Magnetism and Thermodynamics

A current carrying wire heats a metal rod. The wire provides a constant power ( P ) (P) to the rod. The metal rod is enclosed in an insulated container. It is observed that the temperature ( T ) (T) in the metal rod changes with time ( t ) (t) as T ( t ) = T 0 ( 1 + β t 1 4 ) T(t) =T_{0} (1+\beta t^{\frac{1}{4}}) where β \beta is a constant with appropriate dimension while T 0 T_0 is a constant with dimension of temperature .
Find the heat capacity of of the metal?
Answer comes in the form of α P ( T ( t ) T 0 ) ϕ β γ T 0 δ \frac{\alpha P (T(t) -T_0)^{\phi}}{\beta^{\gamma} T_{0}^{\delta}}

Type you answer as α + ϕ + γ + δ = ? \alpha + \phi+\gamma+\delta=?
The problem is not original


The answer is 15.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

There is no magnetism in this problem, but only the use of the definition of heat capacity and power. Let the temperature varies with time as T ( t ) = T 0 ( 1 + β t n ) T(t)=T_0(1+βt^n) where T 0 T_0 is the initial temperatue and β , n β,n are constants.

Then, by definitions of heat capacity and power, the power P P is related to the heat capacity C C through :

P = C d T d t = β n C T 0 t n 1 P=C\dfrac{dT}{dt}=βnCT_0t^{n-1}

C = P β n T 0 t n 1 \implies C=\dfrac{P}{βnT_0t^{n-1}} .

Now, from the expression for T ( t ) T(t) ,

we get t n 1 = ( T ( t ) T 0 ) 1 1 n β 1 1 n T 0 1 1 n t^{n-1}=\dfrac{(T(t)-T_0)^{1-\frac{1}{n}}}{β^{1-\frac{1}{n}}T_0^{1-\frac{1}{n}}} .

So, C = P ( T ( t ) T 0 ) 1 n 1 n β 1 n T 0 1 n C=\dfrac{P\left (T(t)-T_0\right )^{\frac{1}{n}-1}}{nβ^{\frac{1}{n}}T_0^{\frac{1}{n}}} .

In this problem, n = 1 4 n=\dfrac{1}{4} .

So, C = P ( T ( t ) T 0 ) 3 1 4 β 4 T 0 4 C=\dfrac{P\left (T(t)-T_0\right )^3}{\frac{1}{4}β^4T_0^4} .

Therefore α = 4 , ϕ = 3 , γ = δ = 4 α=4, \phi =3, \gamma =\delta =4 , and α + ϕ + γ + δ = 4 + 3 + 4 + 4 = 15 α+\phi +\gamma +\delta =4+3+4+4=\boxed {15} .

@Alak Bhattacharya In the problem due to related to current, therefore I have written magnetism and thermodynamics.
If I have not written magnetism how can i able to post a thermodynamics problem in Electricity and Magnetism.
It will be good if brilliant made a section for Thermodynamics. It is also a very important and interesting part of physics.
@Karan Chatrath what are your view about this. If we all request to Brilliant community to make a new section for Thermodynamics then it might be possible?


Log in to reply

I agree with @Alak Bhattacharya . This problem should have been posted in the classical mechanics section. Usually, problems in classical physics unrelated to electricity and magnetism, including thermodynamics are posted in that section.

Karan Chatrath - 1 year ago

Log in to reply

@Karan Chatrath But thermodynamics is also not related to mechanism. BTW I have corrected that problem.

Log in to reply

@A Former Brilliant Member In my experience problems relevant to thermodynamics are generally posted in that section.

Also, it is not true that thermodynamics is not related to mechanics. Consider the kinetic theory of gases. The ideal gas law, which is used extensively in thermodynamics is derived using that theory. That theory considers the motion of gaseous particles in a Newtonian framework.

Moreover, heat transfer problems related to conduction and convention are explained by the movement of matter either in bulk or in small length scales, depending on the mechanism. The laws of classical physics are quite interrelated when one takes a closer look.

The only heat-related problem that can be considered under the realm of E&M is thermal radiation. Cause that mode of heat transfer takes place through the propagation of Electromagnetic waves.

Karan Chatrath - 1 year ago
Karan Chatrath
May 28, 2020

Applying the first law of thermodynamics on the rod in terms of power:

P i n = P a b s o r b e d P_{in} = P_{absorbed}

P P stands for power. Let the heat capacity be C C . Then:

P = C d T d t P = C \frac{dT}{dt} P = C T o β t 3 / 4 4 \implies P = CT_o \beta \frac{t^{-3/4}}{4} C = 4 P T o β t 3 / 4 \implies C = \frac{4P}{T_o \beta} t^{3/4}

Consider:

T = T o ( 1 + β t 1 / 4 ) T= T_o\left(1 + \beta t^{1/4}\right) t 3 / 4 = ( T T o ) 3 β 3 T o 3 t^{3/4} = \frac{(T-T_o)^3}{\beta^3 T_o^3}

Using the above:

C = 4 P T o β t 3 / 4 C = \frac{4P}{T_o \beta} t^{3/4} C = 4 P T o β ( ( T T o ) 3 β 3 T o 3 ) C = \frac{4P}{T_o \beta} \left(\frac{(T-T_o)^3}{\beta^3 T_o^3}\right) C = 4 P ( T T o ) 3 T o 4 β 4 C = \frac{4P(T-T_o)^3}{T_o^4 \beta^4}

α = 4 \alpha = 4 ϕ = 3 \phi = 3 γ = 4 \gamma = 4 δ = 4 \delta = 4

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...