. What I actually meant was that α can't be obtuse for the range to be maximum.
Log in to reply
Thank you for clarifying. To me it wasn't really that clear at all that we should calculate the angle leading to the most effective range. Now that I kind of got what the task was meant to be about I could look into your calculations and learn some cool things!
Log in to reply
@Amandus Westin – Well, i'm glad i could help! :)
Of course, if Jill throws the stone faster then her range will definitely increase. However in the problem, we are supposed to find the optimal angle for which the range is maximized for a fixed velocity. If the inclined plane has a slope of 3 0 ∘ , then throwing the stone at an angle of 6 0 ∘ maximizes the range. Throwing it at any other angle will reduce the range.
Note that Jill should throw the stone making an angle of 60 degrees with the plane and not 90 degrees.
Log in to reply
Yeah, I think I get the maths behind it now. It was just that for me the question didn't make sense.
Very well explained. +1 !!!
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
So, first it should be clear that we need to find the maximum range possible for the projectile along the inclined plane. To do that, we can easily derive the formula for the projectile's range and differentiate it to get a maxima. Ok then, let's begin!
Let's consider the initial velocity of the projectile to be ' u ' m/s and it's angle of projection to the inclined plane as α as shown in the figure. Let the angle that the inclined plane makes with the horizontal is θ which is 3 0 ∘ in our case.
Notice the components!
Now, as it can be seen from the figure, the component of particle's velocity, perpendicular to the plane is given by v ⊥ = v sin α and that along the plane is given by v ∥ = v cos α . The perpendicular component is provided a retardation towards the plane given by v ⊥ = g cos θ whereas the parallel component is provided an acceleration along the plane given by v ∥ = g sin θ .
Now, the time of flight can be calculated by the double the time it takes for the perpendicular component to be zero, i.e. T = g cos θ 2 u sin α
This is the same time that the particle will travel along the plane and it's range, R can be calculated using the second equation of motion, or:
R = ( u cos α ) g cos θ 2 u sin α + 2 1 ( g sin θ ) ( g cos θ 2 u sin α ) 2
This equation can be simplified to get something like:
R = g cos θ 2 u 2 sin α ( cos α + cos θ sin α sin θ )
and then:
R = g cos 2 θ 2 u 2 sin α cos ( α − θ )
Now, to maximise this range, we simply differentiate it with respect to α and equate the derivative with 0 . Differentiating and equating, we get:
tan α tan ( α − θ ) = 0
Putting tan ( α − θ ) = 1 + tan a tan θ tan α − tan θ and solving the quadratic equation formed in tan α , we get α = 1 5 0 ∘ or α = 6 0 ∘ . Now, since α can't be obtuse, hence, α = 6 0 ∘ is the final answer.