Newton's Laws Are Keeping This Man Alive. Do You Know Which One?


Wingsuits allow humans to control fall and generate lift. The wingsuit flyer above controls his direction of flight by a direct application of which of Newton's laws?

Image credit: Wikipedia
First Law Second Law Third Law Fourth Law

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

6 solutions

David Mattingly Staff
Jan 11, 2014

The correct answer is Newton's Third Law. Note that there is no fourth Newton's Law :)

Wingsuiting is a modern extreme sport, related to skydiving, where people jump out of airplanes or off mountains wearing a special outfit call a wingsuit that increases the ability of the jumper to control their flight. Obviously the flyer above is not carrying an engine or small rockets with which to control his flight, but he also must have some control as he’s about 5 feet from the edge of a very hard rock wall. So what is it about wingsuits that allow for enough control that jumping off of mountains is not instantly lethal?

Wingsuits and control of falling are all about the smart application of Newton’s laws of motion. Newton’s laws can be broken down into three statements:

  1. An object moving at a constant velocity or at rest will stay that way unless acted on by a force.

  2. If a force is applied to the object the object will accelerate (change its velocity) and the acceleration is proportional to the total applied force.

  3. If one object applies a force to a second object, the second object applies an equal and opposite force to the first.

How does this help wingsuit flyers control their fall? Well, let’s look at what happens to you if you jump out of a plane without a wingsuit first. In this case, pretty much the only forces that act on you in midair are gravity, which pulls you straight down, and air resistance, which slightly pushes up on you. Therefore you do not stay at rest, as there are forces acting on you, and by Newton’s second law you start to accelerate and gain a downwards velocity. The technical physics term for this is “falling”. Eventually you fall fast enough that the force from air resistance, which is itself proportional to your velocity, is as large as the force of gravity. Since gravity pulls down and air resistance pushes up, the two forces cancel out and you move at a constant velocity in agreement with Newton’s first law. The velocity at which this happens is called your “terminal velocity”.

If you are wearing a wingsuit you still fall, but more slowly as air resistance is greater, and you have much more ability to shove air out of the way at an angle. If you’ve ever stuck your hand outside of a horizontally moving car you know that by angling your palm you feel a force on your hand vertically. Since the air can’t go through your hand, it must be deflected vertically. This change of direction of the moving air is an acceleration; your hand is applying a force to the air. By Newton’s third law, the air is also applying a force to your hand. Note that the air flow past your hand is horizontal, but the direction of deflection is vertical and hence one generates a force on your hand perpendicular to the direction of air flow. The exact same physics is responsible for wingsuit control. The wingsuit increases the total amount of air pushed out of the way (equivalent to making your palm bigger) and increases the amount of force perpendicular to the direction of air flow. In the falling case the air flow is vertical and so the direction of force is horizontal. By aligning the suit at different angles you can move horizontally and control your fall. After many, many jumps expert wingsuiters have enough control to pull off stuff like this . Don’t try this at home!

I really thank you David sir to give me this insight about generating force perpendicular to the fluid flow.. Its amazing.. :-)

Snehal Shekatkar - 7 years, 5 months ago

why this cannot be explained on the basis of 2nd law.When flyer adjust the surface area of wings ,an unbalanced force act on it which helps him to change the direction. Please tell, if i am wrong.

ayush pagey - 7 years, 3 months ago

Log in to reply

Agreed. 2nd Law.

Dave Zerkle - 5 years, 5 months ago

agreed . it is direct application to 2nd and 3rd laws .

Ahmed Aljayashi - 2 years, 8 months ago

that was an amazing explanation david sir

Steve Cyrus - 7 years, 4 months ago

How do they land on the ground then? Even thought they slow down, they will still hit the ground really hard, right?

Samuel Wong - 7 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

At very end of the flight they release a parachute.

David Mattingly Staff - 7 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

or you can do this:

img img

yet another great option, the 100% fake no chute water landing:

img img

Josh Silverman Staff - 7 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

@Josh Silverman Yes the worlds first wingsuit landing without the use of a parachute.. the second one, water landing, well its cool to watch, but unfortuntaly not very real.. :P

Christian Øglænd - 7 years, 4 months ago

@Josh Silverman Ahahah! I live in the exact location of the second video and still remember when the video was released a few years ago, and all the people from nearby were asking to each other: "Hey, did you see this? Did you see it live? It seems there was a big crowd watching...", but it ended up there was nobody who was present when the "landing" supposedly happened, so after a few weeks we all knew it was fake. Also, the "landing part" is shot from several different angles, but for the actual landing in the final version of the video they used the lowest quality possible, and it isn't even clear if it's a man who is landing or just a puppet thrown from a boat. If the landing was real, they would have shown it in the clearest way, possibly with slow-mo, head cameras and all sort of stuff. I agree and confirm, the second video is 100% fake!

Michele Polli - 1 year, 10 months ago

I don't really think this is a "direct application" of the 3rd law, any more than it is of the 2nd law.

Rather than imagining wingsuit flyers, I'll deal with a heavy disc, kept on a stream of air flowing upwards.

As true as it is, that the lift is generated because the disc stops the air from continuing to flow upwards and hence exerts a downward force (which is reciprocated with an upward force on the disc (and this is the 3rd Law's use)), the reason why the disc exerts a force on the stream of air in the first place, has to be explained in terms of the change in momentum the air flow suffers (vertically upwards to horizontally outwards) and due to the 2nd Law's statement that force applied on an object is directly proportional to the rate of change of its momentum. Infact, that is how the calculation of the lift is done, as I'm sure you'd know.

Thus, I fail to realise how this is more of the 3rd Law, than the 2nd Law. In my humble opinion, the correct answer should be Newton's 3 Laws, not Newton's 3rd Law. Your answer, however, was very enjoyable.

Aritra Das - 5 years, 3 months ago

isn't that it is also an application of second law?

Gabriel S. Perez - 7 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

no. since the man's direction is downward, gravity will increase the speed of the man and increase the probability of him dying. Without air pressure the speed of the man will continuously accelerate because of the pull of gravity.

Ela Cordero - 7 years, 4 months ago

thank you for the explanation. to make it short, air resistance has the most influence. and as the diver falls down, he receives the air/wind with the same or almost the same speed as to his fall makes the third law of motion possible. the wingsuits traps the air making the fall a way slower than the expected speed of a falling object/human.

Joseph Mordeno - 7 years, 5 months ago

what about air pressure ?? it may also effect ..

Ata Awan - 7 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

it does. while gravity pulls you down, air pressure pushes you up therefore slowing the fall of the man. Therefore, the pull of gravity and the push of air on the man states that the law applied is the 3rd law.

Ela Cordero - 7 years, 4 months ago

what if the person wearing wingsuit doesn't have horizontal velocity?

Amogh Negalur - 7 years, 3 months ago

Log in to reply

if he doesn't has horizontal velocity then..... the case must be that he should be jumping from a helicopter or, if its a plane then it should be in complete stall :P....... n the answer to your question is simple-- that is, his vertical velocity will be very large n he might have to experience a huge amount of force when he opens his parachute(impact will be large)..... so instead of taking the hard way they prefer to split up some of their velocity into horizontal component....

Shreyas Miraj - 7 years, 3 months ago

What is newton's forth law(⊙ˍ⊙)?

Xi ang Yu an Ji - 5 years, 1 month ago

LOL. Ok law3 gives us terminal velocity even with lift off the wing. But if we want to CONTROL that we are going to need to accelerate this way and that. For that we need unbalanced forces (Law1). Just how fast we accelerate is given by Law2. How to get the unbalanced force ? You can think of it as pushing off the airstream so we are back to Law3. But if it weren't for Laws 1&2 we would smash into that rick wall at constant velocity. So I vote answer e: Just the first 3 ;-)

Matthew Civil - 4 years, 7 months ago

Objection! Second law does not speak about any acceleration, second law is that force is change of momentum over time(if F=ma was the 2nd NL, then we could never acieve the space age, since you HAVE TO derive the MASS, not only speed).

Michal Krištof - 7 years, 4 months ago

Log in to reply

This made me intrigued. :/

Alexander Paul - 7 years, 4 months ago

But these are not relativistic speeds and the F=ma approximation holds good. Cheers!

Aritra Das - 5 years, 3 months ago
Prasun Biswas
Jan 13, 2014

According to Newton's 3rd law, "to each and every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction". When the wingsuit flyer has to change his direction of flight, he would try to shift to the opposite direction of which he wishes to go. The reaction force exerted by the air to the wingsuit flyer then tries to oppose the applied force and thus the wingsuit flyer can control his direction of flight.

Raghav Dua
Jan 12, 2014

This answer adheres to the concept of Terminal Velocity. When we fall from a height, we are accelerating. However, there is air resistance opposing us, thus lowering our acceleration. Eventually, our velocity becomes constant and accelerations becomes zero and we can control lifts and direction. Terminal Velocity simply occurs because there is a force of Air resistance acting against our force of Gravitation. Since eventually these 2 forces are equal (and thus, no more acceleration), we can say that the downward force had an equal and opposite force in the upward direction, so both cancelled each other out. This corresponds to Newton's 3rd Law (Every force has equal and opposite force).

I hope I don't confuse you :)

No.. though you are right about terminal velocity, this mechanism cannot generate horizontal force.. point is to generate horizontal force though there is no engine.. this can be done using Netwon's third law..

Snehal Shekatkar - 7 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

wait. I don't understand why you are saying "though there's no engine". As in an engine to generate force in the upward direction (to oppose motion) or the downward?

Raghav Dua - 7 years, 5 months ago

Log in to reply

Trick is to generate horizontal force to land at different places on ground or to change it in the air itself.

Snehal Shekatkar - 7 years, 5 months ago

Newton's thrd law states tht every action have equal and opposite reaction(antr eg:recoil of gun)

muhammad rishad - 6 years, 10 months ago
Shekhar Chaudhary
Sep 11, 2015

No such fourth law of newtons. answer is c

Janelle Margallo
Jul 22, 2015

Haha. I knew it. The fourth choice was a bluff.

Lucky Khan
Jan 26, 2014

Because his weight is pushing him downward as an action but the atmospheric air exert an upward force as a reaction. and Newton third law is "EVERY ACTION HAS AN EQUAL BUT OPPOSITE REACTION"

That is wrong. Air resistance and weight are NOT action reaction pairs. An action reaction pair ,must be the same TYPE of force and must act on different bodies

Saad Haider - 7 years, 4 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...