x 1 1 + x 1 1 1
If x is a real number that satisfies the equation x 3 + x 3 1 = 1 8 , find the value of the expression above.
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
This question ultimately boils down to figuring out the value of x + x 1 , and you have to be careful to reject the other values. Otherwise, we could obtain other solutions.
For the third line, you need to show that x + x 1 equals to 3 only. This is because it is a cubic equation, so there can be another 2 roots. So you need to explain why the other two roots are rejected.
Log in to reply
First I also ad hoc took x+1/x = 3 and found the answer, but for rigorous approach we have to show that the other two roots of the cubic equation are complex.
Steps written here are excellent mathematics. However, I think people of these days who use computers could solve by computing method which I find faster and posses more immediate confidence for correctness.
2.618033989 0.381966011
-1.13687E-13 7.99361E-15
39603 39603
Log in to reply
You can actually use Wolfram Alpha to solve a lot of problems here even Calculus ones. But that is not the objective of this website. We promote the use of math rather than computer unless it is a computer science problem. It is not how fast you do it with calculator or computer but how to do it without these tools.
Log in to reply
All right. Thanks!
Log in to reply
@Lu Chee Ket – Why can't computers and calculators be used to further pure mathematics? Why do they need to be limited to computer science problems only? For this particular problem, I see the benefit of analytical techniques. Perhaps other fields, like numerical analysis, Differential equations, to name a few can benefit from the use of technology.
Log in to reply
@Rob Matuschek – For practicing strength to think perhaps. Provided the worry of decreasing of efforts for future generations to think can be eliminated, I think using computers and calculators to solve mathematical problems is a very realistic approach: Fast, accurate and immediate confidence of correctness. This is what technology is developed for. I think solving mathematics with technology is a smart way, provided we are confident enough onto own intelligence.
Log in to reply
@Lu Chee Ket – I am not disputing the use of computers to advance mathematics and solving mathematical problems in the real world. But for this simple Algebra problem in Brilliant.org. The intention, I believe, is for learning members to learn how to solve it using Algebra. And we are providing solutions for that intention. I was just saying use computer to solve computer science problems in Brilliant.org not the outside real world. In fact, I didn't learn Number Theory in schools, and I have been solving NT problems here using computer and I am level 5, but I am still no good in NT. I solved most of the problems here using Wolfram Alpha, Python and Excel spreadsheet then fit in the proper Calculus, Algebra and Number Theory solutions.
Log in to reply
@Chew-Seong Cheong – Similar. There happens that everyone is acting like strong. Actually, we all are using technologies. Nevertheless, your writings in pure mathematics are excellent.
Sir can you please expain that we have to choose the value of x + x 1 = 3 only by checking or there is some method of it or just to plugin some natural nos and check that the equation satisfys ??
Log in to reply
You can solve it using rational root theorem.
Log in to reply
the median time to solve the problem takes 9 minutes. How about thinking for a nice solution to this problem? Does it also takes only less than minutes or more?
Log in to reply
@Phak Mi Uph – It really depends on the problem. This one should be just minutes. I would have solved this one using Newton sum method with an Excel spreadsheet then thought out the solution.
How did you realize that x + 1/x = 3 ?
Log in to reply
( x + x 1 ) 3 − 3 ( x + x 1 ) − 1 8 = 0 is the form u 3 − 3 u − 1 8 = 0 . You can get the solution of u = 3 by trial and error using rational root theorem. That is if there is rational root, it has to be a divisor of 1 8 , that is ± 1 , ± 2 , ± 3 , ± 6 , ± 9 .
First note that ( x + x 1 ) 2 = x 2 + x 2 1 + 2 , and that
( x + x 1 ) ( x 2 + x 2 1 ) = x 3 + x 3 1 + ( x + x 1 ) .
Letting a = x + x 1 , this last equation then becomes
a ( a 2 − 2 ) = 1 8 + a ⟹ a 3 − 3 a − 1 8 = 0 ⟹ ( a − 3 ) ( a 2 + 3 a + 6 ) = 0 .
Since the discriminant of a 2 + 3 a + 6 is − 1 5 < 0 , and since with x real we must have a real, we see that a = x + x 1 = 3 . Thus
x 2 + x 2 1 = 7 ⟹ x 4 + x 4 1 = ( x 2 + x 2 1 ) 2 − 2 = 4 9 − 2 = 4 7 .
Now ( x 3 + x 3 1 ) ( x 4 + x 4 1 ) = x 7 + x 7 1 + ( x + x 1 )
⟹ x 7 + x 7 1 = 1 8 ∗ 4 7 − 3 = 8 4 3 .
Next, ( x 7 + x 7 1 ) ( x 4 + x 4 1 ) = x 1 1 + x 1 1 1 + ( x 3 + x 3 1 )
⟹ x 1 1 + x 1 1 1 = 8 4 3 ∗ 4 7 − 1 8 = 3 9 6 0 3 .
For problems where we want to calculate F n = x n + x n 1 , a direct approach (without having to work out the factorization) it to use the recurrence relation
F n + 1 = ( x + x 1 ) F n − F n − 1 .
In this case, we have F 0 = 2 , F 1 = 3 and the recurrence F n + 2 = 3 F n + 1 − F n .
In the 2nd line yo have written (x+1/x^2) but it will be (x+1/x) if I am not mistaken.
Nicely done, Brian. Thanks.
Mess-free calculator trick.
If x is a real number, then it must be positive, since negative values of x cannot result in a positive x 3 + 1 / x 3 ; and x = 0 would probably spawn a black hole.
Since x is positive, we can safely substitute x = exp ( a ) . By definition of cosh , note that
x 3 + x 3 1 = 2 cosh 3 a = 1 8
a = 3 1 cosh − 1 9
x 1 1 + x 1 1 1 = 2 cosh 1 1 a = 2 cosh ( 3 1 1 cosh − 1 9 )
Punch some calculator buttons to get 39603
Brilliant method! Liked it so much
It is given that x 3 + x 3 1 = 1 8 .
Let us assume that x + x 1 = a .
Now, ( x + x 1 ) 3 = x 3 + 3 ( x + x 1 ) + x 3 1 .
Putting a = x + x 1 and x 3 + x 3 1 = 1 8 we get ,
a 3 = 1 8 + 3 a ⇒ a 3 − 3 a − 1 8 = 0 ⇒ ( a − 3 ) ( a 2 + 3 a + 6 = 0 . )
Now,observe that the discriminant of a 2 + 3 a + 6 is − 1 5 < 0 , there are no real roots.
Therefore a = 3 is the only root.
⇒ x + x 1 = a = 3 .
Again, x 2 + x 2 1 = 7 , x 3 + x 3 1 = 1 8 , x 4 + x 4 1 = 4 7 , x 8 + x 8 1 = 2 2 0 7 .
( x 3 + x 3 1 ) ( x 2 + x 2 1 ) = x 5 + x 5 1 + ( x + x 1 ) = ( 1 8 ) ( 7 ) = 1 2 6 ⇒ x 5 + x 5 1 = 1 2 3 .
( x 8 + x 8 1 ) ( x 3 + x 3 1 ) = x 1 1 + x 1 1 1 + ( x 5 + x 5 1 ) = ( 2 2 0 7 ) ( 1 8 ) = 3 9 7 2 6 . ⇒ x 1 1 + x 1 1 1 = 3 9 7 2 6 − 1 2 3 = 3 9 6 0 3 .
Thanks for this solution, i love it
Log in to reply
Thanks : )
Then why don't you up vote ?
I did not understand the process, could you please redo it in another way? Thanks
Great, Sai Ram. Slightly different from Brian's solution. Thanks.
I suppose you forgot to subtract 123 from the 39726.
Instead of going in direction of x + (1÷x) and then finding the solution mentioned by chew seong , we can alternatively find x . then put it in the required expression to form a question of simple binomial
If you multiply the bottom equation by x^3, you get x^6-18x^3+1=0. Then if you substitute y=x^3, you get a nice and easy quadratic equation. The solutions for y are 9+-4sqrt(5), which you can substitute the cube root into the problem. Both result in the same answer. To see why these are the only real solutions, factor the equation x^6-18x^3+1=0 (solving this is the same as solving the equation in the problem). let theu two known roots be a and b. Then (x^3-a)(x^3-b)=0 we can then use the identity m^3-n^3=(m-n)(m^2+mn+n^2).. The quadratic here has Nonreal solutions. Now it's clear that all the other roots are not real.
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
( x + x 1 ) 3 ( x + x 1 ) 3 ⇒ x + x 1 = x 3 + 3 x + x 3 + x 3 1 = 1 8 + 3 ( x + x 1 ) − 3 ( x + x 1 ) − 1 8 = 0 = 3
( x + x 1 ) 2 ⇒ x 2 + x 2 1 ⇒ x 4 + x 4 1 ⇒ x 8 + x 8 1 = x 2 + 2 + x 2 1 = 9 = 7 = 7 2 − 2 = 4 7 = 4 7 2 − 2 = 2 2 0 7
( x 3 + x 3 1 ) ( x 2 + x 2 1 ) 1 8 ( 7 ) ⇒ x 5 + x 5 1 ( x 8 + x 8 1 ) ( x 3 + x 3 1 ) 2 2 0 7 ( 1 8 ) ⇒ x 1 1 + x 1 1 1 = x 5 + x + x 1 + x 5 1 = x 5 + x 5 1 + 3 = 1 2 3 = x 1 1 + x 5 + x 5 1 + x 1 1 1 = x 1 1 + x 1 1 1 + 1 2 3 = 3 9 7 2 6 − 1 2 3 = 3 9 6 0 3