So Many Great Circles

3 great circles cut the sphere into at most 8 regions.

What is the greatest number of regions that 30 great circles can cut the sphere into?

Note: A great circle on a sphere is the intersection of a sphere with a plane that contains the sphere's center.


The answer is 872.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

5 solutions

Marta Reece
May 19, 2018

The first circle creates two areas.

After that, every great circle added intersects every great circle already there in two points. The number of intersections is maximized if none of these points coincide.

In that case adding circle number n n results in 2 ( n 1 ) 2(n-1) new intersections. These intersections are connected by the same number of segments and each of these segments creates a new area. So adding a circle number n n adds 2 ( n 1 ) 2(n-1) new areas.

The answer then is the 2 2 areas generated by the first circle plus twice the sum of all numbers from 1 to 29 29 .

Using the formula for the sum of first n n integers as n ( n + 1 ) 2 \frac{n(n+1)}2 , we get 2 + 2 29 30 2 = 2 + 29 30 = 872 2+2\cdot\frac{29\cdot30}2=2+29\cdot30=\boxed{872} .

I am proud I solved this one 😁, but I have a question: Is there a number of 'great circles' such that when you get to it, you can no longer prevent intersecting a point where two circles already intersect?

Log in to reply

There is no upper limit on the number of those circles.

Marta Reece - 3 years ago
Mark Hennings
May 10, 2018

Relevant wiki: Linear Recurrence Relations - Problem Solving

Suppose that n n great circles can be used to form a maximum of X n X_n regions on sphere. We will be able to create X n X_n regions with no more than two great circles meeting at any point on the sphere.If we consider adding an extra great circle, it can be drawn so that no more than two great circles meet at any point on the sphere. The new great circle will meet each of the previous n n great circles twice.

Each time the new great circle intersects an old great circle, it will create a new region on the sphere. Thus we deduce that X n + 1 = X n + 2 n X_{n+1} = X_n + 2n . Solving this recurrence relation, together with the initial condition X 1 = 2 X_1 = 2 , we obtain X n = n 2 n + 2 X_n = n^2 - n + 2 . Thus X 30 = 872 X_{30} = \boxed{872} .

Also, we can apply stereographic projection to turn this problem into a very familiar one.

Calvin Lin Staff - 3 years ago

The problem does not even need to specify that they are great circles. Just "circles" would be sufficient. The maximum number of areas would not change.

Marta Reece - 3 years ago

Log in to reply

(This comment is untrue.)

In fact, with great circles, we will always get the maximum number of regions (since every 2 great circles intersect).

Let me edit the question accordingly.

Calvin Lin Staff - 3 years ago

Log in to reply

That is not true. If we consider n n great circles that all pass through the north and south poles ( circles of longitude) we only get 2 n 2n regions. It is not just that every two circles should intersect, but also that at most two circles intersect at any point.

Mark Hennings - 3 years ago

Log in to reply

@Mark Hennings Ah yes. I remembered that afterward but even fixed the problem, but forgot to edit my comment. Thanks for reminding me.

Calvin Lin Staff - 3 years ago

So then it is true that they don't need to be great circles right?

Pau Cantos - 3 years ago

Can you please explain why?

Vaibhav Prabhu - 3 years ago

Log in to reply

All you need is that every circle crosses every other circle, and that only at most two circles meet at a point. It is quite possible for this to happen without the circles being great circles.

Mark Hennings - 3 years ago
David Vreken
May 20, 2018

Relevant wiki: Regular Polyhedra

Since 2 2 great circles can meet at 2 2 different points, n n great circles can create at most 2 ( n 2 ) = n ( n 1 ) 2 \cdot \binom{n}{2} = n(n - 1) intersection points.

Since each intersection point has 4 4 arcs emanating from them (as long as the number of regions is being maximized), and each arc between intersection points shares 2 2 points, there are 4 2 n ( n 1 ) = 2 n ( n 1 ) \frac{4}{2} \cdot n(n - 1) = 2n(n - 1) arcs between intersection points.

The intersection points, the arcs between the intersection points, and regions can be projected to the vertices, edges, and faces of a polyhedron, and so by Euler's formula F + V = E + 2 F + V = E + 2 . Since V = n ( n 1 ) V = n(n - 1) and E = 2 n ( n 1 ) E = 2n(n - 1) , F + n ( n 1 ) = 2 n ( n 1 ) + 2 F + n(n - 1) = 2n(n - 1) + 2 or F = n 2 n + 2 F = n^2 - n + 2 .

Therefore, 30 30 great circles will cut the sphere into 3 0 2 30 + 2 = 872 30^2 - 30 + 2 = \boxed{872} regions.

As an aside, you don't need to "project to a polyhedron". You can apply the formula to F E + V = F - E + V = euler characteristic of the (surface of the) sphere, which is 2.

Calvin Lin Staff - 3 years ago
Calvin Lin Staff
May 24, 2018

Consider any arrangement of n n circles on the sphere.
Take a point that doesn't lie on this sphere.
Take the stereographic projection of the sphere onto the plane.
We thus get the equivalent question of:


Given n n circles on the plane, what is the maximum number of regions that there can be? (Include the outside region)

The answer to this (much more familiar) problem is n 2 n + 2 n^2 - n + 2 .

The proof is very similar to those above, where you count the number of intersection points. (Which shouldn't be surprising, because these are equivalent problems).

Osir Isrex
May 20, 2018

2 great circles can divide the sphere into at most 4 sections. In the case of 3 great circles, the 3rd is able to pass through at most 4 of the regions, and divides each one into 2, which adds 4 new regions for a total of 4+4=8 regions. Add a 4th great circle, and it's able to pass through at most 6 regions, dividing each into 2 and adding 6 new regions for a total of 8+6=14 regions. A 5th great circle can pass through at most 8 for total of 14+8=22 regions, and so on, adding the next even number to the total until 30 great circles, where you reach a total of 872 regions. I'm honestly not sure if this is a valid technique, but it yielded the correct answer.

You're making a common misconception here in your proof. Do you see the (slightly) flawed logic?

Hint: This solution is essentially doing induction , so being aware of its pitfalls is helpful.

Calvin Lin Staff - 3 years ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...