Rotary variable capacitor

A variable capacitor consists of two metal semicircles of radius R R with vertical separation d . d. The capacitor is charged when φ = 0 , \varphi=0, and is then disconnected from the voltage source. The discs are then rotated through the angle φ = 9 0 . \varphi = 90^\circ.

How does the rotation change the energy that's stored in the capacitor?

The energy is halved The energy remains constant The energy is doubled

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

5 solutions

Brandon Johnson
Nov 28, 2017

Given the limited solution choices, we can simply thing about the work that it would take to make the rotation. Simply put, the positive charge on one plate attract the negative charge on the other plate. Rotating by 90 degrees pulls the charges apart and would take positive work, so the system energy must increase (i.e. not stay the same or halve).

(You may be worried that the charge density will move around during the rotation, and it no doubt will due to the changing geometry of the capacitor. As I'm writing this, I can't think or a really qualitative reason why we can discount this. Reply if you have a simple qualitative argument to this effect.)

Relevant wiki: Capacitors

The electrical charge Q Q equally distributed over the overlapping area A ( φ ) = ( π φ ) R 2 A(\varphi) = (\pi - \varphi) R^2 of both disks. Gauss' law results E d A = E A ( φ ) = Q ε 0 E = Q ε 0 ( π φ ) R 2 U = E d r = E d = Q d ε 0 ( π φ ) R 2 = Q C C = ε 0 ( π φ ) R 2 d = ε 0 A ( φ ) d \begin{aligned} & & \oint \vec E \cdot d\vec A &= E A(\varphi) = \frac{Q}{\varepsilon_0}\\ \Rightarrow & & E &= \frac{Q}{\varepsilon_0 (\pi - \varphi) R^2} \\ \Rightarrow & & U &= \int \vec E \cdot d\vec r = E d = \frac{Q d}{\varepsilon_0 (\pi - \varphi) R^2} = \frac{Q}{C} \\ \Rightarrow & & C &= \frac{\varepsilon_0 (\pi - \varphi) R^2}{d} = \frac{\varepsilon_0 A(\varphi)}{d} \end{aligned} with the electric field E E , voltage U U , capacitance C C and permittivity ε 0 \varepsilon_0 . If a differential amount d Q dQ of charge is transferred from one capacitor surface to the other, this requires energy d W = U d Q dW = U dQ . Integration of the charge results W = 0 Q U d Q = 0 Q Q C d Q = 1 2 Q 2 C = d Q 2 2 ε 0 ( π φ ) R 2 W = \int_{0}^Q U dQ = \int_{0}^Q \frac{Q}{C} dQ = \frac{1}{2} \frac{Q^2}{C} = \frac{d Q^2}{2 \varepsilon_0 (\pi - \varphi) R^2} Therefore, W ( φ = π 2 ) = 2 W ( φ = 0 ) W(\varphi = \dfrac{\pi}{2}) = 2 W(\varphi = 0)

Since the given plate is metallic, charge Q will distribute on it uniformly. Therefore, the net charge between the capacitor plates after rotation will be reduced to half. So how can you assume it to be constant?

Mukund Khandelwal - 3 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

A electric charge is only distributed uniformly on a metal surface, if no external electric fields are present. But the opposite charges on the different plates attract each other, so that the charge is distributed only on the overlapping areas of the capacitor (striped area). Futhermore, the capacitor is disconnected from the circuit, so that the charge has to be constant, since there is no electric current.

Markus Michelmann - 3 years, 6 months ago

Well I must confess I am not too clever but I still wonder if the circuit has been disconect where the energy come from to double it.

Mara Jares - 3 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

Well, you have to use a mechanical force to twist the capacitor plates to each other. The charges on a capacitor plate repel each other. To turn the capacitor to the position ϕ = 9 0 \phi=90^\circ , some mechanical work must be done against the electrostatic force

Markus Michelmann - 3 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

It that will mean that once we stop the turning the plates they should return back to its oiginal position like a compressed spring ?

Mara Jares - 3 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

@Mara Jares In principle, that's exactly what should happen. However, the restoring torque is relatively small and may not even overcome the static friction.

Markus Michelmann - 3 years, 6 months ago

I do not follow you. Conceptually indeed the density of energy per square inch of the capacitor has doubled increasing voltage since Q remains constant, but by the same token the area has halved so the total energy stored remains equal . If it were just as your solution indicate we can theoretically transform mechanical work into electric power by acting cycle and periodically in a variable capacitor. I never seen such device. Think what can happen if you keep halving your area one time after another till reach near zero... it will the energy stored became infinite... by no means what probably will happen that voltage rises to a point that the dielectric become conductive and you get an spark.

Mariano PerezdelaCruz - 3 years, 6 months ago

I reviewed again your math and is my strong belief that Q remains constant then dQ=0, therefore there is not change of Energy. Nevertheless since the surface of capacitor has decreased and system is isolated, U must increase to fulfill the equation U*C=Q

Mariano PerezdelaCruz - 3 years, 6 months ago
Riccardo Banzi
Nov 29, 2017

Hello, it's the first time I try to write a solution. Plus, I'm not a native speaker, so please let me know if something is unclear!

Assuming the charge Q Q is constant, we can use Gauss' Law to calculate the field E E inside the capacitor.

E d A = E A = Q ε 0 \oint\vec E \cdot d\vec A = EA=\frac{Q}{\varepsilon_0}

So we get:

E = Q A ε 0 E=\frac{Q}{A\varepsilon_0}

The energy stored in the capacitor is obtained by evaluating the following integral:

W = ε 0 2 V E 2 d V W=\frac{\varepsilon_0}{2}\iiint_V E^2 \,dV

Where V is the volume occupied by the field. Since E E is constant, we get:

W = Q 2 V 2 A 2 ε 0 W=\frac{Q^2 V}{2A^2 \varepsilon_0}

Now, we don't even need to calculate A A and V V , since after the rotation they are both halved. The fileds are:

E ( φ = 0 ° ) = Q A ε 0 E(\varphi=0°)=\frac{Q}{A\varepsilon_0}

E ( φ = 90 ° ) = 2 Q A ε 0 E(\varphi=90°)=\frac{2Q}{A\varepsilon_0}

And the energy stored is:

W ( φ = 0 ° ) = Q 2 V 2 A 2 ε 0 W(\varphi=0°)=\frac{Q^2 V}{2A^2 \varepsilon_0}

W ( φ = 90 ° ) = 4 Q 2 2 A 2 ε 0 V 2 W(\varphi=90°)=\frac{4Q^2}{2A^2 \varepsilon_0}\frac{V}{2}

If we calculate the ratio between W ( φ = 90 ° ) W(\varphi=90°) and W ( φ = 0 ° ) W(\varphi=0°) we get 2.

I hope I didn't make mistakes.

Hello Friends Here We That Energy Stored In A Capacitor Of Capacitance 'C' Voltage 'V' Is E=(1/2 )C V^2

But V=Q/C ,Where Q is Charge Then E=(Q^2)/2C ....Here At 0° Area =A But At 90° Area =A/2 So As We

Know That C=€A/d C also becomes halved....As Enegry Is Inversely Dependent On 'C' It Will Be DOUBLED..

Sai Charan Thumuluru - 3 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

but,doesn't the effect of the charge of those two parallel plates change after rotation?if don't,why?

Log in to reply

Hello Friend...!!! Here You Have To Observe That The Capacitor Was Connected To Volatage

Souce And Then Removed...So The Capacitor Is Charged To A Fixed Value...

As the Area Decreases Capacitance Decreases Which In Turn Increases The Voltage

(Potential Difference Between The Plates) Keeping The Charge Costant....Please Reply My

Friend...Have U Understood

Sai Charan Thumuluru - 3 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

@Sai Charan Thumuluru Point To Ponder Is That Our Capacitor Here Is Not Allowed To Discharge....So The

Charge Remains Same....

Sai Charan Thumuluru - 3 years, 6 months ago

Log in to reply

@Sai Charan Thumuluru R u from West Bengal..?

Sai Charan Thumuluru - 3 years, 6 months ago

@Sai Charan Thumuluru i have understood,hadikALLAH !

Gregory Lewis
Dec 13, 2017

The electrons and holes are originally a little upset about their situation, and how crowded they are, but as long as the plates are close together, they're not too upset, because they can at least see their friends. When the plates are separated, though, they become even more upset about their situation, so the energy increases.

Filippo Cona
Dec 3, 2017

Can anybody tell me if my solution is right or if I'm missing something?

The potential energy U stored by a capacitor is U = 1 2 C V 2 U=\frac{1}{2}CV^2 and since q = C V q=CV then U = 1 2 q 2 C U=\frac{1}{2}\frac{q^2}{C} , where C is the capacitance, q is the electrical charge and V is the potential.

During the rotation the charge remains unchanged while the capacitance is halved since it is proportional to the conductors overlapping area, so the energy doubles.

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...