+ F S O I R T T X T E E T Y N N Y Solve the above cryptarithm given than each letter represent distinct single non-negative integers.
Enter your answer as F O R T Y + T E N + S I X T Y .
This section requires Javascript.
You are seeing this because something didn't load right. We suggest you, (a) try
refreshing the page, (b) enabling javascript if it is disabled on your browser and,
finally, (c)
loading the
non-javascript version of this page
. We're sorry about the hassle.
When writing a solution, it would be helpful to break it up into paragraphs so that the reader can easily follow what you are doing at each step.
@Calvin Lin sir,i have edited the solution according to my understanding.Could you please tell if it is better now?and suggest some changes?
Log in to reply
Yes, this is indeed much better now. It is easier (for someone who doesn't know how to solve the problem) to get an overview of what you are trying to do, and then follow down the details.
Log in to reply
So,sir now could you please change the feedback which you gave and comment about how the solution was?and suggest ways of improving it in the feedback section.
Same solution. It is quite obvious that N = 0 and E = 5 and the rest is very well explained.
You say that if T<7 it would not work therefore T=8, but you have not shown why T isn't 7?
Log in to reply
if t=7 then the digits s and x are getting repeated ......... 29876+750+750 = 31376
Log in to reply
Check your arithmetic. What should the sum be?
N = I but each digit should be distinct
The creator of this problem is a charlatan. It says each digit is distinct. But the answer has repeated digits. !!!
Log in to reply
It says "Each letter represents a distinct digit".
It does not say "The answer of forty+ten+sixty has distinct digits".
Please be respectful of the community. Calling someone a charlatan is a personal attack. You could have phrased it as "The problem says each digit is distinct, but the answer has repeated digits!", which doesn't insult the person.
Log in to reply
Please don't try to defend the u defendable. Both letters Y and T represent the digit 2. So no, they are not distinct !!!
Log in to reply
@DarkMind S. – I'm not sure what you mean by "both letters Y and T represent the digit 2". If you read the solution, Y = 6 and T = 8 .
Log in to reply
@Calvin Lin – @Calvin Lin , Uhhhhhh, the solution is 62122 ! . Problems reading ?
Log in to reply
@DarkMind S. – Note that the solution is not saying F O R T Y = 6 2 1 2 2 .
If you read the solution, you will see that F = 2 , O = 9 , R = 7 , T = 8 , Y = 6 , E = 5 , N = 0 , S = 3 , I = 1 , X = 4 . This gives us the answer that F O R T Y + T E N + S I X T Y = 2 9 7 8 6 + 8 5 0 + 3 1 4 8 6 = 6 2 1 2 2 . The answer of forty+ten+sixty could have repeated digits, even though the letters represent distinct digits.
This solutions deduces letters in the order N, E, O, I, T, R, X, F, S and Y
Please scroll for the final solution
FINDING N AND E
The two Ns in the units column must add to 0 so that the final result is equal to Y
This means that N can be either 5 or 0
By the same logic, E+E=0 (mod 10)
If N were 5, a 1 would be carried over, making it impossible for the two Es to add up to 0 (mod 10)
Therefore, N=0 must be true
And thus E=5
FINDING O AND I
O and I cannot be distinct without having numbers carried over from the previous summation
Likewise F and S
The maximum that can be carried over from the hundreds to thousands column is a 2
If a 1 was carried over, O=9 to carry over a unit to the 10000s - however, this renders I as 0
But N=0
Therefore a 2 must be carried over
For a 1 to be carried over to the final column O>8
Again, if O=8 then I=0 which cannot be true
Thus O=9
And therefore I=1
FINDING T
We have already shown that a 2 must be carried over from R+T+T
We can also see that a 1 must be carried over from 5+5+T (no numbers are carried from the previous 0+0+Y)
Therefore R+T+T+1>20
The maximum value of R+T+T+1 is 24 (T=8, R=7)
and the minimum value is 22 (we have to exclude 21 and 20 as I=1 and N=0)
and R+T+T+1 = 22 or 23 or 24
If T=6 the maximum value of R+T+T+1=21, therefore T=7 or T=8
However, also note that F+1=S, meaning we need two consecutive numbers for F and S
If T=7 then R=8 and X=3
The numbers remaining consist of 2, 4 and 6, none of which are consecutive - thus, T cannot equal 7
Leaving only T=8
FINDING R and X
Since T=8 and R+T+T+1 = 22 or 23 or 24
Leaving R = 5 or 6 or 7
Since E=5, R = 6 or 7
As F and S are consecutive numbers, from the remaining numbers F=2 and S=3 OR F=3 and S=4
Thus, no other letter can represent 3, otherwise F and S cannot be consecutive
We can see that if R=6 then R+T+T+1=23, thus X=3 which is not possible
By elimination, R=7
Now R+T+T+1=24 therefore X=4
FINDING F AND S AND Y
The remaining digits are 2, 3 and 6
Since F+1=S, F=2 and S=3
Finally, Y=6
FINAL ANSWER
F=2, O=9, R=7, T=8, Y=6, E=5, N=0, S=3, I=1, X=4
FORTY = 29876 TEN = 850 SIXTY = 31486
FORTY + TEN + SIXTY = 29876 + 850 + 31486 = 62212
'Distinct' integers usually means different from each other. 'I' 'T' and 'Y' are all '2' Your maths is obviously better than your English!!
Log in to reply
Note that 62212 doesn't correspond to S I X T Y , Tim. It's the sum of F O R T Y , T E N and S I X T Y .
This one was tough, but I got there by brute force and ignorance!
Because Y + 2N = Y plus a carryover of 0 or 1, N must be 0 or 5. However, if N = 5, then T + 2E +1 cannot equal T plus a carryover. Therefore N = 0, and by the same logic, E = 5.
Now consider the first three columns. We know that the second column must generate a carryover in order for F < S, and similarly for O < I - so S = F +1.
Because N = 0, there is only one case that would provide a carryover for the first column, and that is O = 9 and I = 1. That means that R + 2T + 1 (the carryover from column 4) > 21 to provide a carryover of two.
There are three cases that meet this criterion - R = 6, T = 8; R = 7, T = 8; and R = 8, T = 7.
However, because F or S must = 3, the only valid case is R = 7, T = 8, and thus X = 4.
By elimination, F = 2, S = 3 and Y = 6.
The final sum is therefore 29786 + 850 + 31486 = 62122
FORTY is 19874; TEN is 750; SIXTY is 21374; ( 19874 + 750 + 750 = 21374) So my answer is FORTY + TEN + SIXTY = 41 998 Gheorghe Bejan
Log in to reply
You have F = 1 and I = 1. Each digit must be an unique non-negative integer.
Step 1. E + E (+carry) and N + N must be 0 mod 10 to allow the T and Y to come down to the sum.
With matching digits there are only two possibilities, 0 and 5.
The carry from N + N is at most 1.
For any choice of E, E + E + 1 is odd and not 0 mod 10.
Therefore there can be no carry from N + N thus N = 0 and E = 5 is forced.
Step 2. At the other end, F and O must have a carry coming in to make distinct digits in the sum.
The only choice is O = 9 and I = 1 with a carry of 2.
( 8 with carry 2, or 9 with carry 1 would have I=0 duplicating N.)
Step 3. The carry to F is limited to 1. Thus S = F+1, that is, F and S are consecutive digits.
looking at the digits used so far only 2,3,4, and 6,7,8 remain available to provide consecutive digits.
Step 4. The sum R + T + T must produce a carry of 2 for O and I to work.
That means that both values must come from the 6-8 range
and the consecutive F,S must come from the 2-4 range.
Step 5. Evaluate X for each choice of R and T.
R = 7 and T = 8 work, with a carry of 1 add up to 24, X= 4.
(the others either duplicate a digit in X, or take out 3 leaving no consecutive digits for F and S.)
Thus X = 4, F = 2 and S=3.
Step 6. This puzzle has ten digits, all distinct, nine have been solved leaving only 6 for Y.
Matching the ten characters FORTY, EN, SIX into {0, 1, 2,....9}
Digit | Chars | Note |
0 | N | If N=5 then 2E+1 cannot equals to 10 |
5 | E | trivial |
Digit | Chars | Note |
0 | N | |
5 | E | |
9 | O | Since 0 is occupied and (R+T+T+1) <30; O > 8 |
1 | I | consequence result of O=9 |
we know S = F+1 and remaining (2,3,4) and (6,7,8)
S,F should be in (2,3,4) as we need two elements in (6,7,8) for (R+T+T) >= 20
3 must be used by (S,F), hence R+T+T+1 = 22 or 24 ; X=2 or 4
Digit | Chars | Note |
0 | N | |
5 | E | |
9 | O | |
1 | I | |
7 | R | R+2T=21 or 23 => R is odd in (6,7,8) |
8 | T | consequence result of R=7 |
4 | X | 7+8+8+1=24 |
2 | F | F+1=S in (2,3) |
3 | S | |
6 | Y | remaining number |
I cheated and wrote a quick Python program to just check all possible combinations until one with each digit being an unique non-negative integer yielded a solution. Took about 0.3 sec machine time with very sloppy code. Turing and Bletchley Park live on!
Problem Loading...
Note Loading...
Set Loading...
N: We see that N + N needs to end in 0 hence it can either be 0 or 5 . If N = 5 , then the 1 that would be carried over would be added to the T + E + E column.Then E + E + 1 would have to end in 0 but we know that that can't happen, hence N = 0 .
E: Since N = 0 , thus E = 5 as E + E also needs to end in 0 but we know that every digit is distinct.Hence we have found two of the digits.
O:Now,when we add 5 + 5 + T ,there would be a carry over of 1 .Now,we see that O = I ,hence there has to be some carry over when we calculate 1 + R + T + T ,it can either be 2 X OR 1 X ,assuming it to be 1 X ,then O + 1 = 1 I as F = S hence it can only be F + 1 = S as 2 can't be carried over.But the max. value of O + 1 = 1 0 hence I = 0 but that is not possible as the numbers are distinct.So, 1 + R + T + T = 2 X hence 2 would be carried to O hence O + 2 = 1 I ,as O = 8 , O = 9 hence, I = 1 ( 9 + 2 = 1 1 ) .Now,the sum becomes, F 9 R T Y + T 5 0 + T 5 0 = S 1 X T Y
T:Now,we had that, 1 + R + T + T = 2 X ,now we observe that their max. value can be 8 + 8 + 7 + 1 = 2 4 as T = 8 ,and their least possible value is 2 1 as X = 0 hence 1 + R + T + T can be 2 1 , 2 2 , 2 3 , 2 4 ,we have to exclude 2 1 as 1 has already been used.So we are left with 2 2 , 2 3 , 2 4 ,now if T < 7 ,then the max value of our sum would be 2 1 hence we have that T = 8 . Rest of the digits:Hence we have used up the digits, 0 , 1 , 5 , 8 , 9 and F + 1 = S now, S = 0 , 5 , 9 , 1 , 8 , 2 , 6 hence we have that S = 3 , 4 , 7 .Now,digits that are left should for F and S ,need to have two consecutive digits,this only takes place when R = 7 and the two consecutive digits left would be 2 , 3 and hence Y = 6 .Hence we have found all the digits.And done!
Summarizing the above, the only solution set is F = 2 , O = 9 , R = 7 , T = 8 , Y = 6 , E = 5 , N = 0 , S = 3 , I = 1 , X = 4 .