This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
Note that S = ∑ n = 0 ∞ 5 n + 1 1 − ( ∑ n = 0 ∞ 5 n + 4 1 ) is not a true statement. We cannot rearrange the order of terms of a conditionally convergent sequence.
How can we approach this problem if it was ∑ 5 n + 1 1 − 5 n + 2 1 instead?
Challenge Master: Sorry about that, I am not well familiar with the convergence ideas and rules... Do you mean that I should find a general term for the original sequence?
Log in to reply
No. If you look at the way that you've rewritten the summation, observe that the blue terms sum up to ∞ and the red terms sum up to ∞ . So, what you have is S = ∞ − ∞ , which is undefined.
In a conditionally convergent subsequence, we are not allowed to "randomly rearrange" the order of the terms. Doing so could lead to a different result.
Log in to reply
I have got your point.
I have edited the solution, My apologies if it is still wrong. Is it Okay now?
Log in to reply
@Hasan Kassim – I don't think that is a property of the Digamma function, is it? Because it seems to me that you're saying ψ ( a ) = − ∞ , which is not true.
Log in to reply
@Calvin Lin – I have Used the harmonic numbers instead, hope now the solution is sufficiently true.
The property of the Digamma function that I have used is here .
Maybe I misunderstood something... !!
Log in to reply
@Hasan Kassim – Yes. It involves regularization , which is a (somewhat complicated) way of assigning a value to some divergent sequences.
E.g. People who say that 1 + 2 + 3 + … = − 1 2 1 are performing a type of regularization, and most of them do not fully understand what they are doing.
So, in your solution, you have been ignoring many of these "calculus conditions", which would help us ensure that we get a proper / correct valuation.
Why can't we randomly rearrange a conditional subsequence? Can You please explain.
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
Denote our sum by S .Let's group the terms: Positives and Negatives:
S = 1 1 + 6 1 + 1 1 1 . . . − ( 4 1 + 9 1 + 1 4 1 . . . )
Focus on the denominators : they differ by 5 in each set of terms.So we can rewrite as :
S = k → ∞ lim ( n = 0 ∑ k 5 n + 1 1 − n = 0 ∑ k 5 n + 4 1 )
= k → ∞ lim 5 1 ( n = 0 ∑ k n + 5 1 1 − n = 0 ∑ k n + 5 4 1 )
Now Just take out the value at n = 0 :
S = 4 3 + k → ∞ lim 5 1 ( n = 1 ∑ k n + 5 1 1 − n = 1 ∑ k n + 5 4 1 )
Recall the definition of the Harmonic Number for any real positive x :
H x = n = 1 ∑ ∞ n ( x + n ) x
= k → ∞ lim n = 1 ∑ k n ( x + n ) x
= k → ∞ lim ( n = 1 ∑ k n 1 − n = 1 ∑ k n + x 1 )
Therefore:
k → ∞ lim n = 1 ∑ k n + x 1 = k → ∞ lim H k − H x
Substitute that in S :
S = 4 3 + 5 1 ( k → ∞ lim n = 1 ∑ k n + 5 1 1 − k → ∞ lim n = 1 ∑ k n + 5 4 1 )
= 4 3 + 5 1 ( k → ∞ lim H k − H 5 1 − ( k → ∞ lim H k − H 5 4 ) )
= 4 3 + 5 1 ( H 5 4 − H 5 1 )
Recall the Reflection formula for the Harmonic Numbers :
H 1 − z − H z = π cot ( π z ) − z 1 + 1 − z 1
= > S = 5 π cot 5 π
= 2 5 π 2 5 + 1 0 5