Power Divides power

Does there exist positive integers n n such that

5 n 9 n 1 ? 5^n \mid 9^n - 1 \quad ?

No Yes, but infinitely many Yes, but finitely many

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

2 solutions

Calvin Lin Staff
Nov 16, 2016

Observe that 9 n 1 = ( 3 n 1 ) ( 3 n + 1 ) 9^n - 1 = (3^n -1 ) ( 3^n + 1 ) .
We have gcd ( 3 n 1 , 3 n + 1 ) = gcd ( 2 , 3 n 1 ) = 2 \gcd ( 3^n -1 , 3^n + 1 ) = \gcd ( 2 , 3^n -1 ) = 2 .
Hence, at most one of these terms is divisible by 5.

Then, if 5 n 9 n 1 5^n \mid 9^n - 1 , we must either have 5 n 3 n 1 5^n \mid 3^n - 1 or 5 n 3 n + 1 5^n \mid 3^n + 1 .
However, since 5 n > 3 n + 1 > 3 n 1 > 9 5 ^n > 3^n + 1 > 3^n - 1 > 9 , hence this is not possible. Thus, there are no solutions.


This question can be generalized to deal with p n a 2 n 1 p^n \mid a^{2n} -1 .

Kushal Bose
Nov 15, 2016

9 n 1 = ( 10 1 ) n 1 9^n-1=(10-1)^n-1

if n = 5 k m n=5^k m where m Z + m \in \mathbb{Z^+} and m m is not a multiple of 5 5

Case(1) : If m = 2 l + 1 m=2 l+1 then

9 n 1 = ( 10 1 ) 5 k ( 2 l + 1 ) 1 = 10 p 1 1 = 10 p 2 = 2 ( 5 p 1 ) 9^n-1=(10-1)^{5^k(2l+1)}-1=10p-1-1=10p-2=2(5p-1)

It has not a single factor of 5 5 .So, no such integer exists.

Case(2) : If m = 2 l m=2 l then

9 n 1 = ( 10 1 ) 5 k 2 l 1 = 1 0 5 k 2 l ( 5 k 2 l 1 ) 1 0 ( 5 k 2 l 1 ) + + ( 5 k 2 l ( 5 k 2 l 1 ) ) 10 + 1 1 = 1 0 5 k 2 l ( 5 k 2 l 1 ) 1 0 ( 5 k 2 l 1 ) + + ( 5 k 2 l 10 ) 9^n-1=(10-1)^{5^k 2 l}-1 \\ =10^{5^k 2 l}-{5^k 2 l \choose 1}10^{(5^k 2l-1)}+ \cdots +{5^k 2 l \choose (5^k 2 l-1)}10 +1-1 \\ =10^{5^k 2 l}-{5^k 2 l \choose 1}10^{(5^k 2l-1)}+ \cdots +(5^k 2 l*10)

It can have maximum of 5 k + 1 5^{k+1} as a factor But the dividend is 5 5 k m 5^{5^k m} .So, obviously 5 k m > ( k + 1 ) 5^k m>(k+1) .

So ,there is no n n

Well, you showed that there is a factor of 5 in 9 2 n 1 9^{2n} - 1 . What can't there be another factor of 5? As an explicit example, 25 9 10 1 25 \mid 9^{10} - 1 .

The case of n = 2 k + 1 n = 2k + 1 works, with 5 ∤ 9 n 1 5 \not \mid 9^n-1 .

Calvin Lin Staff - 4 years, 7 months ago

Log in to reply

updated my solution. plz check it

Kushal Bose - 4 years, 7 months ago

Log in to reply

I think your binomial equation is wrong. The first line should start off as

1 0 5 k 2 l ( 5 k 2 l 1 ) 1 0 ( 5 k 2 l 1 ) + 10^{ 5^k 2l } - { 5^k 2l \choose 1 } 10^ { (5^k 2l - 1) } + \ldots

The power in the second terms should be 5 k 2 l 1 5^k 2l - 1 instead of 5 k ( 2 l 1 ) 5^k (2l-1) .

Calvin Lin Staff - 4 years, 7 months ago

Log in to reply

@Calvin Lin I have corrected .Is my solution now correct???

Kushal Bose - 4 years, 7 months ago

Log in to reply

@Kushal Bose It is not immediately apparent that the largest factor is 5 k + 1 5^{k+1} . For example, 110 + 20 + 170 110 + 20 + 170 is a multiple of 100, even though the largest factor of 10 that divides any individual term is 10.

You will need to show that it is of the form 5 k + 1 M 5^{k+1} M where M M is not a multiple of 5.

Calvin Lin Staff - 4 years, 7 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...