In Chemistry you are allowed the following type of addition (the addition reaction) C + O 2 ⟹ C O 2
But if you do it in Maths for numbers, a + b = a b it will be a big mistake!
But for how many pairs of integers (a,b) is the above said " f a l s e " property seen to be " t r u e " ?
Details and assumptions :-
∙ Here ab means a × b , not the representation in decimal system (i.e. a b is a × b and N O T 1 0 a + b )
This problem is a part of the set Mistakes Give Rise To Problems !!! .
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
nice solution
Why can't we change the expression like dis 1÷a +1÷b =1 in dis way 0,0 will be rejected
0+9=09, 0+8=08, ..... 0+1=1,
The question states integers so why are the above answers not included.
Log in to reply
a b means here the product, like x y = x × y . Not representation. Updated, thanks
Coz 0*9=0 not 09...
IS THIS REALLY A LEVEL 5 QUES
Log in to reply
Levels are not in our hands, they don't matter either. Problem solving is fun and that's exactly what matters.
And it’s level 3 by the way
Log in to reply
@Aditya Raut Usama just pointed a B I G flaw in the wordings of the problem. When we write C O 2 in Chemistry, we don't multiply them out, and so, your example of Chemistry doesn't collaborate with a+b=ab. BTW Nice Set you've made..
oops addu ....but its level 3 now .................
its level 2
This is the most pure and simple approach:
a b = a + b
Dividing by a we get
b = 1 + a b .
This suggests that b ≥ a , since the RHS must be an integer. But doing likewise with b , we get
a = 1 + b a
which suggests a ≥ b . For both conditions to be satisfied, clearly a = b . Now, substituting, we get
a 2 = a + a
which has solutions a = b = 0 , 2 . Thus there are 2 solutions.
@Aditya Raut This is a better way.
Log in to reply
Ok, that's nice. But Upvotes say something else, i personally like your way though ;)
Log in to reply
Well, hardly anybody scrolls down to see mine, and also your solution has been on longer than mine. Love the picture though. :D
Log in to reply
@Finn Hulse – <3 Happy problem solving, it is really a good approach you've shown.
Log in to reply
We're not fighting, we're appreciating the other one's way. @VAIBHAV borale , right friend ? ( @Finn Hulse ?)
A very simple proof. Better way.Thanks
Bravo!Brilliant!
For me, I thought of 2 simple equations: 2+2=2(2) and 0+0=0(0)
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
Observe that given condition can be transformed to a useful form as follows:-
a + b = a b
a − a b + b = 0
a ( 1 − b ) + b = 0
a ( 1 − b ) + b − 1 = − 1
a ( 1 − b ) − 1 ( 1 − b ) = − 1
( 1 − b ) ( a − 1 ) = − 1
( a − 1 ) ( b − 1 ) = 1
From this you can conclude that because both a and b are integers, ( a − 1 ) = ± 1 and ( b − 1 ) = ± 1 accordingly.
Thus the only solutions are
( a − 1 ) = ( b − 1 ) = 1 and ( a − 1 ) = ( b − 1 ) = − 1
This gives 2 pairs ( a , b ) , namely ( 0 , 0 ) and ( 2 , 2 )