Trigo Lovers-2

Geometry Level 4

Find sum of all acute angles x x in degrees satisfying the equation 2 sin x cos 4 0 = sin ( x + 2 0 ) 2\sin x \cos 40^{\circ} = \sin(x+20^{\circ})


The answer is 30.

This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and, finally, (c) loading the non-javascript version of this page . We're sorry about the hassle.

3 solutions

Ravi Dwivedi
Jul 16, 2015

Notice x = 3 0 x=30^{\circ} is a solution since cos 4 0 = sin 5 0 \cos 40 ^ \circ = \sin 50 ^ \circ .

Now using sin ( A + B ) = sin A cos B + sin B cos A \sin(A+B)=\sin A\cos B+\sin B\cos A we get

2 sin x cos 4 0 = sin ( x + 2 0 ) 2\sin x \cos 40^{\circ} = \sin(x+20^{\circ})

2 sin x cos 4 0 = sin x cos 2 0 + cos x sin 2 0 2\sin x \cos 40^{\circ} = \sin x \cos 20^{\circ}+ \cos x \sin 20^{\circ}

If cos x = 0 \cos x = 0 , then x = 9 0 + 18 0 k x = 90 ^ \circ + 180 ^\circ k , and we can check that these are not solutions. Thus, we can divide both sides by cos x 0 \cos x \neq 0 to get

2 tan x cos 4 0 = tan x cos 2 0 + sin 2 0 2\tan x \cos 40^{\circ} = \tan x \cos 20^{\circ}+ \sin 20^{\circ}

tan x = sin 2 0 2 cos 4 0 cos 2 0 \tan x = \frac{\sin 20^{\circ}}{2\cos 40^{\circ} -\cos 20^{\circ}}

Recall that x = 3 0 x = 30 ^ \circ was a solution to the original equation. The series of steps that we took have not changed the solution set. Since function tan x \tan x is one one on ( 0 , 9 0 ) (0,90^{\circ}) , this implies that there is a unique solution to the final equation. Thus, the only solution is x = 3 0 x = 30 ^ \circ .

Hence answer is 3 0 \boxed{30^{\circ}}

cant we solve the expression u got for tan x \tan x . I tried my best but got stuck, plz reply quick

Tanishq Varshney - 5 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

U cannot solve as far as i think. But see the equation in the end we got is tan x = k \tan x=k where k k is a constant. Now tan x \tan x is increasing in ( 0 , 9 0 ) (0,90^{\circ}) So it has only one solution in this interval Observing that x = 30 x=30 is a solution is necessary trick.

Ravi Dwivedi - 5 years, 11 months ago

x = 3 0 x=30^{\circ} is a solution

Now tan x \tan x is increasing in ( 0 , 9 0 ) (0,90^{\circ})

So tan x = k \tan x=k can be achieved for only one x x in ( 0 , 9 0 ) (0,90^{\circ})

Ravi Dwivedi - 5 years, 11 months ago

Log in to reply

Right, so you should explain that x = 3 0 x = 30 ^ \circ is a solution to the equation tan x = sin 2 0 2 cos 4 0 cos 2 0 \tan x = \frac{ \sin 20 ^ \circ } { 2 \cos 40 ^ \circ - \cos 20 ^ \circ } That is not obvious.

Calvin Lin Staff - 5 years, 10 months ago

Log in to reply

Put x = 3 0 x=30^{\circ} in the original equation and the original equation is same as this one

Ravi Dwivedi - 5 years, 10 months ago

Log in to reply

@Ravi Dwivedi Ah I see, that's what you were referring to (and so my original not isn't valid). However, a similar issue remains, namely that "original equation is same as this one" has not been expressed clearly and correctly.

The main point is that you have to explain why the solution set hasn't changed despite all of the manipulations we have done. In particular, we have to ensure that cos x 0 \cos x \neq 0 , in order to confirm that we didn't lose any solutions.

I've updated your solution to reflect this.

Calvin Lin Staff - 5 years, 10 months ago

Log in to reply

@Calvin Lin question is same and for acute angles cos x 0 \cos x \neq 0

Ravi Dwivedi - 5 years, 10 months ago

Here I will use the sum to product formulas to simplify the equation:

2 sin x cos 4 0 = sin x cos 2 0 + cos x sin 2 0 sin x ( 2 cos 4 0 cos 2 0 ) = cos x sin 2 0 sin x ( cos 4 0 + cos 4 0 cos 2 0 ) = cos x sin 2 0 sin x ( cos 4 0 sin 1 0 ) = cos x sin 2 0 sin x ( sin 5 0 sin 1 0 ) = cos x sin 2 0 sin x ( 2 cos 3 0 sin 2 0 ) = cos x sin 2 0 2 sin x cos 3 0 = cos x 2\sin x \cos 40^\circ=\sin x \cos 20^\circ+\cos x\sin 20^\circ \\ \sin x(2\cos 40^\circ-\cos 20^\circ)=\cos x \sin 20^\circ \\ \sin x(\cos 40^\circ+\cos 40^\circ-\cos 20^\circ)=\cos x \sin 20^\circ \\ \sin x(\cos 40^\circ-\sin 10^\circ)=\cos x \sin 20^\circ \\ \sin x(\sin 50^\circ-\sin 10^\circ)=\cos x \sin 20^\circ \\ \sin x(2\cos 30^\circ\sin 20^\circ)=\cos x \sin 20^\circ \\ 2\sin x\cos 30^\circ=\cos x

Since cos x = 0 \cos x=0 is not a solution:

sin x cos x = 1 2 cos 3 0 tan x = sin 3 0 cos 3 0 tan x = tan 3 0 x = 3 0 + 18 0 k \dfrac{\sin x}{\cos x}=\dfrac{1}{2\cos 30^\circ} \\ \tan x=\dfrac{\sin 30^\circ}{\cos 30^\circ} \\ \tan x=\tan 30^\circ \\ x=30^\circ+180^\circ k

We are looking for an acute angle, so the only solution is x = 3 0 x=30^\circ .

Pi Han Goh
Jul 19, 2015

Disclaimer: This solution is incomplete. It only shows that x = 3 0 x=30^\circ is a solution but it did not show that it is a unique solution.

Apply product to sum formula: 2 sin ( A ) cos ( B ) = sin ( A + B 2 ) + sin ( A B 2 ) 2 \sin(A) \cos(B) = \sin\left(\frac{A+B}2 \right) + \sin \left( \frac{A-B}2 \right) .

So it becomes

sin ( x + 4 0 ) + sin ( x 4 0 ) = sin ( x + 2 0 ) sin ( x + 4 0 ) = sin ( x + 2 0 ) + sin ( 4 0 x ) cos ( 5 0 x ) = cos ( 7 0 x ) + cos ( 5 0 + x ) cos ( 5 0 x ) = cos ( 11 0 + x ) cos ( 13 0 x ) cos ( 5 0 x ) + cos ( 13 0 x ) + cos ( 11 0 + x ) = 0 cos ( 5 0 x ) + cos ( 6 0 ) + cos ( 13 0 x ) + cos ( 11 0 + x ) = 1 2 ( ) \begin{aligned} \sin(x+40^\circ) + \sin(x-40^\circ) &=& \sin(x+ 20^\circ) \\ \sin(x+40^\circ) &=& \sin(x+20^\circ) + \sin(40^\circ - x)\\ \cos(50^\circ - x) &=& \cos(70^\circ - x) + \cos(50^\circ + x) \\ \cos(50^\circ - x) &=& -\cos(110^\circ + x) - \cos(130^\circ - x) \\ \cos(50^\circ - x)+ \cos(130^\circ - x) + \cos(110^\circ + x) &=& 0 \\ \cos(50^\circ - x)+ \cos(60^\circ) + \cos(130^\circ - x) + \cos(110^\circ + x) &=& \frac12 \qquad (\ast) \\ \end{aligned}

Now we just need to show that cos ( π 9 ) + cos ( 3 π 9 ) + cos ( 5 π 9 ) + cos ( 7 π 9 ) = 1 2 \cos\left( \frac \pi9\right) + \cos\left( \frac {3\pi}9\right) + \cos\left( \frac {5 \pi}9\right) + \cos\left( \frac{7 \pi}9\right) = \frac12 .

Let w w be a complex 9th root of unity. Then w 9 = 1 w^9 = 1 . factorizing: w 8 + w 7 + w 6 + + w + 1 = 0 w^8 + w^7 + w^6 + \ldots + w + 1 = 0 and dividing by w 4 w^4 :

w 4 + w 4 + w 3 + w 3 + w 2 + w 2 + w + w 1 = 1 w^4 + w^{-4} + w^3 + w^{-3} + w^2 + w^{-2} + w + w^{-1} = -1 . But also w k + w k = 2 cos ( 2 π k 9 ) w^k + w^{-k} = 2\cos \left( \frac{2\pi k}{9}\right) . Then

2 cos ( 8 π 9 ) + 2 cos ( 6 π 9 ) + 2 cos ( 4 π 9 ) + 2 cos ( 2 π 9 ) = 1 2\cos\left(\frac{8\pi}9 \right) + 2\cos\left(\frac{6\pi}9 \right) + 2\cos\left(\frac{4\pi}9 \right) + 2\cos\left(\frac{2\pi}9 \right) = - 1

And finally

cos ( π 9 ) + cos ( 3 π 9 ) + cos ( 5 π 9 ) + cos ( 7 π 9 ) = 1 2 \cos\left(\frac{\pi}9 \right) + \cos\left(\frac{3\pi}9 \right) + \cos\left(\frac{5\pi}9 \right) + \cos\left(\frac{7\pi}9 \right) = \frac12

Equivalently,

cos ( 2 0 ) + cos ( 6 0 ) + cos ( 10 0 ) + cos ( 14 0 ) = 1 2 ( ) \cos(20^\circ) + \cos(60^\circ) + \cos(100^\circ) + \cos(140^\circ) = \frac12 \qquad (\ast\ast)

This suggests that x = 3 0 x = \boxed{30^\circ} .

Moderator note:

You have showed that x = 30 x = 30 is a solution. Why is it the unique solution?

ChallengeMaster: Because no other 0 < x < 9 0 0^\circ<x^\circ<90^\circ satisfy the penultimate equation.

Pi Han Goh - 5 years, 10 months ago

Log in to reply

That was not stated, nor is it obvious.

Calvin Lin Staff - 5 years, 10 months ago

Log in to reply

Added a disclaimer at the top: stating that this solution is incomplete.

Pi Han Goh - 5 years, 10 months ago

0 pending reports

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...